Question

In: Mechanical Engineering

Ethics in Engineering For each of the following five (5) scenarios, state briefly ‘what you would...

Ethics in Engineering

For each of the following five (5) scenarios, state briefly ‘what you would have done’ from an ethics perspective:

d) Dissent about quality

Discuss the ethical issue this case raises.

Dissent about quality

I

A recent graduate of Engineering Tech, Bernie Reston has been employed in the Research and Development (R&D) Chemical Engineering Division of Larom, Inc. for the past several months. Bernie was recommended to Larom as the top Engineering Tech graduate in chemical engineering.

Alex Smith, the head of Bernie's unit, showed immediate interest in Bernie's research on processes using a particular catalyst (call it B). However, until last week, his work assignments at Larom were in other areas.

A meeting of engineers in Bernie's unit is called by Alex. He announces that the unit must make a recommendation within the next two days on what catalyst should be used by Larom in processing a major product. It is clear to everyone that Alex is anticipating a brief, decisive meeting. One of the senior engineers volunteers, "We've been working on projects like this for years, and catalyst A seems to be the obvious choice." Several others immediately concur. Alex looks around the room and, hearing no further comments, says, "Well, it looks like we're in accord on this. Do we have consensus?"

So far Bernie has said nothing. He is not sure what further testing will show, but the testing he has been doing for the past week provides preliminary evidence that catalyst B may actually be best for this process. This is also in line with what his research at Engineering Tech suggested with somewhat similar processes. If catalyst B should turn out to be preferable, a great deal of money will be saved; and, in the long run, a fair amount of time will be saved as well. Should he mention his findings at this time, or should he simply defer to the senior engineers, who seem as determined as Alex to bring matters to closure?

II

Bernie somewhat hesitantly raises his hand. He briefly explains his test results and the advantages catalyst B might provide. Then he suggests that the unit might want to delay its recommendation for another two weeks so that he can conduct further tests.

Alex replies, "We don't have two weeks. We have two days." He then asks Bernie to write up the report, leaving out the preliminary data he has gathered about catalyst B. He says, "It would be nice to do some more testing, but we just don't have the time. Besides, I doubt if anything would show up in the next two weeks to change our minds. This is one of those times we have to be decisive--and we have to look decisive and quit beating around the bush. They're really getting impatient on this one. Anyway, we've had a lot of experience in this area."

Bernie replies that, even if the data on B is left out, the data on A is hardly conclusive. Alex replies, "Look you're a bright person. You can make the numbers look good without much difficulty--do the math backwards if you have to. Just get the report done in the next two days!"

Bernie likes working for Larom, and he feels lucky to have landed such a good job right out of Engineering Tech. He is also due for a significant pay raise soon if he plays his cards right.

What do you think Bernie should do? Explain your choice.

  1. Write up the report as Alex says.
  2. Refuse to write up the report, saying he will have no part in falsifying a report.
  3. Other.

III

[Following II. 1.]

Bernie decides to write up the report. When he is finished, Alex asks him to sign it. Bernie now has second thoughts. He wonders if he should sign his name to a report that omits his preliminary research on catalyst B. Should he sign it?

IV

Bernie has now had more time to do research on catalyst B. After several weeks his research quite decisively indicates that, contrary to the expectations of Alex and the other more experienced engineers in the unit, catalyst B really would have been, far and away, the better choice. What should Bernie do now?

  1. Keep the data to himself--don't make trouble.
  2. Tell Alex and let him decide what, if anything, to do.
  3. Other.

V

Bernie decides to say nothing. Although Larom has lost a lot of money by investing in an inferior catalyst, it is quite possible that this is the end of the matter for Bernie. The customer never complains, and no one outside at Larom raises any questions. However, it might go otherwise. Suppose a Larom competitor discovers that catalyst B is better for this type of work and it begins receiving contracts that Larom would normally be awarded. Further, what if Alex's superior then makes an inquiry into why his unit has missed out on this development?

VI

[Following II. 3.]

Bernie tries to convince Alex that a straightforward report should be submitted. Since there is a virtual consensus in the unit that catalyst A is best, A can be recommended. But the preliminary evidence about B can also be mentioned. After all, Bernie suggests, if the entire unit is convinced that A is best despite the preliminary evidence about B, why wouldn't those outside the unit be persuaded by the received wisdom of the unit? If they aren't persuaded, perhaps they will grant the unit more time to continue the research on B.

Somewhat to his surprise, Bernie finds Alex and the others receptive to his suggestion. The preliminary evidence about catalyst B is included in the report, even though A is recommended.

Unfortunately, Alex's superiors are very upset with the recommendation. They are unwilling to go ahead with the project without further testing, but they bitterly complain that the further delay will be very costly. Alex is severely criticised for not having a more convincing set of data. He, in turn, blames his staff, especially Bernie, the new specialist in this area. Bernie, Alex tells his superiors, failed to complete the necessary testing in a timely fashion. Alex tells his superiors that he should have supervised Bernie's work more closely, and he assures them that he will not let matters get out of control again. Although Bernie is not fired, he is not promoted and his salary is frozen for another year. What should he do?

  1. Nothing. No good will come from complaining.
  2. Confront Alex, telling him what you think of what he has done, but carrying it no further.
  3. Other.

VII

Bernie decides he has nothing to gain from complaining to Alex or anyone else about becoming the "scapegoat" of the project. So, he keeps quiet. Sometime later, Alex is being considered for promotion to another division. Members of Bernie's unit are privately interviewed about his performance in the unit. Bernie is told that his comments will be kept confidential. What should he say in his interview?

VIII

Bernie says nothing negative about Alex in the interview. None of the others in the unit do either. Alex is promoted to another division. However, a year later it is discovered that he has directed someone in his new division to falsify data for reasons very similar to those in Bernie's original situation. The new person does what Alex asks. The result is a significant loss of money to Larom--only this time there is an expensive product-liability lawsuit relating to an unsafe Larom product. An inquiry takes place. The person who has falsified the report says that Alex has often requested that data be falsified--and that he typically has gotten young engineers to do the "dirty work" for him. So, it comes back to Bernie. He is asked why he didn't report Alex's orders to falsify data when the matter first came up. Bernie is accused of being partly responsible for allowing Alex to be promoted--with the resulting harm to others and loss of money and reputation to Larom.

Solutions

Expert Solution

,


Related Solutions

Consider each of the following scenarios and think what you would you do in each situation:...
Consider each of the following scenarios and think what you would you do in each situation: Scenario 1 Blackburn Holdings is an IT organization of 50 workers. As manager you are required to organize training and ongoing support for all employees about current privacy legislation   related to the IT industry. Scenario 2 United Healthcare is a health care provider with over 1,500 workers on four different sites. It has introduced a new detailed email policy for all workers. As manager,...
In each of the following scenarios, state whether the labor supply curve would shift to the...
In each of the following scenarios, state whether the labor supply curve would shift to the left, to the right, not shift at all, or if the shift is ambiguous because there is more than one effect and they would move the curve in opposite directions. (a) The stock market rises sharply. (b) Fewer teenagers work while in school than before. (c) A large fraction of the population flees the country because of a bird flu epidemic. (d) The expected...
For this assignment, in each of the following five scenarios, indicate whether you consider the following...
For this assignment, in each of the following five scenarios, indicate whether you consider the following individual's behavior to be normal or abnormal. After deciding if the individual's behavior is normal or abnormal, defend your response by referencing the "4 D's" 1) A person drinks approximately three beers and three shots of liquor per day and sometimes has trouble remembering daily events in his life. 2) You see your neighbor trim his hedges with a pair of scissors and scrub...
For each of the following scenarios, state whether there is or is not a contract, and...
For each of the following scenarios, state whether there is or is not a contract, and why: 1. Bob and Mary were talking at a bar on Thursday night. Bob wrote the following on coaster and handed it to Mary: “I promise to pay you $1,000 to dance with man at the bar in the Gray Shirt” Mary read the coaster, signed it, and danced with the man in the gray shirt. 2. Mr. Wilson said to 18 year old...
Case Studies: For each of the following scenarios, give a brief explanation of what you would...
Case Studies: For each of the following scenarios, give a brief explanation of what you would suggest, and why. You are working as a Nurse at a rural high school and have been asked to assess the body composition and overall health of the students. What specific body composition assessment technique would you use (consider price, ease of use, etc…)? Make sure you explain why you would choose this technique. (3 pts) You have been asked to give a presentation...
5.8  What’s wrong? State what is wrong in each of the following scenarios. (a) A parameter...
5.8  What’s wrong? State what is wrong in each of the following scenarios. (a) A parameter describes a sample. (b) Bias and variability are two names for the same thing. (c) Large samples are always better than small samples. (d) A sampling distribution is something generated by a computer.
Consider the market for coffee. For each of the following scenarios, what would happen to total...
Consider the market for coffee. For each of the following scenarios, what would happen to total revenue after the price increases? Place each scenario in the correct category. Items (5 items) (Drag and drop into the appropriate area below) Coffee drinkers say there is no substitute. Coffee drinkers decide to save their money for alcohol on Friday nights. Leaf rust damages one-third of the world's coffee crop. Brazil has a drought. Coffee drinkers discover a flavor of tea that tastes...
(5%) For each of the following data series, state what type of data you are dealing...
(5%) For each of the following data series, state what type of data you are dealing with and which type of graph (from the list below) would be best (the most effective way) to describe the data. Column (bar) chart Line chart Pie chart Box-plot Histogram Data series: Need to answer what type of data and use which type of graph 1. The number of years since a person immigrated to Canada. These are individual level data collected as part...
For each of the following scenarios, (a) state the study design, (b) calculate the risk of...
For each of the following scenarios, (a) state the study design, (b) calculate the risk of the outcome among the exposed relative to the unexposed being sure to use the appropriate measure of risk, and (c) interpret your findings in a full sentence in the context of the study. Hint: First, identify the exposure and outcome.  Then, set up the 2x2 table and calculate the risk. The incidence rate of stomach cancer in a population of middle-aged men who smoke is...
Which elements of the marketing communications mix would you employ for each of the following scenarios?...
Which elements of the marketing communications mix would you employ for each of the following scenarios? Explain your answers. A newly established hair salon in a suburban shopping center. An established restaurant facing declining patronage because of new competitors. A large, single-office accounting firm in a major city that serves primarily business clients.
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT