Question

In: Operations Management

Some argue that the traditional role of managers and bureaucratic control systems are in conflict with...

Some argue that the traditional role of managers and bureaucratic control systems are in conflict with the principles and processes of self-management and self-designing teams. It has been suggested that managers need to change to be more like coaches in order for such agile teams to be effective. Attack or defend this idea and support your position.

Solutions

Expert Solution

I support the statement, that in Agile Methodology the managers need to play the role of Scrum Coach or Agile coach and the responsibility of such role will be to maintain the Agile methodology throughout the team so that the team does not deviates from the Agile structure. I believe that this Role is given to individuals who have a sound knowledge of working in Agile environment or teams and is aware of the details of how to work in Agile. the traditional managerial roles are getting obsolete with time and managers today are playing the technocrat role where they have both business and technical objectives and have to be effective in their new role as technical managers. Scrum master in Agile can also be a manager who will ensure that tasks are in progress with the expectation of the goals and objectives of the sprint.

I believe that the idea of Agile has changed the concept of managers to quite an extent and has helped organizations use the role effectively for the betterment of organizations.


Related Solutions

What are the main advantages of contemporary control systems over traditional control systems? What are the...
What are the main advantages of contemporary control systems over traditional control systems? What are the main differences between these two systems?
It has been argued that bureaucratic control systems are a holdover from a time when businesses,...
It has been argued that bureaucratic control systems are a holdover from a time when businesses, products, technologies, and society itself ran, and changed, at a far slower pace than it does today. Due to the rapid growth of global competition, the acceleration of technological change, and the growing interconnectedness of individuals some believe that bureaucracies should be replaced by more agile and dynamic mechanisms. For example, statistical process control, one of a number of tools and methods W. Edwards...
Management accounting systems tend to parallel the manufacturing systems they support and control. Traditional manufacturing systems...
Management accounting systems tend to parallel the manufacturing systems they support and control. Traditional manufacturing systems emphasized productivity (average output per hour or per employee) and cost. This was the result of a competitive philosophy that was based on mass producing a few standard products and "meeting or beating competitors on price." If a firm is going to compete on price, it had better be a low-cost producer. Firms achieved low unit cost for fixed sets of resources by maximizing...
What role does communication play in workplace conflict and what are some strategies for reducing conflict?
Conflict between employees or between employee and supervisor exists in many organizations.  What role does communication play in workplace conflict and what are some strategies for reducing conflict?  
An organization that is managed in a traditional and bureaucratic way will find itself stagnant, dysfunctional,...
An organization that is managed in a traditional and bureaucratic way will find itself stagnant, dysfunctional, and unable to adapt to its environment. Write a short essay that explains people change and culture change, and evaluate why they are necessary to achieve the change process. Be sure to include a detailed example of each in your answer.
How can communication be improved in an organization that is structured in a traditional bureaucratic form?...
How can communication be improved in an organization that is structured in a traditional bureaucratic form? How might computerized communication be utilized to improve the effectiveness of communication in a bureaucratic organization?
What role do third parties play in conflict resolution? What problem does Walter argue that they...
What role do third parties play in conflict resolution? What problem does Walter argue that they solve? Driscoll argues that third parties face their own problems in solving conflict. What are those challenges? How do local actors abuse them? Is it possible for Walter and Driscoll to both be right in different places? Which places are best for each theory?
Some argue that the Anglo-American separation of ownership and control is an inevitable outcome in corporate...
Some argue that the Anglo-American separation of ownership and control is an inevitable outcome in corporate governance. Others contend that this is one variant (among several) on how large firms can be effectively governed and that it is not necessarily the most efficient form. What do you think?
Compare and contrast the Traditional View of Conflict, the Human Relations View of Conflict and the...
Compare and contrast the Traditional View of Conflict, the Human Relations View of Conflict and the Interactionist Perspective of Conflict
Some systems analysts argue, “Give users what they ask for. If they want lots of reports...
Some systems analysts argue, “Give users what they ask for. If they want lots of reports and reams of data, then that is what you should provide. Otherwise, they will feel that you are trying to tell them how to do their jobs.” Others say, “Systems analysts should let users know what information can be obtained from the system. If you listen to users, you’ll never get anywhere because they really don’t know what they want and don’t understand information...
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT