Question

In: Physics

Well, it does according to this preprint for certain scales. What would be a simple way...

Well, it does according to this preprint for certain scales.

What would be a simple way to explain MOND to a layman?

Does it ignore mainstream physics? How much?

Solutions

Expert Solution

Yes. The would appear to be the point of the paper you cite. It has been accepted for PRL apparently so that should lend it some credibility.

MOND - short for MOdified Newtonian Dynamics - is a phenomenological theory that was conceived of by Mordechai Milgrom in order to explain the huge discrepancy between the shapes of galaxy rotation curves as predicted by Newtonian theory and the actual shapes observed. A rotation curve is the plot of the orbital velocity of objects in the galaxy with respect to distance from the center:
The simplest statement of MOND is that it is a theory with a minimum acceleration scale . When this scale is reached at some radius in a galaxy, objects appear to cease to respond to gravitational forces. Alternatively one could say that gravitational forces cannot generate an acceleration lower than .

There are many critics of MOND. However, it has had remarkable success over the years. This paper is only the most recent evidence in its favor. MOND makes no claim to explaining the microscopic physics which leads to these effects. Compared to the LCDM model, MOND makes far fewer assumptions (only one, in fact) and thus has the benefit of being simpler.

The challenge for theories of quantum gravity is to either rule out MOND'ian behavior in weak fields or otherwise explain what gives rise to it. So far, none have even tackled the question in part due out of fear of being labeled "fringe" for associating with such rabble as MOND ;]


Related Solutions

Explain is a super simple way--so a 6th grader would understand: What is primary data? How...
Explain is a super simple way--so a 6th grader would understand: What is primary data? How is that different from secondary data? Would you use primary data or secondary data (or both) to gather information about your target population for your own program? (Remember to include a "for real" example)
In prokaryotic translation and transcription, what way does mRNA build and what way does it read?...
In prokaryotic translation and transcription, what way does mRNA build and what way does it read? (ie 5' to 3')
how does economy of scales influence global competition?
how does economy of scales influence global competition?
How does anti-discrimination legislation impact the way you would work and what are the consequences of...
How does anti-discrimination legislation impact the way you would work and what are the consequences of breaching this legislation. (Word limit 250)
a. What does GDP measure? b. How well does GDP measure the well-being of a society?
a. What does GDP measure? b. How well does GDP measure the well-being of a society?
Below are statements coming from different psychological scales constructed by different authors; what the scales are...
Below are statements coming from different psychological scales constructed by different authors; what the scales are measuring nor the number of scales that are represented by these items are identified. Since the psychological variables measured by the items are fairly easily identifiable, create a table in which you will group those items that represent a common concept. Then, invent a construct or variable name for these items. This is an exercise that tests your intuitive abilities to spot the supposedly...
According to PMI, What is the Fairest way for Buyer and Seller to bid a new...
According to PMI, What is the Fairest way for Buyer and Seller to bid a new project? Select one: a. Analagous b. None of these c. PERT d. Time and Materials
According to the Lucas critique, what is the proper way to evaluate a proposal that reduces...
According to the Lucas critique, what is the proper way to evaluate a proposal that reduces government borrowing by raising taxes and reducing government spending?
1) Nadiya does very well on a psychology exam. According to research on the self-serving bias,...
1) Nadiya does very well on a psychology exam. According to research on the self-serving bias, Nadiya is likely to credit her success to all of the following except ______________________. her intelligence her teacherher talent in the field of psychology her teacher her hard work 2)---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- In Milgram’s obedience study, who played the role of “learner?” a participant who was recruited through a newspaper ad a computer program a confederate Milgram himself 3)--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Travis wants to sell childhood toys that...
Give an example of simple random sampling. what would be the strenghts and weaknesses of simple...
Give an example of simple random sampling. what would be the strenghts and weaknesses of simple random sampling in terms of external validity and sampling error?
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT