Question

In: Psychology

What is the standard for commitment for those who are mentally ill?

What is the standard for commitment for those who are mentally ill?

Solutions

Expert Solution

Many states have established civil commitment laws and criteria that govern when the condition of an individual with acute or chronic psychiatric symptoms warrants a court order to mandate mental health treatment in a hospital. Among other provisions, these laws address how long and under what criteria patients can remain hospitalized for psychiatric treatment against their wishes; whether the state can require patients to adhere to court-ordered treatment after hospital discharge; and how much deterioration must occur before a patient can be re-hospitalized involuntarily.

There are short-term emergency hospitalization; longer-term commitment to a psychiatric hospital; and, where applicable, provisions for the less-restrictive option of court-ordered treatment (often called “assisted outpatient treatment” or “AOT”) in the community.

Civil commitment laws are universal but the quality of the laws and their implantation are not. The quality of the civil commitment laws in the vast majority of states remains far below what is necessary to provide a readily accessible path to treatment and recovery for individuals with the most severe mental illness who are unable to seek care for themselves.

In studies,

  • Only 14 states earned a cumulative grade of “B” or better for the quality of their civil commitment laws.
  • 17 states earned a cumulative grade of “D” or “F” for the quality of their laws.
  • Only 18 states were found to recognize the need for treatment as a basis for civil commitment to a hospital, and several of those were found to have less than ideal standards.
  • No state earned a grade of “A” on the use of its civil commitment laws.

Related Solutions

How do we overcome the stereotype that mentally ill patients are ill because of something they...
How do we overcome the stereotype that mentally ill patients are ill because of something they did while physically ill patients are ill because of something that happened to them? Even physical illness is often blamed on the patient (e.g., lifestyle behaviors), (1) to what extent does such blaming interfere with, even suppress, empathy or patient-centered care? (2) How do insurance restrictions reduce the quality of care and diminish outcomes for mentally ill or lifestyle-related illness?”
(17.3) What can a community do to provide safety for the mentally ill and safety for...
(17.3) What can a community do to provide safety for the mentally ill and safety for the community?
What are the laws pertaining to establishing and running a community home for mentally ill clients...
What are the laws pertaining to establishing and running a community home for mentally ill clients in texas? Discuss the pros and cons of this type of community group home for these clients. Discuss the pros and cons of this type of community group home for the neighborhood that it is in.
In regards to the mentally ill and domestic violence, what are 3 ways that we can...
In regards to the mentally ill and domestic violence, what are 3 ways that we can better reach this group with awareness and resources?
Mentally ill youth in crisis discussed Discrimination and Lack of (coordinated) care.
Mentally ill youth in crisis discussed Discrimination and Lack of (coordinated) care.
Compare the legal definition of insanity with the psychological concept of mentally ill. How do these...
Compare the legal definition of insanity with the psychological concept of mentally ill. How do these two terms differ? How does this distinction affect the validity of the insanity defense?
What resources should prisons provide for (a) mentally ill inmates, (b) pregnant inmates, (c) elderly inmates,...
What resources should prisons provide for (a) mentally ill inmates, (b) pregnant inmates, (c) elderly inmates, and (d) inmates with chronic and/or infectious diseases? What strategies should prisons use to prevent violence? Why? "Please type response due to me not understanding some handwriting." Thanks!
you will research " insane asylums" to better understand the stigma of being labeled mentally ill...
you will research " insane asylums" to better understand the stigma of being labeled mentally ill and assess how far mental health treatment has come. In two paragraphs describe how far mental health has come from " insane asylums" to what occurs today
Do you think there is a stigma associated with mentally ill persons today? Why or why...
Do you think there is a stigma associated with mentally ill persons today? Why or why not?
The Mentally Handicapped/Ill Inmate A significant number of inmates at all levels of corrections is made...
The Mentally Handicapped/Ill Inmate A significant number of inmates at all levels of corrections is made up of the mentally ill/handicapped. What is the impact of these inmates on the operations of a corrections facility, how many are there, what are their crimes? What is being done to properly treat the them? What legal requirements are in place to ensure proper treatment of the mentally ill/handicapped? What is a proper disposition for these offenders? Instructions for Writing Your Paper Write...
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT