In: Finance
An office uses 1,000 photocopies per working day and there are
200 working days per year. Brand A copier costs $3,000 and will
produce a total of one million copies before it wears out. Brand
B’s copier costs $5,000 and will produce 2 million copies over its
life. Maintenance and materials cost 3 cents per copy with either
machine, and neither machine will have any salvage value. The
required return is 10 percent per year. Which machine should the
company acquire.
Please solve with out using excel. and show steps please.
Annual requirement of photocopies = Daily required photocopy x working days per year
=1,000 x 200 = 200,000
Useful life of Brand A copier = Total capacity / Annual requirement
= 1,000,000/200,000 = 5 years
Useful life of Brand B copier = Total capacity / Annual requirement
= 2,000,000/200,000 = 10 years
We can compute EAC of both copiers to analyze and choose best option as they have unequal life span.
EAC = Asset price x Discount rate/ [1-(1+Discount rate)-Number of periods] + Annual expense
EAC of Copier A = $ 3,000 x 0.1 / [(1 – (1+0.1)-5 ]+ $ 0.03 x 200,000
= $ 3,000 x 0.1 / [(1 – (1.1)-5 ]+ $ 6,000
= $ 300 / [(1 – (1.1)-5 ]+ $ 6,000
= $ 300 / (1 – 0.620921323059155) + $ 6,000
= $ 300 / 0.379078676940845 + $ 6,000
= $ 791.392442384236 + 6,000 = $ 6,791.39244238424 or $ 6,791.39
EAC of Copier B = $ 5,000 x 0.1 / [(1 – (1+0.1)-10 ]+ $ 0.03 x 200,000
= $ 5,000 x 0.1 / [(1 – (1.1)-10 ]+ $ 6,000
= $ 500 / [(1 – (1.1)-10 ]+ $ 6,000
= $ 500 / (1 – 0.385543289429531) + $ 6,000
= $ 500 / 0.614456710570469 + $ 6,000
= $ 813.726974412558 + 6,000 = $ 6,813.72697441256 or $ 6,813.73
Copier A should be acquired as its equivalent annual cost is less than that of Copier B.