Question

In: Operations Management

When an organization's leaders and members allow themselves to be captured by their own beliefs, they...

When an organization's leaders and members allow themselves to be captured by their own beliefs, they see only what they want to see. When coupled with ambition and greed, a feedback loop develops that increasingly biases the interpretation of information and distorts reality. Group members may rationalize or ignore warning signs that are in conflict with closely held beliefs and develop illusions of invulnerability. Many historians now feel that aspects of these processes are a core explanation for the excessive credit expansion that fuelled the 2007 subprime mortgage meltdown and subsequent financial crisis.

In the years leading up to the financial crisis, clear warnings of impending problems were ignored. The revered chairman of the U.S. Federal Reserve Bank, Alan Greenspan, was a strong advocate of the free market and supported minimal market intervention. He was also known to be unwelcoming to challenges to his ideas. As William White, the chief economist for the central bank of all central bankers, the Bank for International Settlements, recalls, “Greenspan always demanded respect.” And who could question Greenspan? He was an economic superstar and everything was going well. As White further states, “When you are inside the bubble, everybody feels fine. Nobody wants to believe that it can burst.”

White was the only central banker in the world willing to challenge or criticize Greenspan and his ideas. White predicted the approaching financial crisis years before it happened and presented a paper to the central bankers that contradicted everything Greenspan believed. Despite White's and his team's persistent criticism of the mortgage securitization business, explanations of the perils of risky loans, and provision of evidence about the rating agencies' lack of credibility, few in the highly secretive world of central banking listened. As White later said, “Somehow everybody was hoping that it wouldn't go down as long as you don't look at the downside.”

All the ingredients of the financial crisis were known by the central bankers more than two years before the crisis began. The Mortgage Insurance Companies of America, a trade association of U.S. mortgage providers, even sent a letter to Alan Greenspan expressing its strong concerns about risky mortgage lending practices and speculating that the Fed might be using incorrect data. But the data and warnings were ignored because the economy was doing well and billions in bonuses were being awarded on Wall Street. No one was anxious to break up the party. When Ben Bernanke succeeded Greenspan in early 2006, he also ignored the warnings. Even as the financial crisis began, Bernanke downplayed the risk of the troubles spreading further. We now know that the troubles and concerns highlighted by White and others rocked the foundations of the global economy.

To decrease the chances of groupthink undermining the financial industry again, some experts have suggested increasing the diversity of senior management and among those developing products that affect the risks in the financial system. Because similar people (age, race, education, gender, etc.) tend to think in the same way, perhaps people from different backgrounds would be more willing to question ideas and counter the effects of groupthink.

Questions:

  1. How were the elements of groupthink illustrated in the financial crisis?

  2. What could be done to reduce the effects of groupthink in the future?

  3. Do you think that increasing the diversity of the financial companies' leadership would reduce groupthink? Why or why not?

Solutions

Expert Solution

Answer-

-. Groupthink is said to happen when the individuals from a gathering take choice in request to minimize a contention circumstance and arrive at an agreement in a friendly way.

The case expresses that the there were clear signs and solid warnings accessible to financial arrangement producers, market analysts and national banks before the 2007 subprime contract emergency. Anyway the warnings were overlooked because of groupthink. Alan Greenspan, the executive of U.S. Central Bank emphatically preferred minimum market intervention.

This drove other pioneers in Bank for International Settlements; rule with the expectation of complimentary market despite the fact that there was a reasonable requirement for advertise intervention. This choice was made despite the fact that the pioneers knew that it was anything but an ideal choice.

-. To reduce the effects of groupthink in future, all financial strategy making ought to be straightforwardly attached to current large scale and smaller scale monetary elements. A framework ought to be worked in which high significance is paid to financial information when making choices. Warnings and current improvements ought to never be disregarded. With such a framework set up, ideal choices will be made more often than not.

-. Indeed, I think that increasing the diversity of the financial companies' leadership would reduce groupthink for the basic explanation that it would reduce predispositions.

The more different the leadership the more grounded will be the capacity of the gathering to consider the genuine situations and settle on ideal choices. Diversity will reduce stereotyping in the gathering.

PLEASE LIKE MY ANSWER PLEASE..


Related Solutions

An organization's culture refers to a set of beliefs, customs, behaviors, and attitudes that brings about...
An organization's culture refers to a set of beliefs, customs, behaviors, and attitudes that brings about an understanding of what the organization stands for, how it does things and what is most important. Discuss the importance of organizational culture, where it comes from and how is the culture managed for success.
Scenario: Your organization's CEO is concerned that members of the strategic planning committee are not familiar...
Scenario: Your organization's CEO is concerned that members of the strategic planning committee are not familiar with current economic thought and principles. The CEO has assigned you the task of developing a report to introduce some of these thoughts and principles. Develop a 1,050-word report to the members of the strategic planning committee explaining the following information: How economists are both scientists and policymakers and what process society uses to allocate its scarce resources. Using the circular flow model, explain...
Are the buying organization's Purchasing and Supply Management staff members the only ones involved in the...
Are the buying organization's Purchasing and Supply Management staff members the only ones involved in the utilization of cost management and contract management strategies?
The Working Stage of the group is active for members. Leaders need to develop and introduce...
The Working Stage of the group is active for members. Leaders need to develop and introduce activities that elicit member self-reflection and participation for change. Research the internet and find at least three activities you would use in your domestic abuse group. Explain how these activities would help your group members reach the goals you have for the group.
Pick an organization (business) 1. Describe the organization's culture through its values, rituals, beliefs, language, architecture,...
Pick an organization (business) 1. Describe the organization's culture through its values, rituals, beliefs, language, architecture, stories, heroes and artifacts. 2. Discuss the leadership of the organization and its relationship to the culture. 3. How does the culture of the organization reflect the industry and environment in which that company conducts business? 4. How would you advise a new employee to behave and in this culture? Your paper should be a maximum of three (3) pages, double-spaced in a Microsoft...
what role does a CEO play in an organization's cultures? what role do other leaders/managers play?
what role does a CEO play in an organization's cultures? what role do other leaders/managers play?
Discuss how members of a military unit could openly bring themselves to kill some individual(s) and...
Discuss how members of a military unit could openly bring themselves to kill some individual(s) and not feel any sense of deviance or criminal wrongdoing for the act. Be sure to include ideas from the work of Stanley Milgram in your answer. In addition, if you were a participant in Milgram’s research on obedience, how far do you think you would go in carrying out “orders”? What were some of the potential ethical problems with the experimenter’s manipulation of the...
What happens to the projected object size and amount of light captured when the effective focal...
What happens to the projected object size and amount of light captured when the effective focal length is increased by 300%?
In 1997, Scottish researchers captured newspaper headlines when they announced the birth of Dolly, a lamb...
In 1997, Scottish researchers captured newspaper headlines when they announced the birth of Dolly, a lamb cloned from an adult sheep by nuclear transplantation. These researchers cultured mammary (nuclear-donor) cells in a nutrient-poor medium and then fused these cells with enucleated sheep eggs. The resulting diploid cells divided to form early embryos, which were implanted into surrogate mothers. Out of several hundred implanted embryos, one successfully completed normal development, and Dolly was born. Later analyses showed that Dolly’s chromosomal DNA...
Explain the advantages to the organizations when values and behavior of the leaders and the followers...
Explain the advantages to the organizations when values and behavior of the leaders and the followers are aligned.
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT