Question

In: Physics

Senior physicists constantly complain they spend too much time on administration, teaching, getting grants, serving in...

Senior physicists constantly complain they spend too much time on administration, teaching, getting grants, serving in committees, peer-reviewing articles, supervising, etc. . Do senior physicists conduct research by getting their post-docs and graduate students to do all the intensive work for them?

Solutions

Expert Solution

From the way the question is phrased, I take "senior physicist" to mean physicist who are advanced in administration rather than advanced in age.

The answer is that no, senior physicists do not contribute directly to research. At least, they do not contribute more than everyone else who works at a physics department. And do note that most of the people earn their money because of "physics" do not have an advanced physics degree and certainly are not "physicists". Instead, for each physicist there are large numbers of undergraduate students, graduate students, janitors, secretaries, various specialties such as plumbers, builders. Large experiments employ huge numbers of technicians, computer programmers, various blue-collar workers, accountants, lawyers, the list goes on and on. Finally, any physics group purchases equipment (example: personal computers, oscilloscopes, raw material) from companies that have little to do with physics. Since physics is an endeavor that is supported by taxes you might want to consider all taxpayers as contributing to physics. In this sense, sure, senior physicists do contribute.

The success of the human race is due to its unique organizational skill. Though most of the individuals do not understand this, the species is a classic herd animal. Almost all of the human race's domesticated animals are also herd animals, i.e. dogs, horses, chickens, pigs, ducks, cattle, donkeys, camel, llama, various fish, etc. The only common exception is the cat, hence the common expression, "like trying to herd cats".1

As a herd animal, humans do their activities in packs. They generally form hierarchical structures typically led by an older "alpha" male. This male spends his time keeping the other herd members in line and defending himself from aspirants to his position (which typically comes with improved access to females or various other perks). Their most impressive herd behavior are the large scale conflicts they organize. They use their most advanced available technology to hunt each other in packs. Humans make velociraptors look cuddly.

The success of the human species in physics is due to extreme specialization. Any given physicist knows almost nothing from direct observation. Instead, almost all knowledge is obtained from other physicists. This is the ultimate in specialization, there is no other known animal species anything like it. This specialization is extremely useful. For example, the number of physicists who actually measure the mass of the electron is only a tiny fraction of the total but all of them use the same number.

The stuff that goes on in a physics work groups is is all standard primate behavior that can be observed with more clarity in any jungle (the clarity arises because you will be examining a different species). Any sociologist can tell you these things. And there is at least one sociologist who specializes in physics, Harry Collins. To learn more about the sociology of physics, try picking up some of his fascinating books: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Harry_Collins

As a side note, the sociology of science is not a subject that is appreciated by very many physicists. They would instead prefer to believe that physics is an activity that is governed by a universal inclination to seek the truth. The only reason I ended up reading on the sociology of physics is because I was taught general relativity by Joseph Weber, and Weber was the primary subject of a book by Collins, "Gravity's Shadow: the search for gravitational waves". Naturally, when I saw the book on sale, I bought it, read it, and was fascinated by the description of physicists in it.


Related Solutions

Many managers complain about the budgeting process. They claim it takes too long, requires too much...
Many managers complain about the budgeting process. They claim it takes too long, requires too much management time, encourages managers to “pad the budget” because of uncertainties, and creates unnecessary tension among managers. As a result of these charges, some managers and business leaders have called for an abandonment of traditional budgeting practices. However, regardless of budgeting’s failures, it continues to be widely used across all types of businesses and not-for-profit enterprises. One reason for the continued use of budgeting...
You love french fries and suspect that the serving sizes in the cafeteria vary too much....
You love french fries and suspect that the serving sizes in the cafeteria vary too much. Some portions are too large while others are too small. The cafeteria claims that a serving of fries is 12 ounces. You and three of friends decide to test the cafeteria's claim. Each of you takes a sample by weighing the french fry servings in the cafeteria when each of you goes to each lunch this week. 1. State the hypothesis and create a...
Explain how organizations tht spend "too much" or "too little" on capital investments can each experience...
Explain how organizations tht spend "too much" or "too little" on capital investments can each experience financial difficulties and/or be impacted by their competitors
How much customers buy is a direct result of how much time they spend in the...
How much customers buy is a direct result of how much time they spend in the store. A study of average shopping times in a large national houseware store gave the following information (Source: Why We Buy: The Science of Shopping by P. Underhill). Women with female companion: 8.3 min. Women with male companion: 4.5 min. Suppose you want to set up a statistical test to challenge the claim that a woman with a female friend spends an average of...
How much customers buy is a direct result of how much time they spend in the...
How much customers buy is a direct result of how much time they spend in the store. A study of average shopping times in a large national houseware store gave the following information (Source: Why We Buy: The Science of Shopping by P. Underhill). Women with female companion: 8.3 min. Women with male companion: 4.5 min. Suppose you want to set up a statistical test to challenge the claim that a woman with a female friend spends an average of...
How much customers buy is a direct result of how much time they spend in the...
How much customers buy is a direct result of how much time they spend in the store. A study of average shopping times in a large national houseware store gave the following information (Source: Why We Buy: The Science of Shopping by P. Underhill). Women with female companion: 8.3 min. Women with male companion: 4.5 min. Suppose you want to set up a statistical test to challenge the claim that a woman with a female friend spends an average of...
4). How much customers buy is a direct result of how much time they spend in...
4). How much customers buy is a direct result of how much time they spend in the store. A study of average shopping times in a large national houseware store gave the following information (Source: Why We Buy: The Science of Shopping by P. Underhill). Women with female companion: 8.3 min. Women with male companion: 4.5 min. Suppose you want to set up a statistical test to challenge the claim that a woman with a female friend spends an average...
1.Getting sunburned is dangerous as well as painful. Too much exposure to high energy electromagnetic (EM)...
1.Getting sunburned is dangerous as well as painful. Too much exposure to high energy electromagnetic (EM) radiation can lead to cellular DNA damage causing an increased risk for cancer. You know that DNA damage occurs if the energy of the incident, EM radiation, is above a certain threshold. What would you predict is worse based on your knowledge of quantum theory - a weak beam of ultraviolet light, or an intense beam of infrared light? Explain your reasoning. 2. The...
Analyze a health-related behavior that is considered unhealthy (smoking, unhealthy eating, drinking too much, not getting...
Analyze a health-related behavior that is considered unhealthy (smoking, unhealthy eating, drinking too much, not getting enough sleep, not exercising, avoiding health screenings. And give reasons to why people still do it. (reasons such as the Health Belief Modles).
How much time did a person spend at the library over a month for them to...
How much time did a person spend at the library over a month for them to spend 40 hours reading a book? Round your final answer to the nearest whole number. ___ hours
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT