Question

In: Biology

answer both questions 1.What does it mean for a trait to have an appropriate amount of...

answer both questions
1.What does it mean for a trait to have an appropriate amount of variation for a use in a phylogenetic analysis? Use examples

2.Why is using parsimony with morphological data problematic?


Solutions

Expert Solution

Explaining with examples

1.Assume the size that communities assembled from many phylogenetic lineages show large functional diversity if assembly is random, but low functional diversity if assembly is controlled by interactions between species within lineages. We combined less than  9000 varities of Dutch plant communities, a species‐level phylogeny, and information on 16 functional traits (including eight dispersal traits). We found that all traits were conserved within lineages, but nevertheless communities assembled from many lineages showed a smaller variation in trait‐states of most traits (including dispersal traits) than communities assembled from few lineages. Hence, within lineages, species are not randomly assembled into communities, contradicting Neutral Theory. In fact, we find evidence for evolutionary divergence in trait‐states as well as present‐day mutual exclusion among related, similar species, suggesting that functional diversity of communities increased due to past and present interactions between species within lineages.

2.First of all more you've got homoplasy more parsimony is problematic. It means (in my mind of course) that parsimony is working well as soon as you've got a moderate rate of mutations. A way to partially solve it is to use a Goloboff correction....but it is not optimal

As you know mitochondrial genes are clearly biased for AT especially in "our" insects.

Anyway, when it is possible, I prefer to compare parsimony, phenetic and maxlik trees and discuss the 3 approaches rather than using a single method.

I had many problems with MrBayes......Bayesian statistics are extremely powerful for many things...but I'm not fan for phylogenetic analysis.

To summarize, flaws exist for all the available methods, we've got just to accept that and staying cautious in our conclusions !!!


Related Solutions

what does trait hertability mean ?
what does trait hertability mean ?
If the narrow sense heritability of a trait is 0, what does this mean? Does this mean a trait is entirely determined by environment?
If the narrow sense heritability of a trait is 0, what does this mean? Does this mean a trait is entirely determined by environment? Explain all the contributions to total phenotypic variance.
Short Answer Questions: 1.) What does the term "economizing problem" mean for an individual and for...
Short Answer Questions: 1.) What does the term "economizing problem" mean for an individual and for society? As part of your answer, include the four economic resources and the opportunity cost in your answer. 2.) What are the four assumptions in the production possibilities curve and how can unemployment be illustrated with that curve. You do not need to draw it, you need to explain it. Additionally, what does it mean when the curve shifts to the right? 3.) Explain...
Answer the following questions. a. What does it mean to say that b is a divisor...
Answer the following questions. a. What does it mean to say that b is a divisor of a? b. What is the meaning of the expression a divides b? c. What is the Congruent Modulo n ? Support your answer with one example of Congruent Modulo n. d. What is a prime number? Support your answer with one example of two integers are relatively prime. e. What is the difference between active and passive attacks?
What does it mean to have a “future taxable amount” and give an example of a...
What does it mean to have a “future taxable amount” and give an example of a temporary difference that would create a deferred tax liability, and what does it mean to have a “future deductible amount” and give an example of a temporary difference that would create a deferred tax asset?
Please answer the following questions: 1.What does it mean “Fiat Money” and why did the modern...
Please answer the following questions: 1.What does it mean “Fiat Money” and why did the modern economies move to this payments system? 2.Calculate the total increase in deposit of a bank in the following case: Initial deposit: $ 2,000 RRR: 20 percent 3. Which component of the Federal Reserve System decides on the reserve requirement and what will be the effect of its reduction? Please answer them properly and Write in PRINT!
What does it mean to have a critical lens? What does it mean to have a...
What does it mean to have a critical lens? What does it mean to have a gender/sex lens?
What does it means for a trait to have evolved convergently. Be sure to include the...
What does it means for a trait to have evolved convergently. Be sure to include the terms ancestor and descendant. Give one example of convergent evolution in nature, and explain what makes it convergence rather than homology.
What does it mean to have a good life? What does it mean to be a...
What does it mean to have a good life? What does it mean to be a good person?
Whether or NOT it is appropriate, answer the following concerning the test of the mean. What...
Whether or NOT it is appropriate, answer the following concerning the test of the mean. What is the value of the appropriate test statistic for the statistical test of the mean? Note: Input Answer you calculate to 3 Decimal Places. DATA BELOW: The Population Mean for daily high temperatures in Hawaii for the month of January is 80 degrees; however, the Population Standard Deviation is Unknown. A researcher tests whether mean January temperatures in Hawaii have been significantly higher over...
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT