Which form of judicial selection do you think is best? What are the differences?

Expert Solution

There are primarily two forms of judicial selection; election and appointment and other forms are combination of the two. People who favour election consider it to be in the spirit of democracy as the people will have a say in the third branch of governance and select their judicial representative. The second form is appointment and it also comes in various forms; in some systems the chief executive decides and appoints the judge. Generally, the judge is appointed on the basis of "merit selection". A commission identifies the well-qualified candidate and then afterwards the chief executive chooses a judge from the list of nominees.

In my opinion, both are effective ways and both are prone to just and fair judicial selection. Election seems a better form of selecting judges in a democracy because if the judges are chosen by people in power poistion then there is a possibility of system compromise and an unfair judicial system.

Hayet Jeridi answered 3 weeks ago

What do you think is the best / ideal form of taxation? How does the current...

What do you think is the best / ideal form of taxation? How does the current system in the US measure up to what you think the ideal system should be.

Explain the differences between Monetary Policy and Fiscal Policy? Which policy do you think is best...

Explain the differences between Monetary Policy and Fiscal Policy? Which policy do you think is best at stabilizing the economy during a recession or continue GDP decline?

How do other methods of judicial selection, such as the merit selection system, address accountability and...

How do other methods of judicial selection, such as the merit selection system, address accountability and independence?

What is the difference between group and individual selection? Do you think natural selection operates at...

What is the difference between group and individual selection? Do you think natural selection operates at the level of a group? Why? Why do some scientists think that is problematic? What is kin selection, and how is it expected to affect the persistence of cooperative traits? How does spatial structure affect the stability of cooperation?

What are the differences between work groups and teams? Which do you think is a better...

What are the differences between work groups and teams? Which do you think is a better concept for the workplace? How can we effectively work as a team in virtual spaces?

Which of the following statements best describes non-judicial foreclosure?

Which of the following statements best describes non-judicial foreclosure? When there is a "partnership" provision in the mortgage or trust deed document, a non-judicial foreclosure cannot proceed unless a circuit judge agrees with the lender. When there is a "sale requirement provision in the mortgage or trust deed document, a non-judicial foreclosure cannot proceed unless the borrower agrees. When there is a "power of sale" provision in the mortgage or trust deed document, a non-judicial foreclosure can force the sale of the lined...

Which diet do you think is the one which creates the best environment for your cells...

Which diet do you think is the one which creates the best environment for your cells so that they can function at their optimum level. Why? Tell me how the foods in the diet affect your cells, groups of cells, organs and glands so that they can function optimally. How? How do your foods affect pH, sugar balance and the needs of your cells? How? Understanding that your lymphatic system is the sewer system of the body, how do your...

What did you learn from viewing "Zoot Suit"? Which "SLO" do you think is best achieved...

What did you learn from viewing "Zoot Suit"? Which "SLO" do you think is best achieved from this play/show? Which ending did you think is most appropriate? Why did Luis Valdez give you choices?

what type of research do you think is best suited for the topic area you are...

what type of research do you think is best suited for the topic area you are interested in follows a bottoms-up or top-down for theory verification or theory generation? Why?

What are the current “Drivers” of the globalization process? What form do you think the globalization...

What are the current “Drivers” of the globalization process? What form do you think the globalization process will take over the next decade? Develop your answer into a 3 - 4 page essay using the following topic: TOPIC (What will be the new, emerging characteristics of this process?)

Question