Question

In: Psychology

The following passage contains an argument that commits at least one informal fallacy. Name the type...

The following passage contains an argument that commits at least one informal fallacy. Name the type of fallacy committed and explain why the passage is an example of that type.
That biscotti ought to be good—I used only the best ingredients in it.

Solutions

Expert Solution

Note: This response is in UK English, please paste the response to MS Word and you should be able to spot discrepancies easily. You may elaborate the answer based on personal views or your classwork if necessary.

(Answer) “That biscotti ought to be good – I’ve only used the best ingredients in it.”

The statement implies that simply because the ingredients are good, the biscotti must be equally delicious. However, when cooking there are other things to consider, for instance, cooking techniques, recipes, and correct ingredients added at the right time during preparation.

The statement tries to imply propositional logic. Basically, the sentence connects two elements in order to come to a logical conclusion, that is, good ingredients equal a good dish. However, the logic is flawed because all of the elements are not considered in the statement.

This is known as association fallacy. In other words, it is assumed that the dish will be gob because the ingredients associated with it are good. The problem here is that association is not an absolute indicator of a correct conclusion.


Related Solutions

Any argument that depends on an ambiguity commits the fallacy of equivocation the fallacy of begging...
Any argument that depends on an ambiguity commits the fallacy of equivocation the fallacy of begging the question the fallacy of appealing to ignorance the gambler's fallacy none of the above As a contestant on a game show you win the following prize. You are allowed to blindly choose one card from a regular deck. If you get a heart, you win $29; otherwise you win $13. The expected payoff of this opportunity is: $14 $15 $16 $17 $18 You...
A. Decide whether each passage should be thought of as containing no argument, one argument, or...
A. Decide whether each passage should be thought of as containing no argument, one argument, or more than one argument. For each argument, determine whether it is simple or complex (whether it contains only one or more than one inference), pick out any premise or conclusion indicators, and identify each premise and conclusion. example: 1. The snow is making driving conditions very dangerous. But I must still go out and vote, even though my candidate has no chance of winning....
Instructions: Identify the fallacy of relevance that appears in the following passage. Either you accept that...
Instructions: Identify the fallacy of relevance that appears in the following passage. Either you accept that this legislation is good, or we will vote you out of office. The appeal to emotion The red herring The straw man The attack on the person The appeal to force Missing the point (irrelevant conclusion)
Name four types of information bias. Name at least one way in which each type of...
Name four types of information bias. Name at least one way in which each type of bias can be prevented or minimized.
Which fallacy is most obvioulsy committed in the following argument? America—Love it or leave it! Multiple...
Which fallacy is most obvioulsy committed in the following argument? America—Love it or leave it! Multiple Choice False dilemma Appeal to ignorance Ad hominem Appeal to unqualified authority Complex question Appeal to the nation
Match the following passages with the fallacy committed. Only one instance of a fallacy is used(False...
Match the following passages with the fallacy committed. Only one instance of a fallacy is used(False DilemmaImproper,Appeal to Authority,Post Hoc,Appeal to Ignorance,Hasty Generalization,or Two Wrongs) 1.As a scientist, I base my science on a combination of things. One is observation. I've seen aliens and alien technology with my own eyes so I know there is life on other planets. 2.You can't apply the scientific method to evolution. It's never been observed. You can't repeat the experiment. 3.Who should the U.S....
Match the following passages with the fallacy committed. Only one instance of a fallacy is used.(Begging...
Match the following passages with the fallacy committed. Only one instance of a fallacy is used.(Begging the Question,False Dilemma,Appeal to Tradition,Two Wrongs,Appeal to Emotion: Fear/Force,Hasty Generalization, or Straw Person) 1.I'm your mother and I'm telling you to finish your dinner. You don't want me to have to call your father in here do you? 2.I'm sorry but I can't believe in evolution. I'm not just a hairless monkey. 3.Feminists just want to break the family unit up. Fathers have always...
Consider the following passage: The first and most manifest way is the argument from motion. It...
Consider the following passage: The first and most manifest way is the argument from motion. It is certain and evident to our senses that some things are in motion. Whatever is in motion is moved by another.... For 'motion' means the reduction of something from a state of potentiality into a state of actuality. But a thing can be reduced from a state of potentiality into a state of actuality only by something already in a state of actuality.... It...
Create a class named Horse that contains the following data fields: name - of type String...
Create a class named Horse that contains the following data fields: name - of type String color - of type String birthYear - of type int Include get and set methods for these fields. Next, create a subclass named RaceHorse, which contains an additional field, races (of type int), that holds the number of races in which the horse has competed and additional methods to get and set the new field. ------------------------------------ DemoHorses.java public class DemoHorses {     public static void...
Suppose a file (whose name is given through an argument by the user) contains student names...
Suppose a file (whose name is given through an argument by the user) contains student names and their scores (ranging from 0 to 100): i.e. each line contains a student name (just the first name with no space inside) and the student’s score separated by a space. Find out who has the highest score with what score, and who has the lowest score with what score. Also, calculate the average of all of the scores. Do not use arrays to...
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT