Question

In: Psychology

There is an emphasis in American culture on developing a strong sense of autonomy and independence...

There is an emphasis in American culture on developing a strong sense of autonomy and independence as we grow older. Although Erikson was keenly aware that there is a constant tension between independence and belonging, a theme running throughout his developmental theory is that in order to advance to higher stages of development we must achieve a stronger sense of independence, increasingly liberating ourselves from our dependence upon others. Is our focus in America on autonomy and independence an unmitigated good or are there other possibilities? Looking at moral reasoning in America, Carol Gilligan contends that the emphasis on autonomy and independence is based on a masculine ideal, whereas a focus on social relationships, empathy, and interconnectedness lies at the heart of the feminist perspective. In your written assignment please describe Gilligan’s case for gender bias in Kohlberg's theory of moral reasoning. How does she justify her argument? How does her theory of moral reasoning relate to Erikson’s ideas about the relationship between autonomy and intimacy? Finally, in your own upbringing, were interdependence/empathy or independence/autonomy emphasized more? At what ages (be specific with at least one example)? Did the focus change as you grew older? Was it different in your family depending on your gender? What perspective would you try to emphasize with your own (perhaps hypothetical) children? Would it be different for different genders? This last set of questions is asking for your opinion about these issues in moral reasoning and there is not a correct answer, but you should engage the course readings in your responses.

Solutions

Expert Solution

According to Carol Galligan who proposed the theory of moral development for women stating that the moral development proposed by Kohlberg doesn’t hold any water for women because of the physical and social conditions. She argued that the male perspective is more towards Logical and individualistic while the female perspective is towards care and contextual. She even suggested to go for an androgyny integrating male and female values.
Autonomy depends on which country you live in because western world gives almost equal rights to women but in developing countries and Islamic countries women are still treated as child bearing machines. The term freedom in these countries is applicable only for men. In the western world, women have the same level of autonomy because of the societal changes and economic independency while it is missing in other parts of the world.
Intimacy is again another interesting topic because a male doesn’t need to worry about bearing a child after being intimate with a woman physically but for a woman, it’s going to affect their entire life. They have to change their career, life style etc. in order to bring the children up. Intimacy in terms of relationship again depends on which part of the world one lives in. Western countries have the same perspective about a relationship and intimacy between a woman and man but in other parts of the world, woman cannot be very expressive and show their emotions openly.
According to me, the society has got different perspective about man and woman and that definitely affects the moral development of the child. I’ll definitely treat my children equally but despite the fact that Carol Galligan’s proposed moral development theory for women, the fact that it again changes depending on the geographical and societal environment where one lives.


Related Solutions

Looking at moral reasoning in America, Carol Gilligan contends that the emphasis on autonomy and independence...
Looking at moral reasoning in America, Carol Gilligan contends that the emphasis on autonomy and independence is based on a masculine ideal, whereas a focus on social relationships, empathy, and interconnectedness lies at the heart of the feminist perspective. Please describe Gilligan’s case for gender bias in Kohlberg's theory of moral reasoning. How does she justify her argument? How does her theory of moral reasoning relate to Erikson’s ideas about the relationship between autonomy and intimacy?
In the current HR employer-employee relations, there’s more emphasis on improved employee degree of autonomy and...
In the current HR employer-employee relations, there’s more emphasis on improved employee degree of autonomy and responsibility. HR is also placing more focus on employability. Use a real bussenis example (apple company) to discuss what is meant by empowerment era, employability and the benefits, costs and effects of employability. essay , about 250 words
The need to protect professional autonomy and independence may lead to ethical issues concerning _____. CHOOSE...
The need to protect professional autonomy and independence may lead to ethical issues concerning _____. CHOOSE THE BEST (one) ANSWER A) respect for others B) loyalty and respect for others C) loyalty D) hiring decisions
The autonomy of (American) colonists to conduct their own affairs prior to the revolutionary period was...
The autonomy of (American) colonists to conduct their own affairs prior to the revolutionary period was known as __________. Home rule. Compromise. Colonialism. Treaty-power.
Module 09 Discussion - Culture of Safety In this discussion, emphasis is on awareness of client...
Module 09 Discussion - Culture of Safety In this discussion, emphasis is on awareness of client quality and safety and in particular what is a "culture of safety." Based on the review of the following websites at the Institute of Healthcare Improvement and Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality answer the following questions. What values ensure a culture of safety? How can healthcare facilities establish a culture of safety? What is the nurse's role in maintaining a culture of safety?...
Explain the importance of developing a strong introduction to your speeches? Explain the importance of developing...
Explain the importance of developing a strong introduction to your speeches? Explain the importance of developing a strong conclusion to your speeches? Name 3 things you can put into your introduction and 3 things you can put into your conclusion to make your speech great?
In general, Are there important cultural variations in the emphasis placed on individual autonomy, and if so, how should those cultural differences be handled?
We have watched a documentary where one exploited or demonstrated disrespect for people in minority cultures by failing to obtain individual informed consent for research or treatment.In general, Are there important cultural variations in the emphasis placed on individual autonomy, and if so, how should those cultural differences be handled? What special considerations need to be taken for research in developing countries? Should the responsibility fall on the country sponsoring the research or the country where the research is taking...
What is ethics ? and why is a strong sense of ethical responsibility vital for public...
What is ethics ? and why is a strong sense of ethical responsibility vital for public speakers ?
Are the traditional American beliefs in free markets and respect for personal autonomy contributing to diet-related...
Are the traditional American beliefs in free markets and respect for personal autonomy contributing to diet-related public health crises such as obesity and diabetes? hurry please
The educational model at UoPeople places a great emphasis on examinations. Does your culture or country...
The educational model at UoPeople places a great emphasis on examinations. Does your culture or country have the same emphasis? Do you personally agree with the emphasis placed on examinations?
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT