Pitfalls of each of the criteria for accepting/rejecting a project

Expert Solution

Their are many metrics which can be used in capital budgeting to estimate the profitability of potential investments. Some of the popular one are :

1. NPV

2. IRR

3. PAYBACK PERIOD

4. MIRR, etc..

Now, let's understand their pitfalls one by one :

1. NPV

The NPV method does not measure the project size.
The IRR method can, at times, give you conflicting answers when compared to NPV for mutually exclusive projects.

2. IRR

The Multiple IRR Problem
A multiple IRR problem occurs when cash flows during the project lifetime are negative (i.e. the project operates at a loss or the company needs to contribute more capital).

This is known as a "non-normal cash flow," and such cash flows will give multiple IRRs.

3. PAYBACK PERIOD

Ignores Time Value of Money
Not All Cash Flows Covered
Not Realistic
Ignores Profitability

4. MIRR : The disadvantage of MIRR is that it asks for two additional decisions i.e. determination of financing rate and cost of capital. These can be estimates again and the managers in real life may hesitate in involving these two additional estimates.

jeff jeffy answered 1 year ago

list capital decisions methods and explain the criteria of accepting or rejecting capital projects under the...

list capital decisions methods and explain the criteria of accepting or rejecting capital projects under the net present value method .

State the criterion for accepting or rejecting independent projects under each of the following methods. Profitability...

State the criterion for accepting or rejecting independent projects under each of the following methods. Profitability index [2 Marks] Discounted payback period [2 Marks] Accounting rate of return [2 Marks] Net present value [2 Marks] Payback period [2 Marks] Internal rate of return [2 Marks]

what role does significant value and significant level play in accepting or rejecting the null hypothesis?

Explain and compare two(2) examples of special order(accepting a special order and rejecting a special order)...

Explain and compare two(2) examples of special order(accepting a special order and rejecting a special order) for a sample bussiness decision for a company. Rejecting a special order) for a sample business decision for a company can I get a refund for this question.

Describe several project evaluation criteria

describe several project evaluation criteria

Describe several project evaluation criteria.

A Type 1 error is defined as: Rejecting a False Null Hypothesis Rejecting a True Null...

A Type 1 error is defined as: Rejecting a False Null Hypothesis Rejecting a True Null Hypothesis Failing to Reject a False Null Hypothesis Failing to Reject a True Null Hypothesis b.) The probability for which a Type 1 error may occur in a hypothesis test is referred to as: Z-value Test Statistic Critical Value Level of Significance c.) A researcher conducts a hypothesis test to evaluate the effect of a treatment. The hypothesis test produces a z-score of z...

Give design criteria or basis for designing a foundation project

NPV always gives you correct decision for accepting the project. If NPV always gives us the...

NPV always gives you correct decision for accepting the project. If NPV always gives us the correct decision why should we pay attention to profitability ratios or IRR? Provide an example where one of these other ratios might change your decision on a project.

Question