Question

In: Psychology

Blumberg refers to the practice of justice as a confidence game because the prosecutor and the...

Blumberg refers to the practice of justice as a confidence game because the prosecutor and the defense attorney conspire to appear as something they are not – adversaries in a do-or-die situation. Do you agree with Blumberg? Why or why not? Discuss your position.

Solutions

Expert Solution

Yes I agree with him.

Abraham S. Blumberg’s major thesis is that criminal-defense lawyers are turned from their duties to the client by the system to get their clients to plead guilty. This is a fair characterization overall, but not universally. Most criminal-defense lawyers put the client first—before personal and professional relationships and “clients”—to some extent.

Those at the “lesser” end of that spectrum are clearly derelict in their duties; those at the “greater” end are paragons of Sixth Amendment virtue.1 Most criminal-defense lawyers are neither derelict nor paragons, but somewhere in between. There are few who could not do a better job of subjugating all else to the client’s interests.

So how can the defendant, desperate to get out of trouble, find a lawyer who will do the best possible job of putting the client’s interests first?

Blumberg calls the practice of law a “confidence game.” There is a difference between a confidence game and a run-of-the-mill swindle. In a confidence game, the mark is led to believe that he is doing something shady. Most bad lawyer advertising is a run-of-the-mill swindle; “we’ll bribe the judge” would be a confidence game. “I am a former prosecutor,” with its hint that the relationships formed as a prosecutor might be used to give the accused some advantage, is a confidence game.

So the best piece of advice for the client who wants not to be the victim of a criminal-defense confidence game is not to expect anything shady. The lawyer who intimates that his relationship with the prosecutor will get a better result should, like the lawyer who intimates that he can bribe the judge, be avoided at all costs. As I’ve noted before, when the lawyer’s long-term relationship with the prosecutor is placed in tension with her short-term relationship with the client, it is not the former that will suffer. Blumberg describes the inherent conflict between the interests of the client and the interests of the lawyer:

Plz rate the question if satisfied.thanks


Related Solutions

The courts impact in professional practice of criminal justice
Is there a better solution to the role that the court(s) play in establishing the legal standards which apply to the professional practice of criminal justice? Explain
What is community justice? Are there characteristics of a practice that must be present for a...
What is community justice? Are there characteristics of a practice that must be present for a strategy to be deemed community justice?
The term grace period is very important to an insurance policy because A. it refers to...
The term grace period is very important to an insurance policy because A. it refers to living benefits that can be paid for a grace period prior to death in special circumstances. B. it refers to the period when benefits are still payable while premiums are in arrears. C. it refers to the period when a policy can no longer be contested by an insurance company. D. it refers to the period when the policy has lapsed and can be...
Goals Practice loops and conditional statements Description Create a game for elementary school students to practice...
Goals Practice loops and conditional statements Description Create a game for elementary school students to practice multiplication. The application should display a greeting followed by a set of mathematical questions.  In each set the player is asked to enter a number from 1 to 9 to test multiplication skills or to press ‘E’ to exit the game.  The application checks if the number entered is indeed between 1 and 9 and if not displays a message inviting the...
1. Social justice is important for every nurse to consider in their daily nursing practice. Do...
1. Social justice is important for every nurse to consider in their daily nursing practice. Do I agree with that statement? What does it mean to my current nursing practice? 2. Do I know how I might further incorporate knowledge of the social determinants of health into my everyday practice? 3. When I think about making practice changes based on my new understanding of the social determinants of health, I feel... 4. When I tried to apply knowledge in social...
1. You are excited because your new card game has arrived. This game consists of 40...
1. You are excited because your new card game has arrived. This game consists of 40 unique cards. What is the number of ordered samples of 4 cards that can be drawn without replacement from the new deck of cards? 2. You are arranging flowers for a party. You have four white flowers, three yellow flowers, and two lavender flowers. How many different ways can these different colors be arranged? 3. You have a brown paper bag that contains two...
The routine practice of "ghost surgery" is well documented in medicine. Ghost surgery refers to any...
The routine practice of "ghost surgery" is well documented in medicine. Ghost surgery refers to any medical procedure in which the contracting physician was not the actual physician who performed the procedure. In many instances the patient is completely unaware simply because the patient is unconscious at the time. Ghost surgery is not, strictly speaking, limited to surgical procedures. The same phenomenon occurs in a variety of medical settings from radiology to routine lab work. In some instances, ghost surgery...
"The Case of​ Hoodia" concerns bioprospecting. Bioprospecting refers to the​ centuries-old practice of collecting and screening...
"The Case of​ Hoodia" concerns bioprospecting. Bioprospecting refers to the​ centuries-old practice of collecting and screening plant and other biological material for commercial​ purposes, such as the development of new​ drugs, seeds and cosmetics. Biopiracy is a negative term referring to the claiming of legal rights over such biological​ material, usually by means of​ patents, without compensation to the groups who discovered and originated the knowledge of this material. Graham Dutfield has described fundamentally different views on biopiracy as​ follows:...
Because the practice is in a market with increasing competition, discuss the pros and cons of...
Because the practice is in a market with increasing competition, discuss the pros and cons of accepting an equity share in place of additional salary.
If the 95% confidence interval for the average number of runs scored in a baseball game...
If the 95% confidence interval for the average number of runs scored in a baseball game is 5.8<population mean<6.7, what does this maen?
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT