Question

In: Operations Management

What are “competing constraints”? Illustrate any SIX (6) occasions where the Pak Elektron Limited (PEL) management...

What are “competing constraints”? Illustrate any SIX (6) occasions where the Pak Elektron Limited (PEL) management was dealing with these competing constraints and/or making trade-offs in the implementation of the new ERP system.

Solutions

Expert Solution

Pak Elektron Limited (PEL) is a Pakistani engineering corporation which manufactures major home appliances and electrical equipment.

The constraints faced by Pak Electron Limited are as follows :

1. Dealing with mental blockage of the employees

With the implementation of Oracle EBS a new skill set is required for all employees and thus training will be required. The mental capabilities and capacities of the employees is a potential constraint when implementing the new system. There is a running risk that some employees will not have sufficient knowledge to work under the new Oracle EBS. During the transitional period, the costs of the project is another constraint because the timeline for the transition is not clearly defined. Delays with the project are always a possibility, which could make the implementation of Oracle EBS go over budget. Once the new software is completely operational, employees with the new skill set will demand a higher wage or salary. On one hand it will motivate the employees to work harder, but the other hand the current trained staff will not be motivated. The overall scattered and segregated structure of PEL poses a problem when developing and implementing the Oracle EBS. It is nearly impossible for one version of any given Oracle EBS module to satisfy the needs of all the different areas of operation within PEL. Modernizing the information systems can cause gaps with regards to old and new information. Certain functions, from either the new or old systems, may not be available as a result of this mixed use of software.

2. A wide variety of operations

Due to the variety of operations within PEL, the new Oracle EBS system must be tailored to fit the specific needs of each “silo” of operations. In order to improve the structure that was originally in place at the company, the new Oracle EBS must be customizable for any given area of operations so that any information inputs thereafter can be used company-wide. Any legacy modules that are held over should have a middleware developed for it until a suitable module from the new Oracle EBS becomes available for use. The implementation plan must be actively reviewed throughout the process in order to avoid and/or troubleshoot any unsuspecting problems that may arise. The review process will ensure that the plan is moving along at the intended pace. A review of all legacy modules should be completed to determine and shut down any unused modules as a result of economic developments. This could in turn reduce the amount of work needed to develop and tailor new Oracle EBS modules from the Legacy applications.

3. Cash Flow Issues

The implementation of Oracle EBS experienced many delays, due to PEL’s cash flow problems. Due to the company needing to make a large investment for consultant support, new hardware, and new technical staff, it was decided that implementing the complete Oracle modules would be postponed. However, this led to the problem of transitioning from the Legacy applications to Oracle EBS as the primary system. A temporary solution, the Material Management System (MMS), was developed to bridge both information systems. Although MMS helped to eliminate the Legacy application, there were a few Oracle functions that were unavailable. This delayed the shutdown process of some of the Legacy applications because PEL relied on the Material Requirement Costing System (MRCS) bridged by MMS for at least the first quarter of 2012. Furthermore, the termination of Legacy applications was reliant on Phase II of the project, but it is unclear as to when exactly Phase II will begin to be implemented.

At the end of Phase I, 30 Legacy applications were supposed to be replaced into 8 Oracle EBS modules, however, 26 out of the 33 Legacy applications are currently in use, making the completion timeframe of the Oracle EBS project questionable. Another uncertainty for PEL with regards to cash flow is revenue. According to the PEL Divisional and Consolidated Performance Summary, revenue in the Power department was 50% lower at the 2011 half year mark in comparison to other years and both the power and appliance department are experiencing huge net losses. PEL has never had net losses in the previous years, thus there is concern that the new software implementation is doing more bad than good for the company. Implementing Oracle EBS has also caused concerns with the effectiveness in hiring new staff and retraining old staff. PEL wanted to hire new employees who were familiar with the Oracle EBS yet still needed employees who had experience with Visual FoxPro. Since Visual FoxPro was last updated in 2007, PEL has had difficulty in finding potential employees who were both knowledgeable with Visual FoxPro and Oracle, especially due to the money constraint.

4. Issues related to Shareholders directives and motives

Both the CFO and CIO of PEL understands that data entry is a huge component of the business and hopes to see it become more streamlined with the implementation of Oracle EBS. Once business operations are streamlined, the added efficiency and reduction of errors may provide a boost to company performance and help PEL with competing against rival companies. The new chief financial controller also wants to see the quality and timeliness of data entry and overall business operations to improve through the use of Oracle EBS. The financial controller is understanding of the fact that with a new ERP system comes a new set of skill requirements and as a result, he wishes to focus on team development and training for both current and new employees in the use of the Oracle EBS software.

Shareholders of PEL wish to see the company prosper and most likely support the reasoning for implementing the new ERP system. They will be looking at the financial statements to determine the impact of the new Oracle BBS on revenue and relevant ratios. If PEL is seeking a loan from a bank to finance this transition, then they must prove to the banks that this new system is in fact worth the risk for potential rewards in order to secure funds. Banks will be interested in the timeline of the project as well as the financial reports for PEL to ensure the company transition to Oracle EBS is smooth, accurate, and beneficial. Moreover, they will be analyzing the potential consequences of the software transition.

5. Alternatives available for the implementtion phase

One alternative is to revert back to the Legacy applications. In the Phase I process of over a year and a half, at least 21 Legacy applications were supposed to be converted into the Oracle EBS modules and only 7 were actually converted. Hence, to save time and money, PEL would be better off with their original business process. Things cannot completely go back to the way they were due to the lower number of staff and change in staff, but if PEL wants to have net profits again, they will find a way to motivate and strengthen their workforce. On the other hand, PEL could keep their current information systems, but take a look into other ERP software that have been released. Since the time when the Oracle BBS software was chosen at the end of 2009, newer and more affordable ERP options have become available and could possibly be a better fit for PEL. When choosing one of these recently available software options, PEL must take the costs and timeframe of the implementation, compatibility with the Legacy applications and Oracle modules, customization of the software, and training and/or hiring of staff into consideration.

As the CFO had already analyzed ERP software solutions in 2007, PEL should hire an information systems consultant to review the current state of the company’s ERP system and determine the best solution to help move the company forward. If PEL still believes that the Oracle EBS software is the best solution for the company, they could also hire the information systems consultant to work with Iftikhar Ahmed to analyze the past months of implementation and suggest where improvements can be made. Although this will be another cost for PEL, the savings from the consultant’s suggestions would outweigh that cost. The consultant could help PEL figure out how to conclude the implementation of Oracle EBS by their deadline, the first quarter of 2012.

Senior management will have to be much more involved with the ERP project, especially since this has now become a serious business priority. They will have to find additional ways to raise the capital needed for the complete transition of Oracle EBS. One possibility is a larger bank loan with higher interest to mitigate the risk. PEL can convince the bank that with their new manufacturing facility and company restructuring, revenue will increase in the future. Another possibility is raising more capital, but PEL will have to take their major shareholder Saigol Group of companies into consideration.

6. Dealing with high employee turnover ratio

Having a high employee turnover rate with employees potentially feeling confused, disgruntled, and insecure about their position at the company along with weak senior management support does not help with the changes being implemented. The overall company structure of PEL contributed to the slow roll out of Oracle EBS. First and foremost, various staff members were responsible for various modules. Either responsibilities were overlapping or the amount of support given towards specific modules was spread too thinly, as evidenced in exhibit 10. PEL’s business has distinct of production lines and mentions that they each have different cost structures. As a result modules must be specifically tailored to each sector of the business in order to accommodate the special requirements. This will end up being more costly for PEL to roll out the modules and further delay the implementation plan. Furthermore, the workforce of PEL is widespread an


Related Solutions

The static perspective: Where is Amazon competing? What is the product? How is Amazon competing? What...
The static perspective: Where is Amazon competing? What is the product? How is Amazon competing? What is the basis for Amazon's competitive advantage? The dynamic perspective—the firm's preparation for the future: What does Amazon want to become? What does Amazon want to achieve? How will Amazon get there?
List any six (6) legislations and six (6) organisational policies relevant to planning and implementing a...
List any six (6) legislations and six (6) organisational policies relevant to planning and implementing a mentoring program.
6 What is a constraint? Explain the Theory of Constraints.
6 What is a constraint? Explain the Theory of Constraints.
What are the six core components to CM (Case Management) practice? The following scenarios are where...
What are the six core components to CM (Case Management) practice? The following scenarios are where CM would be beneficial. Comment on the goals of CM for these patients: a) patient who had a stroke during biopsy that is positive for cancer b) liver transplant patient readmitted for surgery for bowel blockage c) elderly depressed patient who has just had third surgery to manage low back pain
First, review the "triple constraints" of IT Project Management as covered in this week's reading "What...
First, review the "triple constraints" of IT Project Management as covered in this week's reading "What is Project Management?" Note that there are more than 3 constraints discussed in the article. The illustration above from the article shows the author's interpretation of the "triple constraints." Group C: Please address the following 3 questions: Which of the triple constraints do you think is the most important for the project of implementing an enterprise hiring system for CIC? You should address from...
53. What are the three primary constraints in project management? -A Schedule, cost, and deadline -...
53. What are the three primary constraints in project management? -A Schedule, cost, and deadline - B Outsourcing, sponsors, and budget - C Time, scope, and resources - D Testing, accptance, and operation - -54. Which document outlines participation by various roles in a project? -A Communication plan B- PERT chart - C Responsibility matrix D Gantt chart 55. The relationship among the variables of the triple constraints is such that if any one variable changes, at least one other...
Banks are exposed to various types of risk. Discuss any SIX (6) types of risk that...
Banks are exposed to various types of risk. Discuss any SIX (6) types of risk that could effect the bank’s position. 5 paragraph with examples . TQ
What are the six basic elements of a performance management program?
What are the six basic elements of a performance management program?
What were three explanations for the great depression? Where appropriate, illustrate with a graph.
What were three explanations for the great depression? Where appropriate, illustrate with a graph.
six differences between manager and a leader? what a manager is and does? what management is?...
six differences between manager and a leader? what a manager is and does? what management is? what a leader is and does? what is leadership? explain management and leadership styles?
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT