Question

In: Physics

Context is 1D Ising model. Metropolis algorithm is used for simulate that model. Among all possible...

Context is 1D Ising model. Metropolis algorithm is used for simulate that model. Among all possible spins configurations (states) that algorithm generates only states with the desired Boltzmann probability.

Algorithm chooses spin at random and makes a trial flip. If trial satisfies certain conditions related to Boltzmann probability, flip is accepted. Otherwise flip is rejected and system is unchanged.

Define "acceptance ratio" as a percentage of accepted trials. Simulation shows that acceptance ratio is higher on higher temperature (behave as increasing function of temperature).

Questions:

Why Metropolis algorithm is not efficient at low temperatures?

Is efficiency of algorithm related to acceptance ratio?

Solutions

Expert Solution

There are two problems at low temperatures. One is intrinsic to the Ising model, the other to the Metropolis algorithm. The Ising one is a bit more serious.

Problem with the Ising Model at low temperatures

The Ising model of ferromagnetism posits that the electrons in a model can be modeled as little magnetic dipoles, confined to only two quantized spin states, up and down, and that all the electrons in the metal have the same two possible orientations. The Metropolis algorithm counts up the quanta of energy to be gained if a particular dipole were flipped over by counting up the states of the dipole's neighbors and comparing it to the dipole itself. It compares the number it gets with the thermal energy from the Boltzmann distribution to determine whether or not the metal is cool enough that flipping to join the neighbors' alignments is energetically favorable.

Even if the dipoles have more possible orientations than this (ie if their spins don't really all align on the same plane), that's not the big problem at low temperatures. The real issue is that quantum mechanics is more subtle than this. In reality, it isn't the orientation of each individual which is quantized, but the sum of their magnetic moments which is quantized. At very low temperatures, this becomes an important failure in the Ising model, and the relevant states of a true ferromagnet are "magnons" in which all dipoles are nearly parallel and a single unit of opposite alignment is spread across many dipoles. So, we really shouldn't be comparing the dipole to its neighbors individually at very low temperatures.

Problem with the Metropolis algorithm at low temperatures

The problem here is also subtle. The Metropolis algorithm works by randomly picking a single dipole out of the whole magnet, checking it as described above, then checking another - it's just a Monte Carlo method. Now, theoretically, there should be a "critical temperature," below which it is energetically favorable for the dipoles to side with magnetism instead of temperature. But check out the following plots, which came from a simulation I did of a Metropolis-algorithm Ising magnet in C a while ago. In the units I used, the critical temperature happened to be :
The lowest temperature systems converge much more quickly to a homogeneous magnetization, but even at T=1.5 you still see "meta-stable states." In these cases, large sections of the magnet are commonly aligned, but the entire magnet isn't. Change can only occur along the border region - and since you are using a random choice of dipoles, the chance that you randomly select one of those dipoles on the border region is pretty small, so you need a very long timeframe for the system to reach equilibrium using this Monte-Carlo scheme.

Since the efficiency is worse close to the critical point of temperature, you could say that the algorithm's efficiency is worse near the critical point of the acceptance ratio, since the acceptance is related to the temperature.


Related Solutions

Among all the possible permutations that can be made by all the characters from the series...
Among all the possible permutations that can be made by all the characters from the series of words "COMPUTER", how many different ways that always and only three characters are in between 'P' and 'R''? Show both your work and the exact number.
An important theoretical construct used to differentiate among cultural communication styles involves the continuum of low-context...
An important theoretical construct used to differentiate among cultural communication styles involves the continuum of low-context to high-context cultures. High and low context cultures differ in the degree to which one must attend to interpersonal and contextual cues in the situation in order to understand what is taking place and what is being communicated.   What country is an example of a high-context culture? How does a high-context culture differ from a low-context culture?
Q1. Have you used the rational decision-making model to make a decision? What was the context?...
Q1. Have you used the rational decision-making model to make a decision? What was the context? How well did the model work? Give example of your work place. (You need to provide a convincing and relevant justification for the points, and it would be better if you can provide real life workplace examples to support the justification of the points)
How have you used the rational decision-making model to make a decision? What was the context?...
How have you used the rational decision-making model to make a decision? What was the context? How well did the model work? Please explain in at least 120 words.
1- Describe some of the most common used drugs among teenagers and their possible dangerous effects....
1- Describe some of the most common used drugs among teenagers and their possible dangerous effects. 2- What are risk factors for Child abuse and how can they be prevented? 3- Why is the elderly population more at risk for substance abuse? How can the nurse prevent or identify patients at risk? 4- What is trauma/shaken baby syndrome ? 5- What are the different types of elderly abuse, provide example.
In the IS-LM model, analyze the effects of increased optimism among banks on all the endogenous...
In the IS-LM model, analyze the effects of increased optimism among banks on all the endogenous variables (Y, r, I, S, C, T, L1, L2).
Develop Python implementation of combinatorial algorithm which will find all possible Anagrams of user input. Hint:...
Develop Python implementation of combinatorial algorithm which will find all possible Anagrams of user input. Hint: use backtracking algorithm. Example: Input = ROWAN UNIVERSITY Output (298 possibilities): YOUR WINTERS VAIN OAT RUINS WIN VERY … ROAR TUNES WIN IVY IRONY UNWISER VAT TIE IN SUN ROW VARY…
Suppose that in the context of one-sided search model of unemployment, all jobs pay start paying...
Suppose that in the context of one-sided search model of unemployment, all jobs pay start paying lower wage. What ,will be the consequences on the reservation wage and the unemployment rate? Explain.
1. A multiple linear regression model should not be used if: A The variables are all...
1. A multiple linear regression model should not be used if: A The variables are all statistically significant. B The coefficient of determination R2 is large. C Both of the above. D Neither of the above. 2. Consider a multiple linear regression model where the output variable is a company's revenue for different months, and the purpose is to investigate how the revenue depends upon the company's advertising budget. The input variables can be time-lagged so that the first input...
"the laugh gas", N2O, is used by dentists. a. write down all possible lewis structures for...
"the laugh gas", N2O, is used by dentists. a. write down all possible lewis structures for N20. b. what is the structure of electronic pairs around each of the atoms in the lewis structures you proposed? c. what is the geometric structure around each of the atoms in the lewis structures?
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT