Question

In: Physics

I find plane waves are uncompatible with light cone. Perhaps plane waves are "virtual" and can...

I find plane waves are uncompatible with light cone.

Perhaps plane waves are "virtual" and can never be measured in that case, shouldn't we call plane waves as "virtual plane waves"? (other option could be that plane waves allows waves travel faster than c)

I would like to clarify this point through this question.

If plane waves would exist(as measurable), then higher than c speed could be reached like this:

A wave going from X to Y at a speed c, it will reach Z at higher than c speed, because it will reach at same time, traveling more distance.

(X).
|   
v   
________________________________________________
plane waves ________________________________________________
going X to Y ________________________________________________
(Y). (Z).

In a real situation the wave will be a circle (or a sphere in 3d) so it will get Z later then that's not a plane wave.

Solutions

Expert Solution

A "plane wave" generally refers to an infinite and perfectly flat wavefront, which cannot exist in reality, of course. However, there is nothing at all impossible about a plane wave of finite extent. Such a wave will experience diffraction at its edges, of course, but can still propagate over long distances before losing its planar nature.

The problem with your question about faster than light information transmission, is that if X were the only point emitting a wave, then it would be a spherical wave, not a plane wave. A plane wave can be thought of as being composed as a superposition of spherical waves emitted in phase from every point on an infinite plane. So in your example, information would not be arriving at Z from X, but instead from some other source point within the causal past of Z. In your diagram that point could be at the same height as X, but directly above Z.

Considering a wavefront (planar or otherwise) as a superposition of spherical waves is the central feature of the Huygens-Fresnel Principle, which would be a good reading on the topic.


Related Solutions

(1) Radio waves and light are electromagnetic waves and transverse waves that can operate in a...
(1) Radio waves and light are electromagnetic waves and transverse waves that can operate in a medium or in space. What is an Aether or ether? Upon which medium does sound travel the fastest? (2) Some scientists think that ether does exist but does exist in another dimension that we cannot see. Can you elaborate on this?
We saw in lecture that light waves can be polarized. Can sound waves be polarized? If...
We saw in lecture that light waves can be polarized. Can sound waves be polarized? If so, give an example of polarized sound. If not, explain why not.
Using plane waves, find the Fresnel and Snell formulas. (Reflection and refraction). Show that in a...
Using plane waves, find the Fresnel and Snell formulas. (Reflection and refraction). Show that in a vacuum plane waves propagate orthogonally to each other, and are transverse to the direction of propagation
Using plane waves, find the Fresnel and Snell formulas. (Reflection and refraction) Show that in a...
Using plane waves, find the Fresnel and Snell formulas. (Reflection and refraction) Show that in a vacuum plane waves propagate orthogonally to each other, and are transverse to the direction of propagation.
Consider electric field of electromagnetic waves that are parallel to plane of incidence find a)   fractional...
Consider electric field of electromagnetic waves that are parallel to plane of incidence find a)   fractional ratio of reflected and refracted fields relative to incident field b) critical angle at which reflected wave vanishes
suppose you conduct an experiment where you shine plane waves of light through a small slit....
suppose you conduct an experiment where you shine plane waves of light through a small slit. how would the intensity graph of this experiment differ than that of a double slit of similar width?
For a light to be coherent light waves should have:
                                                                     For a light to be coherent light waves should have: same color different phases same wavelength and phase all wavelengths   Which phenomenon shows the wave nature of light? reflection refraction diffraction lenses   Bright fringes are a result of: diffraction constructive interference destructive interference stimulated...
Light energy of sufficient intensity can cause materials to emit sound waves depending on their light...
Light energy of sufficient intensity can cause materials to emit sound waves depending on their light absorption. Propose a system to make 2D images of these optoacoustic properties of an object
All of the following quantities can be measured or calculated for light waves and subatomic particles...
All of the following quantities can be measured or calculated for light waves and subatomic particles except _____. A. momentum B. velocity C. frequency D. energy
A. What are electromagnetic waves? What is the difference between visible light and other electromagnetic waves...
A. What are electromagnetic waves? What is the difference between visible light and other electromagnetic waves that we cannot see? Name four electromagnetic waves that we are not able to see. B- What is the remnant energy of the Big Bang, called Cosmic Microwave Background waves (CMB)? How can we say that the universe is expanding by comparing it to the electromagnetic waves at the time of the Big Bang? C- What is the wavelength of red light and blue...
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT