Question

In: Accounting

A law firm is expanding rapidly and must move to new office space. Business is good,...

A law firm is expanding rapidly and must move to new office space. Business is good, and the firm is encouraged to purchase an entire building for £10 million. The building offers first-class office space, is conveniently located near their most important corporate clients, and provides space for future expansion. The firm is considering how to pay for it. David Rooney, a consultant, encourages the firm not to buy the building but to sign a long- term lease instead. “With lease financing, you’ll save £10 million. You won’t have to put up any equity investment,” Rooney explains. The senior law partner asks about the terms of the lease. “I’ve already checked that,” Rooney says. “The lease will provide 100% financing. It will commit you to 20 fixed annual payments of £950,000, with the first payment due immediately.” “The initial payment of £950,000 sounds like a down payment to me,” the senior partner observes sourly. “Good point,” Rooney says amiably, “but you’ll still save £9,050,000 up front. You can earn a good rate of return on that money. For example, I understand you are considering branch offices in London and Beijing. The £9 million would pay the costs of setting up the new offices, and the cash flows from the new offices should more than cover the lease payments. And there is no financial risk—the cash flows from the expansion will cover the lease payments with a safety cushion. There is no reason for you or your partners to worry or to demand a higher-than-normal rate of return.”

Requirement: Suppose the present value of the building equals its purchase price of £10 million. Assume that the law firm can finance the offices in London and Beijing from operating cash flow, with cash left over used for the lease payments. The firm will not default on the lease payments. For simplicity, you may ignore taxes.

(a)If the law firm takes the lease, it will invest £950,000 and in effect borrow £9,050,000, repaid by 19 instalments of £950,000. What is the interest rate on this disguised loan? [20 marks]

(b)The law firm could finance 80% of the purchase price with a conventional mortgage at a 7% interest rate. Is the conventional mortgage better than the lease? Provide supporting calculations and discussion. [20 marks]

(c)Construct a simple numerical example to convince Rooney that the lease would expose the law firm to financial risk. You may wish to consider what is the rate of return on the firm’s equity investment in the office building if a recession arrives and the market value of the (leased) office building falls to £9 million after one year?; what is the rate of return with conventional mortgage financing?; with all-equity financing? [15 marks]

(d)Do the investments in London and Beijing have anything to do with the decision to finance the office building? Explain briefly. [10 marks]

Solutions

Expert Solution

a). Taking this as an annuity-due lease, where the first payment is made immediately,
equating the PVs, using the PV of annuity-due formula for 20 annual payments of 950000
10000000=(950000*(1-(1+r)^-20)/r)*(1+r)
Solving for r , we get,
the interest rate on the lease= 8.11%
Total cash outflow under lease will be 950000*20= 19000000
b). As 80% *10000000 =8000000 is financed,
monthly payment on the mortgage will be
taking monthly rate=7%/12= 0.5833%,
8000000=Pmt*(1-1.005833^-240)/0.005833
Monthly payment = 62022
so, total Yearly payment= 62022*12=744264
Total cash outflow under mortgage will be
(62022*12*20)+2000000=
16885280
So, conventional mortgage is cheaper than leasing.
c). Leasing will expose the firm to financial risk ,
ie. When the market value of the leased building falls from 10 millions to 9 millions,the law firm stands to lose by way of higher annual lease payments ,calculated based on the original price--which affects the net income & consequent return to shareholders' equity.
Whereas,
under conventional mortgage,the firm can deduct periodic mortgage payments towards interest , and also claim depreciation for the buildings purchased.
As interest payments are less under mortgage , it creates more return to equity

_____________________________________________

If you have any query or any Explanation please ask me in the comment box, i am here to helps you.please give me positive rating.

*****************THANK YOU**************


Related Solutions

Murphy’s Brewhouse was a rapidly expanding chain of home-brew bars. The beer was not very good,...
Murphy’s Brewhouse was a rapidly expanding chain of home-brew bars. The beer was not very good, but hopes were high when the company went public three years ago, because of founder/owner Kevin Murphy’s promotional skills. At the time the company went public, Murphy’s also issued $50 million of 20-year maturity debentures at a coupon rate of 9 percent. These debentures were sold at par ($1,000 per bond). Shortly after this debenture issue, Murphy’s received some very negative reviews, both in...
Business law 2. New Jersey Landfills and "dumps" were rapidly being filled to capacity. land to...
Business law 2. New Jersey Landfills and "dumps" were rapidly being filled to capacity. land to create new landfills was getting more and more scarce. Environmental groups were protesting the creation of new waste facilities. the governor of New Jersey issued an emergency order banning any out of state residents and businesses from using New Jersey Landfills while allowing New Jersey residents to continue using them. the state of Pennsylvania and Delaware sued New Jersey on the grounds that the...
A small family-owned business is rapidly expanding. Payroll is currently processed by the owner's wife but...
A small family-owned business is rapidly expanding. Payroll is currently processed by the owner's wife but she can no longer keep up. You've been hired to evaluate whether or not the company should outsource the payroll function. What questions must be answered for you to make a recommendation? What are the advantages and disadvantages of outsourcing payroll? What factors should be considered in outsourcing payroll to a payroll service bureau? Discuss the advantages and disadvantages of using a payroll service...
Erma’s Beauty Supply is considering expanding the existing store. Erma wants to lease the office space...
Erma’s Beauty Supply is considering expanding the existing store. Erma wants to lease the office space next door to her business. Erma must spend, $120,000 on equipment to expand. The equipment is expected to have a zero-salvage value and will be retired in 8 years. Erma expects to increase networking capital by $8,000 right now if she goes through with the expansion. Erma spent $12,000 last month on a survey of the area surrounding the shop to see if there...
This is referring to Business Law 1: US Law All that is law must consist of...
This is referring to Business Law 1: US Law All that is law must consist of a right to which a duty is owed. In other words, law is composed only of rights and duties. 1. What do you suppose this means? 2. Can you think of a situation in which a right exists where there is no corresponding duty? 3. Who or what has rights? 4. Who or what has duties? 5. Are rights and duties connected in specific...
Porsche is expanding rapidly through both related and geographic diversification. Do you consider this business strategy...
Porsche is expanding rapidly through both related and geographic diversification. Do you consider this business strategy to be successful? Why, or why not? If you consider Porsche’s diversification to be successful, what is the source of Porsche’s success? Corporate Strategy
(in business law ) Is good faith part of Australian contract law? Discuss with reference to...
(in business law ) Is good faith part of Australian contract law? Discuss with reference to decided cases and legislation?(at least 150 words)
Lowes Inc is a new firm in a rapidly growing industry. The company is planning on...
Lowes Inc is a new firm in a rapidly growing industry. The company is planning on increasing its annual dividend by 20% a year for the next four years and then decreasing the growth rate to 5% per year. The company just paid its annual dividend in the amount of $1.00 per share. What is the current value of one share if the required rate of return is 9.25%? A. $35.63B. $38.19C. $41.05D. $43.19E. $45.81
The Bell Weather Co is a new firm in a rapidly growing industry. The company is...
The Bell Weather Co is a new firm in a rapidly growing industry. The company is planning on increasing its annual dividend by 31% a year for the next 4 years and then decreasing the growth rate to 3% per year. The company just paid its annual dividend in the amount of $3.30 per share. What is the current value of one share of this stock if the required rate of return is 8.80%? -I think the answer is 144.6...
The Newton Co. is a new firm in a rapidly growing industry. The company is planning...
The Newton Co. is a new firm in a rapidly growing industry. The company is planning on increasing its annual dividend by 15% a year for the next four years (Year 1, Year 2, Year 3, and Year 4) and then increase at the constant growth rate of 5% per year indefinitely. The company just paid its annual dividend in the amount of $1.50 per share. What is the current value of Newton Co.’s stock if the required rate of...
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT