How do other methods of judicial selection, such as the merit selection system, address accountability and...

How do other methods of judicial selection, such as the merit selection system, address accountability and independence?

Expert Solution

Merit selection system means that the judges get selected by a nonpartisan commission of lawyers andnon-lawyers who nominate three highly qualified persons for the post of the judge and send it to the governer. The governer then has to choose one of the 3 people as the judge.

This results in independence as the selection process is free from partisan politics and can't be manipulated by politicians or executive. Since the peersons being nominated also dont need to file nomination, run on a platofrm, raise money etc., they remain free of influence from businessman, lobbyists etc.

But that does not mean that they have no accountability after becoming judges. After an initial term of office, judges are evaluated on the basis of their performance on the bench by a retention commission or by the voters in an uncontested retention election. Judicial performance is similarly re-evaluated for each subsequent term. This provides an opportunity toremove from office those who do not fulfill their judicial responsibilitie

Rahul Sunny answered 9 months ago

Compare and contrast the federal judicial system with California's judicial system in terms of how judges...

Compare and contrast the federal judicial system with California's judicial system in terms of how judges are selected, their length of service, and types of courts, and types of cases heard. Please be detailed so I can understand the subject better. I don't seem to understand these differences since I'm not very familiar with goverment structure, I've looked on the internet, so please don't just copy and paste. Thanks!

Which form of judicial selection do you think is best? What are the differences?

How do companies address climate change in their annual reports and other corporate documents? Are these...

How do companies address climate change in their annual reports and other corporate documents? Are these sources convincing to stakeholders?

1. Explain how judicial review is part of the checks and balance system. Explain how 1...

1. Explain how judicial review is part of the checks and balance system. Explain how 1 of the other branches checks and balances the judicial branch. 2. Explain the terms majority opinion, concurring opinion, and dissenting opinion. Who writes the opinion for each? 3. Explain the policy making process and explain all 5-6 steps of the policy making process. Give an example of any problem and take it through the steps.

How do diseases of the urinary system affect other body systems?

How do disruptive selection, directional selection, and stabilizing selection differ from one another?

What is a merit pay plan and how well do such plans generally hold up against...

What is a merit pay plan and how well do such plans generally hold up against the standard method of pay for employees? please attach a web reference (actual article, not just link) to support the claim.

Discuss the sympathetic and parasympatheric nervous system? How do they work together and support each other...

Discuss the sympathetic and parasympatheric nervous system? How do they work together and support each other ? please include refrences and citations.

How does selection, evocation, and/or manipulation influence prejudice, e.g. racism or sexism? (Address one or more...

How does selection, evocation, and/or manipulation influence prejudice, e.g. racism or sexism? (Address one or more of selection, evocation, and manipulation)

How is adverse selection mitigated in the US system of care? How might repealing the individual...

How is adverse selection mitigated in the US system of care? How might repealing the individual mandate affect adverse selection and insurance premiums? When it was passed, part of the goal of the ACA was to decrease health care costs in the United States. Discuss the ways in which costs might be reduced and the ways in which costs might actually increase as a result of ACA.

Question