Question

In: Psychology

What did Socrates say was his role in Athenian public life?

What did Socrates say was his role in Athenian public life?

Solutions

Expert Solution

In 399 BCE Socrates was charged with impiety by Meletus the poet, Anytus the tanner, and Lycon the orator who sought the death penalty in the case.

The accusation read: “Socrates is guilty, firstly, of denying the gods recognized by the state and introducing new divinities, and, secondly, of corrupting the young.”

It has been suggested that this charge was both personally and politically motivated as Athens was trying to purge itself of those associated with the scourge of the Thirty Tyrants of Athens who had only recently been overthrown. Socrates' relationship to this regime was through his former student, Critias, who was considered to be among the worst of the tyrants and was thought to have been corrupted by Socrates.

It has also been suggested, based in part on interpretations of Plato's dialogue of the Meno, that Anytus blamed Socrates for corrupting his son. Anytus, it seems, had been grooming his son for a life in politics until the boy became interested in Socrates' teachings and abandoned political pursuits.

As Socrates' accusers had Critias as an example of how the philosopher corrupted youth, even if they never used that evidence in court, the precedent appears to have been known to the jury.

Ignoring the counsel of his friends and refusing the help of the gifted speechwriter Lysias, Socrates chose to defend himself in court. There were no lawyers in ancient Athens and, instead of a solicitor, one would hire a speechwriter. Lysias was among the most highly paid but, as he admired Socrates, he offered his services free of charge. The speechwriter usually presented the defendant as a good man who had been wronged by a false accusation, and this is the sort of defense the court would have expected from Socrates.

Instead of the defense filled with self-justification and pleas for his life, however, Socrates defied the Athenian court, proclaiming his innocence and casting himself in the role of Athens' 'gadfly' - a benefactor to them all who, at his own expense, kept them awake and aware. When it came time for Socrates to suggest a penalty to be imposed rather than death, he suggested he should be maintained in honor with free meals in the Prytaneum, a place reserved for heroes of the Olympic games.

This would have been considered a serious insult to the honor of the Prytaneum and that of the city of Athens. Accused criminals on trial for their life were expected to beg for the mercy of the court, not presume to heroic accolades.

Socrates was convicted and sentenced to death (Xenophon tells us that he wished for such an outcome and Plato's account of the trial in his Apology would seem to confirm this). The last days of Socrates are chronicled in Plato's Euthyphro, Apology, Crito and Phaedo, the last dialogue depicting the day of his death (by drinking hemlock) surrounded by his friends in his jail cell in Athens and, as Plato puts it, "Such was the end of our friend, a man, I think, who was the wisest and justest, and the best man I have ever known" (Phaedo, 118).

Socrates' influence was felt immediately in the actions of his disciples as they formed their own interpretations of his life, teachings, and death, and set about forming their own philosophical schools and writing about their experiences with their teacher.

Of all these writings we have only the works of Plato, Xenophon, a comic image by Aristophanes, and later works by Aristotle to tell us anything about Socrates' life.

He, himself, wrote nothing, but his words and actions in the search for and defense of Truth changed the world and his example still inspires people today.


Related Solutions

[a] From Socrates’ “Apology” - How did Socrates go about trying to disprove the Oracle of...
[a] From Socrates’ “Apology” - How did Socrates go about trying to disprove the Oracle of the god about who was the wisest person in Athens, and what do you think this shows about the nature of wisdom in Socrates’ philosophy? What does it mean to be wise? Have you ever known someone you considered wise? If so, what were they like? If not, why do you think such persons are rare? [b] From Socrates’ “Apology” - What are two...
What Sandel trying to say in the fifth chapter of his book about the role of...
What Sandel trying to say in the fifth chapter of his book about the role of advertising in society? Do you think that naming-rights, so prevalent in athletics today, affect the quality of the games being played? What kind of limits should we place on advertising?
ANALYZING THE CORE TEACHING OF SOCRATES Socrates posed the following challenge to his fellow citizens: "...are...
ANALYZING THE CORE TEACHING OF SOCRATES Socrates posed the following challenge to his fellow citizens: "...are you not ashamed of heaping the greatest amount of money and honour and reputation, and caring so little about wisdom and truth and the greatest improvement of the soul?" Do you think that this challenge is still relevant today? Explain your reasoning by giving some specific arguments and examples. WHAT IS YOUR CONCEPT OF REALITY? - This covers the topics from Course Content II,...
What role did World War I play in the development of public investing in the United...
What role did World War I play in the development of public investing in the United States?.
What role did "yellow journalism" play in shaping the opinions of the American public toward the...
What role did "yellow journalism" play in shaping the opinions of the American public toward the war?
for philosophy.. Explain why Socrates was brought to trial? What were the charges and how did...
for philosophy.. Explain why Socrates was brought to trial? What were the charges and how did he offend his fellow citizens of athens ? 200 words.
What did Michael Jensen say? What would Keynes think of his ideas? Explain what Larry Summers...
What did Michael Jensen say? What would Keynes think of his ideas? Explain what Larry Summers said about ketchup? How was this critical of efficient markets
What role did God play in Copernicus’ thinking in terms of his heliocentric model?
What role did God play in Copernicus’ thinking in terms of his heliocentric model?
What are the “personal reasons” Socrates has for his refusal to escape from jail? Try to...
What are the “personal reasons” Socrates has for his refusal to escape from jail? Try to prioritize them, that is, distinguish what you think are the more important from the less important reasons he gives Crito.
Explain in more than 1700 words for what Socrates makes life worth living and how the...
Explain in more than 1700 words for what Socrates makes life worth living and how the same could be applicable to you by following ideas, standards and ideals encounter so far
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT