Question

In: Operations Management

What are McGregor's Theory X and Theory Y? Which do you think is more valid and...

What are McGregor's Theory X and Theory Y? Which do you think is more valid and why??

Solutions

Expert Solution

McGregor's Theory states that there are two contrasting theories specific to the two styles of management which are used based on the motivation level of the workforce.

Theory X - This theory is about the "Authroitarian Leadership style" which is used when the employees do not like theor work or they are demotivated to work. The managers in this scenario use an authoritarian style where they mircromanage the employees to get the work done.

Theory Y - This theory is about the "Participative Leadership style" which is used when the employees are motivated to work and require challenges. In this scenario, the managers act as facilitators and provide the employees all the resources to accomplish their jobs.

Theory Y is more valid in most cases as it not only increases the overall productivity at work. The approach motivates the employees to work hard and take challenges. It makes a manager's job easy and avoids conflicts at work.


Related Solutions

Compare and contrast modernization theory and dependency theory. Which do you think is more useful for...
Compare and contrast modernization theory and dependency theory. Which do you think is more useful for explaining global inequality? Explain, using examples.
4. What are theory X and theory Y? Give example of Theory X and Theory Y...
4. What are theory X and theory Y? Give example of Theory X and Theory Y management styles.
What do you think of Howard Gardner's theory of Multiple Intelligence? Do you think that people...
What do you think of Howard Gardner's theory of Multiple Intelligence? Do you think that people can be smart in ways that aren't easily measured by a test? When looking at Gardner's types of intelligence, which ones do you think fit you best? Please write 1-2 paragraphs responding to the above questions.
What do you think about Erikson's theory in regards to Adolescence? How do you think it...
What do you think about Erikson's theory in regards to Adolescence? How do you think it is connected to the three different areas of development (Physical, Cognitive, and Emotional/Social) during this period? please explainn
What do you think about Merton's Structural Strain Theory? Do you agree with his theory of...
What do you think about Merton's Structural Strain Theory? Do you agree with his theory of deviance? Why, or why not?
Question: 1) Which project do you think is more risky? How do you think you should...
Question: 1) Which project do you think is more risky? How do you think you should incorporate differences in risk into your analysis? Question: 2) Based on the calculated payback period, net present value (NPV), and internal rate of return (IRR) for each project, which project looks better for New Balance sharehold-ers? Why? Question: 3) Should Rodriguez be more or less critical of cash flow forecasts for Persistence than of cash flow forecasts for Sneaker 2013? Why? Question: 4) What...
Which do you think is more important for organizations: downward communication or upward communication? What is...
Which do you think is more important for organizations: downward communication or upward communication? What is the "grapevine" and what role does it play in organizational communications, Are there problems with the grapevine?
What is your view on "standardized versus localized" advertising? Which do you think is more effective?...
What is your view on "standardized versus localized" advertising? Which do you think is more effective? Why?
In your opinion, do you think leadership gaps, in general, fall more within “Theory” or “Practice?”...
In your opinion, do you think leadership gaps, in general, fall more within “Theory” or “Practice?” Explain. Use examples of your own organization or an organization with which you are familiar. For example, a high profile organization such as Toyota or BP may add richness to the discussion.
Which do you think is a more accurate view of the economy, the Keynesian or Classical...
Which do you think is a more accurate view of the economy, the Keynesian or Classical View?. Explain.
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT