Assessing the Importance of Client Culture and Ethnicity When
Planning, Providing and Evaluating Care
Madeleine Leininger was a nursing professor, theorist and
anthropologist who is now considered to be the leader in terms of
transcultural nursing.
Madeleine Leininger's work relating to cultural care began in
the 1950s, and she published her book "Culture Care Diversity and
Universality: A Theory of Nursing" in 1991. Madeleine Leininger,
herself, states that her theory is the only existing theory that
"searches for comprehensive and holistic care data relying on
social structure, worldview, and multiple factors in a culture in
order to get a holistic knowledge base about care" (Leininger,
2006, p. 219)
The purpose of transcultural nursing research is to study
cultures in order to better understand both the similarities and
the differences among patient groups and cultures. Culture is a set
of established beliefs that are held by a certain group of people
that has been handed down from generation to generation and not
held and shared by other groups or the members of other groups.
These beliefs, values and perceptions are unique to the particular
culture.
Nurses' practice must incorporate cultural needs and beliefs
into their nursing practice to provide care that is individualized
for the client and appropriate to the client's needs. During the
assessment phase of the nursing process, the nurse assesses the
client's and family member's cultural background, preferences and
needs, after which the nurse modifies the plan of care
accordingly.
This cultural assessment and culturally oriented care enables
the nurse to:
- Identify ways with which the client's culture and its features
impact on their perceptions, beliefs, values, experiences with
health, wellness, illness, suffering, and even death
- Remain accepting, respectful and welcoming of human
diversity
- Facilitate more holistic assessments and plans of care as based
on the client's culture
- Deep and strengthen their commitment to nursing and their
insight into the nursing profession as based on culturally based
nurse-patient relationships which emphasize the importance of the
whole person rather than viewing the patient as simply a set of
symptoms or an illness
- Integrate their full and in depth cultural knowledge into the
treatment of patients
- Develop and integrate open mindedness into nursing care which
can lead to some innovative, non-traditional, alternative nursing
interventions such as spiritually based therapies like meditation
and anointing.
In the Transcultural Nursing Theory, nurses have a
responsibility to understand the role of culture in the health of
the patient. Not only can a cultural background influence a
patient's health, but the patient may be taking culturally driven
home remedies that can affect his or her health, as well.
Leininger proposes that care is the dominant, unifying and
distinctive essence of nursing. Caring, a universal phenomenon is
primarily culturally driven as based on the variations among
cultures in reference to their process, patterns and
expressions.
Madeleine Leininger's theoretical thoughts also support three
nursing modes of intervention that are necessary in order for
nurses to care for, and assist, people of diverse cultures. These
three nursing modes are:
- Cultural preservation and maintenance
- Cultural care negation and accommodation
- Cultural care repatterning and restructuring
In today's health care field, nurses and other health care
providers have the professional responsibility to be sensitive to
their clients' cultural backgrounds. This sensitivity is particular
important and vital to the quality of care because culture is so
integral and intrinsic to who the client is as a unique individual.
Culture can greatly affect client health, as well as their
reactions to treatments and care. Madeleine Leininger's
Transcultural Nursing Theory facilitates the nurses' understanding
of why and how the patient's cultural background is important to
health.
Recognizing Cultural Issues That May Impact on the Client's
Understanding of and Acceptance of a Psychiatric Diagnosis
Cultural issues that may impact on the client's understanding
and acceptance of a psychiatric mental health disorder and
diagnosis are numerous and varied. For example, these cultural
beliefs, values and practices can impact on the client's
understanding and acceptance of a psychiatric mental health
disorder and diagnosis among various cultures:
- The meaning of the mental disorder or illness to the client and
their family members: The meaning of a psychiatric mental health
disorder can be viewed as imaginary or it can be viewed as real;
some can view these psychiatric mental health illnesses as a
disorder of the mind, or the body, or both; and still more may view
these illnesses as a stigma which promotes shame that at times can
be quite severe and other cultures view these illnesses like all
other kinds of illnesses. Based on these views, different
strategies and interventions are planned and implemented to
accommodate for these various culture bound perceptions for the
client and their significant others.
- The way with which the client relates their symptoms to the
health care provider: Some cultures state that they are
experiencing somatic and physical symptoms rather than emotional
symptoms such as anxiety and distress. For example, clients with an
Asian culture may have somatic complaints rather than complaints
relating to their mental health. It is, therefore, necessary that
health care providers are cognizant of the fact that some
subjective data given by the client during the assessment may be
culturally driven and without any data about their psychiatric
mental health signs and symptoms when indeed the client is
adversely affected with a mental health disorder.
- Culture also impacts on the ways which some cultures cope with
stress: Some cultures cope with stress by openly expressing their
feelings; other cultures avoid thinking about and expressing their
feelings when confronted with stress. These cultures suppress their
feelings. For example, members of the Asian culture tend to
suppress their feelings and discussions about their true feelings
rather than expressing their feelings; and, on the other hand,
African Americans actively confront their stress and, more often
than other cultural groups, they tend to resolve their stress and
distress on their own, often drawing on spiritual influences to
assist them during stressful times.
- Whether or not treatment is sought for a psychiatric mental
health disorder: Research indicates that minority groups within the
United States are less likely to seek treatment for a mental health
disorder than Caucasians in this nation. They are also more likely
to delay getting treatment than whites.
- The kind of help that is elicited when help is sought for a
psychiatric mental health disorder: Research indicates that
minority groups within the United States are more likely to seek
treatment for a mental health disorder with their primary care
physician and non health care related informal resources such as a
member of the clergy, culturally based nontraditional "healers",
rather than a mental health professional, when compared and
contrasted to American Caucasians. For example, American Indians
and Eskimos, for example, may tend to seek the help of a
traditional healer such as a medicine man.
It must also be noted that psychiatric mental health
professionals, including nurses, are affected and impacted by their
own cultural beliefs, values and practices. It is, therefore,
necessary that all health care providers eliminate their cultural
biases towards clients with mental disorders and all other
disorders and diseases; therefore, the nurse must recognize their
own cultural biases and then overcome them with a full
understanding, acceptance and respect for all clients regardless of
their own integral cultural practices, values, beliefs and
perceptions.
Incorporating the Client's Cultural Practices and Beliefs When
Planning and Providing Care
In addition to the cultural practices and beliefs that were
discussed immediately above this section, culture also impacts on
other areas of the client-nurse relationships. Some of these
cultural influences include:
- General Perceptions Relating to Illness and
Health: Some cultures place a high value on health, health
promotion and wellness and others do not. Some cultures believe
that illness is stigmatic and outside of any control by the members
of the culture. Still more may have culturally bound rituals and
practices to promote health, to prevent illness, and to cure
disease.
- Distance and Space Orientation: Space and
distance orientation and tolerance for closed and open spaces may
also vary among cultures. For example, research indicates that
cultures that live in crowded areas, such as in heavily populated
city, are more tolerant of closeness and proximity to others when
compared to members of other cultures who are not tolerant to
closeness, but instead, prefer to be in and live in less crowded
and congested areas. This distance and space tolerance may
influence and impact on a client's tolerance of crowded areas and
being in close proximity to others as they are when they are in a
hospital.
- Family Dynamics: The size of the family unit,
family member roles, internal family dynamics, power and decision
maker powers, interpersonal interactions within the family, among
members of the family, and with others outside of the family unit,
and communication patterns within the family unit often vary
according to one's culture. For example, some families have top to
bottom communication patterns where the leaders communicate with
the followers in the family unit and not from the bottom up from
the children to the authority figures; some families are
paternalistic with the male as the predominant figure of the family
unit, others can be maternalistic and still more may share power
equally in the family unit; some families and cultures value and
honor their elders and others do not to the same extent; and still
more culturally bound dynamics can include who makes the decisions
and decision making. For example, some families elicit and seek out
the help and support of those outside of the family unit to aid
their decision making and others restrict discussions and decision
making to only one person, only the nuclear family members, or only
the members of the extended family in collaboration with the
nuclear family.
- Self Efficacy: Simply defined, self efficacy
is the personal belief that one has the ability and capability to
do something successfully. Cultures and members of cultures who
hold the belief that they have self efficacy will be motivated to
learn, they will be motivated to participate in their care, and
they will also be motivated to change behaviors; on the other hand,
cultures and members of cultures who hold the belief that they do
not have the ability and capability to be successful will not be
motivated to learn, they will be motivated to participate in their
care, or be motivated to change behaviors when they lack self
efficacy. These clients will be less likely to actively participate
in their care and care decisions; they will depend on others,
including health care professionals to make these decisions for
them.
- Communication Patterns: As fully discussed in
the beginning of this review under the integrated process of
"Communication and Documentation", verbal and nonverbal
communication patterns and elements, such as terminology, silence,
eye contact, choice of vocabulary, facial expressions, and touch,
are impacted by different cultures.
- Time Orientation: Some cultures focus more on
the past than on the present or future; other cultures place an
emphasis on the present, rather than the past or future; and sill
more focus on the future rather than the past or present. This
perspective and focus impacts on the client and their perspectives.
For example, a client who focuses on the future will more likely be
committed to sacrifice in the present to better insure a healthy
future; and those with a focus on the past and the current time may
not be as focused on the future by maintaining healthy life styles
and participating in health and wellness activities and
programs.
Culture is integral to the person as a unique individual. It
impacts greatly on the client's health, and their reactions to
treatments and care. Cultural beliefs, perspectives, values and
practices are determined and assessed by the nurse, after which
they are then integrated into the planning, implementation and
evaluation of client care. All aspects of the direct and indirect
care of the client is modified and changed according to the
client's culture and cultural background. Additionally, all these
cultural modifications must be documented as all other aspects of
nursing care are.
Respecting the Cultural Background and Practices of the
Client
Like religious and spiritual beliefs, nurses remain respectful
and accepting of all cultural beliefs, practices and perspectives,
regardless of those that the nurse possesses. They must,
additionally, overcome their own cultural biases by recognizing
that they have them and then detaching from them as they plan and
render client care to clients from diverse cultures.
Using Appropriate Interpreters to Assist in Achieving Client
Understanding
As previously mentioned in the "Integrated Process:
Communication and Documentation" and the "Integrated Process:
Teaching and Learning", interpreters and other aids such as large
print and Braille reading materials, are used to facilitate the
client's understanding of their health care status, their care and
their treatments.
Although at first glance a nurse may think of only a foreign
language interpreter for those who do not have English as their
primary language, it should not be forgotten that American Sign
Language interpreters should, and can, be used among those clients
who cannot gain their understanding of their health care status,
their care and their treatments when the client is adversely
affected with an auditory impairment.
Evaluating and Documenting How the Client Language Needs Were
Met
Interpreters and the use of instructional materials in multiple
languages often have to be used in order to accommodate for the
clients' language barriers. These accommodations, like all other
accommodations and modifications of care, are thoroughly
documented.
The most effective way to decide whether or not the client
language needs were met is to assess whether or not the client has
gained an understanding and insight into their health care status,
their care and their treatments.
Documentation in the medical record should include the client's
level of comprehension, or lack thereof, and the modifications that
were used to facilitate this comprehension using an interpreter
and/or appropriate reading material
2. Maternal chronic medical conditions, infectious diseases,
psychiatric conditions, parental and environmental exposures, and
psychosocial stressors have an established impact on fetal and
neonatal health. Although countless studies have shown
relationships between maternal risk factors and low-birth weight,
pre-term birth, and fetal and infant morbidity (e.g. reduced apgar
scores), fewer have demonstrated direct associations with fetal and
infant death.
pre-term birth, low birth weight, obesity, diabetes,
hypertension, alcohol, tobacco, HIV, rural residence, race, and
psychosocial stressors.