Question

In: Psychology

In Chapter 3 of Structure of Scientific Revolutions, Kuhn discusses the “box” of the paradigm and...

In Chapter 3 of Structure of Scientific Revolutions, Kuhn discusses the “box” of the paradigm and describes efforts to place all the events of nature within that box. What are the advantages and/or dangers associated with attempting to place social science in a box? Use the case of behaviorism to make your point; did behaviorism become confined to a box and, if so, to what consequence?

Solutions

Expert Solution

Answer:-

According to the scientific revolutionary philosopher Thomas Kuhn, science represents what he called a ‘paradigm’. That is, scientists constitute a culture of their own and their beliefs and academic behaviours are governed by certain implicit And explicit norms which validate their perspective on objectivity and positivism. To this end, the scientist community can promote and generate only those ideas which can fit the similitude of their common beliefs. Thus, a major critique of positivist science can be that it loses the larger vision of generating novel ideas and instead focuses on fitting theories and research within existing, confined “boxes”. Research in social science then becomes a strenuous practice of forcing nature into the conceptual boxes acquired from ones educational experience. However, scientific revolutions can also emerge in this situation when there is dissent in the community about the existing normative practices within a discipline and this leads to emergence of a new set of theory or a paradigm shift.

Kuhn’s Ideas on scientifc revolution is significant as it can be used as framework to evaluate the potential decay within the system of theories in the social sciences. Within Psychology, we can see how certain ideas which may have been revolutionary at the time of their emergence had become archaic over the decades. Thus for instance,Watsonian behaviourism at one point provided a practical way to apply the psychological theories to resolve the real life problems in society such as the use of conditioning in treating phobias, aggressive behaviour in young adults, etc. however, a the same time, it can be seen that the treatment model within behaviourism itself has been influenced by the cultural politics of the time. Thus for instance, classical conditioning and punishment were increasingly applied as ways to give institutionalised treatment to even the sexual minorities since homosexuality was stereotyped as a pathology. Thus, in a way, a behavioural therapist too was prone to fall short of te ideal of objectivity and his/her treatment approach was built towards perpetuation of even some the draconian and inhuman practices in society.

In the end, it appears that a once revolutionary theory of objective behaviourism ended up being confined to a box of concepts such a study behaviour and environment (S-R chains) and it became oblivious to some of the more dynamic aspects of human life such as emotional, interpersonal relationships, the myriad of simple and complex cognitive processes, unconscious motives, etc.


Related Solutions

1. According to Kuhn, what is a paradigm? What is its role in scientific discovery and...
1. According to Kuhn, what is a paradigm? What is its role in scientific discovery and can paradigms be compared? Explain. Point out at least one strength and one weakness to Kuhn’s theory of paradigms as applied to the field of engineering.
Q1 . The authors cite the explanation of Thomas Kuhn (author of The Structure of Scientific...
Q1 . The authors cite the explanation of Thomas Kuhn (author of The Structure of Scientific Revolutions) of how a change of 'looking at the world' (Khun's term is "paradigm shift") within the practice of science takes place. The authors compare the views of Copernicus and Ptolemy regarding the structure of our solar system as an example: a.Copernicus and Ptolemy used the same assumptions to organize a different set of facts and came to the same conclusion. b.Copernicus and Ptolemy...
Is regulation part of the structure-conduct performance paradigm?
Is regulation part of the structure-conduct performance paradigm?
Chapter 3 discusses social behavior, and some of the variables that allow humans to be “ultrasocial”...
Chapter 3 discusses social behavior, and some of the variables that allow humans to be “ultrasocial” (existing in vary large cooperative societies). Philosophically, think about this chapter in terms of the Social Contract, and what seems to be necessary in order to maintain the Social Contract (and we’ll discuss that more fully in class). The main idea that Haidt puts forth in this context is that reciprocity is key to upholding the Social Contract, and living socially. So after reading...
Two examples are the Scientific and Industrial Revolutions. Burke says, "together with the Industrial Revolution came...
Two examples are the Scientific and Industrial Revolutions. Burke says, "together with the Industrial Revolution came the modern expectation of progress and a better standard of living made possible by men's skills and the machines they invented..." He goes on to credit the Industrial Revolution with promoting both capitalism and giving birth to socialism among other things and claims that it changed society, making "modern urban society dependent on mass-production techniques without which we cannot now survive" (1985/1995, page 193)....
"The Bindler-Ball Healthcare Model: A New Paradigm for Health Promotion" discusses a new model for child...
"The Bindler-Ball Healthcare Model: A New Paradigm for Health Promotion" discusses a new model for child health nursing. Provide a brief summary of the article and evaluate the merits of the model. If a health care organization decided to implement this model, what types of communication would need to happen to make the implementation a success?
This chapter discusses "Firms in a competitive market," concepts like monopolies, etc. 3) Determine whether the...
This chapter discusses "Firms in a competitive market," concepts like monopolies, etc. 3) Determine whether the following statements are true or false. Explain your answers. a) A firm will make a profit when the price it charges exceeds the average variable cost of the chosen output level. b) To maximize profits in the short run, a firm must minimize its costs. c) if economic profit is positive, firms will exit the market in the short run d) A firm that...
This chapter discusses companies that are oligopolists in the market for the goods they sell. Many...
This chapter discusses companies that are oligopolists in the market for the goods they sell. Many of the same ideas apply to companies that are oligopolists in the market for the inputs they buy. If sellers who are oligopolists try to increase the price of goods they sell, the goal of buyers who are oligopolists is to try to decrease the prices of goods they buy. Major league baseball team owners have an oligopoly in the market for baseball players....
Chapter 2: Chapter 2 shows and discusses the gains from trade that can result when individuals,...
Chapter 2: Chapter 2 shows and discusses the gains from trade that can result when individuals, firms, or countries specialize in producing goods for which they have a comparative advantage, and trade those goods with others. Gains from specialization and exchange can be seen in many situations. For example, most people that we pay to do things for us (e.g. grow our food, cut our hair, tutor us, etc.) perform the task for a lower opportunity cost than we would...
The chapter discusses tool, techniques, and the advantages in adopting philosophies such as JIT or Lean....
The chapter discusses tool, techniques, and the advantages in adopting philosophies such as JIT or Lean. What are some of the disadvantages and challengeswith these philosophies (if any)?
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT