Judges, lawyers, politicians, and scholars have long debated theories of how our nation's Constitution should be...

Judges, lawyers, politicians, and scholars have long debated theories of how our nation's Constitution should be understood and applied to the issues of our day. Originalists believe that the Constitution should be understood according to its political meaning. Others see the Constitution as a living document whose meaning evolves over time.

Who is right in this argument, and why?

Solutions

Expert Solution

In my opinion, the individuals who believe that Constitution as a living document whose meaning evolves over time are having the appropriate opinion. This is due to the fact that constitution provides the guidelines of how the nation will be governed under specific circumstances or under the prevailing situation. There can be a lot of variation in the situation where the constitution was formed and when it is being cited for getting the help of resolving any issue. The constitution is a living document and it should be changed and in fact, it is being changed by the parliament or the Congress time to time so that it can accommodate the requirement of the current situation. The provisions and laws which were made earlier may be completely obsolete in a present scenario and thus some new norms and laws are formed old are revised or modified or abandoned. Thus, the constitution is a living phenomenon which changes as per the requirement of the current situation of the society and the country.

keosha answered 11 months ago

Next > < Previous

Related Solutions

4. Policymakers have long debated whether employees should be required to join a union. Federal law...

4. Policymakers have long debated whether employees should be required to join a union. Federal law allows unions to negotiate security clauses in collective bargaining. However, the Taft-Hartley Act of 1947 allows states to pass right-to-work laws to make security clauses illegal. The year is 1946 and you are the leader of a small craft union in Missouri. You are in the midst of bargaining for a new contract and you must select a form of security clause to include...

is justice for sale ? How should Texas judges get their job?

“Criminologists have long debated whether there is [an association] between weather and violent crime. The author...

“Criminologists have long debated whether there is [an association] between weather and violent crime. The author of the article "Is There a Season for Homicide?" (Criminology (1988): 287 - 296) classified [1352] homicides according to season, resulting in the accompany data.” Results of the author’s study found the following counts of homicide in the population studied. • winter = 311 • spring = 320 • summer = 401 • fall = 320 Does it appear that homicide counts differ by...

The power of judicial review is not mentioned in the U.S. Constitution (although many constitutional scholars believe that the founders intended the judiciary to have this power).

write a summary in your own words. The Origins of Judicial Review in the United States The power of judicial review is not mentioned in the U.S. Constitution (although many constitutional scholars believe that the founders intended the judiciary to have this power). The United States Supreme Court explicitly established this power in 1803 in the case Marbury v. Madison. In that decision, the Court stated, “It is emphatically the province [authority] and duty of the Judicial Department to say...

At times, politicians have argued that we should have a law that requires Congress to balance...

At times, politicians have argued that we should have a law that requires Congress to balance the federal budget. Some politicians believe this is the fiscally responsible approach while others think it is better to allow the federal government the leeway to determine the budget based on the state of the economy. Some politicians worry about running a deficit as this will add to the federal debt. Most states in the US have balanced budgets. What are the arguments for...

Question: At times, politicians have argued that we should have a law that requires Congress to...

Question: At times, politicians have argued that we should have a law that requires Congress to balance the... At times, politicians have argued that we should have a law that requires Congress to balance the federal budget. Some politicians believe this is the fiscally responsible approach while others think it is better to allow the federal government the leeway to determine the budget based on the state of the economy. Some politicians worry about running a deficit as this will...

How did the framers of our constitution harmonize majority rule with individual rights? and how do...

How did the framers of our constitution harmonize majority rule with individual rights? and how do we still struggle with this same tension today?

Historians have debated whether or not the Cotton Kingdom (1820s-Civil War) should be considered a capitalist...

Historians have debated whether or not the Cotton Kingdom (1820s-Civil War) should be considered a capitalist society. I'm not sure how to form my argumentative essay on this topic. I'm curious to hear from someone what the main points of debate are on both sides of this topic. Here are my specific questions: a. What is the definition of a capitalist society? This seems to be a highly debated area (especially when it comes to this debate). b. What are...

The Constitution is a revered document that guides politics today... but how should it be interpreted?...

The Constitution is a revered document that guides politics today... but how should it be interpreted? How strictly should we interpret the Constitution? Is America still ruled by "WE THE PEOPLE"? Can it adapt to a 21st century America and does it need to?

Discuss how the balance of payments can affect a nation's economy. What types of policies should...

Discuss how the balance of payments can affect a nation's economy. What types of policies should be put in place to correct trade imbalance? Discuss with peers. Please post with 200+ words.

Subjects