is justice for sale ? How should Texas judges get their job?

Solutions

Expert Solution

The justice system in Texas has been scrutinized for over a decade since a major television expose probed the influence of campaign money on judicial decision-making. Now, with Texas Governor George W. Bush running strong for president, everything about the state, including its courts, is being examined. The Governor has been unequivocal in his support of judicial elections as the way to select judges in Texas, but others in the state--including many who are intimately involved or high-placed in the system--are searching for alternatives. (Note: Texas is one of three states whose judicial election process was examined in FRONTLINE's.

Judges should be independent and should not have to run for election. We have a code ofethics and are limited by what we can and can't say. We can't make promises and can't prejudge a case, often what those seeking political office do. Additionally, who are we most likely to raise money from? The lawyers who appear before us. Not a good practice.Running for election takes time away from doing what we are being paid to do - be fair and impartial judges, rule on cases in a timely manner, and not be swayed by public opinion - inessence be an independent judiciary.

Rahul Sunny answered 1 year ago

Next > < Previous

Related Solutions

Judges are powerful players in the criminal Justice System. Theyrule on admissibility of evidence and...

Judges are powerful players in the criminal Justice System. They rule on admissibility of evidence and testimony. They sign affidavits for search and arrest warrants, and sentence defendants found guilty of criminal offenses, and make rulings on civil cases.Please describe how judges are selected to the bench.( appointed,Elected).Give your opinion good or bad on these methods with attention given to the present confirmation process we are witnessing for a Supreme court Justice.

Should judges cultivate a more strict-constructionist or liberal-constructionist judicial philosophy? Also, should judges with the philosophy...

Should judges cultivate a more strict-constructionist or liberal-constructionist judicial philosophy? Also, should judges with the philosophy you select be more judicially restrained or judicially active? Create a unified and cohesive argument.(summary) Form a claim by selecting one option from each of the two questions above. Include and defend at least two arguments for each claim. For question two, include and rebut at least one counterargument.

How should Texas deal with increasing rates of incarceration? Should Texas decriminalize certain behavior, reduce sentence...

How should Texas deal with increasing rates of incarceration? Should Texas decriminalize certain behavior, reduce sentence lengths, invest in crime prevention (such as drug and alcohol rehabilitation), or build more prisons?

"Union activity should promote justice and job security for all workers" Analyze the role of unions...

"Union activity should promote justice and job security for all workers" Analyze the role of unions in utilizing the collective bargaining machinery to effectively achieve equity in the workplace. Please state examples to substantiate your response.

Suppose you wanted to evaluate the performance of the three judges in Smallville, Texas: Judge Adams,...

Suppose you wanted to evaluate the performance of the three judges in Smallville, Texas: Judge Adams, Judge Brown, and Judge Carter. Over a three-year period in Smallville, Judge Adams saw 26% of the cases, Judge Brown saw 33% of the cases, and Judge Carter saw the remainder of the cases. 3% of Judge Adams’ cases were appealed, 6% of Judge Brown’s cases were appealed, and 9% of Judge Carter’s cases were appealed. (See the case problem on pages 216-218 of...

Suppose you wanted to evaluate the performance of the three judges in Smallville, Texas: Judge Adams,...

Suppose you wanted to evaluate the performance of the three judges in Smallville, Texas: Judge Adams, Judge Brown, and Judge Carter. Over a three-year period in Smallville, Judge Adams saw 26% of the cases, Judge Brown saw 34% of the cases, and Judge Carter saw the remainder of the cases. 3% of Judge Adams’ cases were appealed, 6% of Judge Brown’s cases were appealed, and 9% of Judge Carter’s cases were appealed. Given the judge in a case from this...

Describe the various courts found in the Texas justice system. What are some of the benefits...

Describe the various courts found in the Texas justice system. What are some of the benefits and drawbacks of electing state judges?

Should Texas afford greater protections to individuals than offered by the Federal Government, or should Texas...

Should Texas afford greater protections to individuals than offered by the Federal Government, or should Texas provide the same freedoms afforded by the US Constitution. Does this hinder or help law-enforcement procedures in Texas?

Judges, lawyers, politicians, and scholars have long debated theories of how our nation's Constitution should be...

Judges, lawyers, politicians, and scholars have long debated theories of how our nation's Constitution should be understood and applied to the issues of our day. Originalists believe that the Constitution should be understood according to its political meaning. Others see the Constitution as a living document whose meaning evolves over time. Who is right in this argument, and why?

Should the Texas legislature meet annually?

Subjects