Question

In: Psychology

A key part of critical thinking, especially when using inductive reasoning, requires us to evaluate sources...

A key part of critical thinking, especially when using inductive reasoning, requires us to evaluate sources of information. That is, whether or not they're credible. Therefore, it's vitally important we develop good source analysis skills. The following 4 websites were used as references for academic papers. evaluate whether they were good, credible sources for the assignment's topic? Be sure to explain your reasoning.

Paper 1: Topic: Why hands wrinkle with prolonged bathing. Source #1: http://www.npr.org/2013/01/11/169144851/getting-a-handle-on-why-fingers-wrinkle

Paper 2: Topic: Is it safer smoking tobacco using hookah? Source #2: https://www.cdc.gov/tobacco/data_statistics/fact_sheets/tobacco_industry/hookahs/index.htm

Paper 3: Topic: Does the painting, Judith Beheading Holofernes by Artemisia Gentileschi circa 1620, have aesthetic value? Websites: Source #3: https://leafcollector.wordpress.com/2010/02/23/judith-slaying-holofernes-artemisia-gentileschi/ Source #4: http://www.arthistoryarchive.com/arthistory/baroque/Artemisia-Gentileschi.html

Solutions

Expert Solution

Note: This response is in UK English, please paste the response to MS Word and you should be able to spot discrepancies easily. You may elaborate the answer based on personal views or your classwork if necessary. Also, the third paper has a 404 error for the article.

(Answer) Inductive reasoning is when the logic is induced or caused by the source. By this form of reasoning, a statement is reasonable if its source is reasonable.

Paper 1: In this dialogue, Lichtman discusses why human fingers wrinkle when they get wet. After carrying on the discussion, Lichtman says that Mark Changizi who is a neuroscientist, has found out why wet fingers wrinkle. It turns out that it is an evolutionary trait that enabled early man to have better grip under water. Furthermore, he conducted a study of Japanese macaques in hot springs water to support his hypothesis.

Mark Changizi is a legitimate theoretical cognitive scientist who specialises in evolutionary studies. Therefore, the discussion in this paper revolves around legitimate information.

Paper 2: American Lung Association and U.S. Department of Health and Human Services are two of the top contributors to this study. I reckon most of the statistics are legible. However, in certain places, the authors mention that a small study that was conducted gave them the results. The authors do not mention certain institutions or authors that may have conducted the research. Although the major facts of this paper are sourced from proper studies, they seem to be connected with “filler” information that is used simply to help prove the hypothesis.


Related Solutions

Your understanding of: Critical Thinking, Clinical Judgement, Clinical reasoning.
Your understanding of: Critical Thinking, Clinical Judgement, Clinical reasoning. Use one resource
Part A Briefly explain the concept of integrated reporting Critical evaluate four key attributes of integrated...
Part A Briefly explain the concept of integrated reporting Critical evaluate four key attributes of integrated reporting which would enhance the capabilities of traditional financial reporting in providing high-quality information. Part B What are the two types of accounting theories that you have studied during semester 2, 2020 and what is the objective of each? Give an example of each type of theory.
Clinical Reasoning, Decision Making and Critical Thinking We will use this scenario and build on it...
Clinical Reasoning, Decision Making and Critical Thinking We will use this scenario and build on it over the next 4 weeks. Scenario: Patient is a 68-year male patient who has a history of fluid and electrolyte imbalance. Mr. Donald is status post coronary artery bypass graft (CABG) 3 days ago. He also has multiple co-morbidities, colon cancer, anemia, and hypertension.   Alterations in fluid and electrolyte status are common in the elderly population. Therefore, maintaining and managing fluid and electrolyte balance...
Considering only the Introduction to Chapter 5, in terms of developing critical thinking and reasoning, what...
Considering only the Introduction to Chapter 5, in terms of developing critical thinking and reasoning, what do you consider is the most valuable and important idea in that section? You can either summarize or directly quote the text; then, briefly explain why you find this idea important and valuable?
Based on your understanding of critical thinking and memory, describe one (1) flaw in Bruce's reasoning
Based on your understanding of critical thinking and memory, describe one (1) flaw in Bruce's reasoning
Key Assessment: Stereotypes and Barriers to Critical Thinking Unit 2 Key Assignment: Stereotypes and Barriers to...
Key Assessment: Stereotypes and Barriers to Critical Thinking Unit 2 Key Assignment: Stereotypes and Barriers to Critical Thinking Estimated time to complete: 10 Hours Instructions: In this course so far we have discovered stereotypes and how they can have an impact from the perspective of others. For this key assignment you will be conducting research and writing a paper on stereotypes and how they act as barriers to critical thinking. Please follow these guidelines and questions: Specifically you will be...
Unit 2 Key Assessment: Stereotypes and Barriers to Critical Thinking Unit 2 Key Assignment: Stereotypes and...
Unit 2 Key Assessment: Stereotypes and Barriers to Critical Thinking Unit 2 Key Assignment: Stereotypes and Barriers to Critical Thinking Estimated time to complete: In this course so far we have discovered stereotypes and how they can have an impact from the perspective of others. For this key assignment you will be conducting research and writing a paper on stereotypes and how they act as barriers to critical thinking. Please follow these guidelines and questions: Specifically you will be investigating...
Thinking of the previous question, what kinds of things would you need answered before you could determine the inductive strength of my reasoning?
 Thinking of the previous question, what kinds of things would you need answered before you could determine the inductive strength of my reasoning? List at least 3 questions you’d want answered.
explain what part do language and communication play in critical thinking
explain what part do language and communication play in critical thinking
Critical Thinking: Nebraska is required to balance its state budget. The primary internal sources of revenue...
Critical Thinking: Nebraska is required to balance its state budget. The primary internal sources of revenue for Nebraska are income tax and sales tax. Externally, Nebraska, like all states, also receives a block grant from the Federal Government, but this might end. If the country goes into a recession and people both earn and spend less money, the state will receive less revenue. How can the state then maintain a balanced budget?
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT