Question

In: Economics

[a] From Socrates’ “Apology” - How did Socrates go about trying to disprove the Oracle of...

[a] From Socrates’ “Apology” - How did Socrates go about trying to disprove the Oracle of the god about who was the wisest person in Athens, and what do you think this shows about the nature of wisdom in Socrates’ philosophy? What does it mean to be wise? Have you ever known someone you considered wise? If so, what were they like? If not, why do you think such persons are rare?
[b] From Socrates’ “Apology” - What are two of Socrates several opposing arguments about death not being something that he should fear? Why do you think so many people fear death? Do any of Socrates arguments help you think differently about death?
[c] From Plato’s “Republic: The Allegory of the Cave” - Explain how the Allegory of the Cave can be understood as a picture of Socrates’ life and death, as well as a picture of our human situation. What is the difference between people who won’t let go of their cave-wall-shadows and those who won’t let go of their screened technology?

Solutions

Expert Solution

Sol:

The oracle of Apollo at Delphi was the most famous and most revered oracle of the ancient world. That Chaerephon did in fact visit the oracle is confirmed by Xenophon, though in his account, the oracle declared Socrates to be "the most free, upright, and prudent of all people" (Xenophon, Socrates' Defense) rather than the most wise. In either case, it is clear that the oracle made a positive claim about Socrates. Most of Plato's early dialogues--those that center more on Socrates' thought than on Plato's own--are concerned with ethical questions, and so we can perhaps reconcile Xenophon's and Plato's accounts by saying that Socrates' wisdom is a kind of ethical wisdom, one that would make him supremely free, upright, and prudent. But the Delphic oracle sided primarily with Sparta during the Peloponnesian War, so it is doubtful how much an Athenian jury would trust or appreciate the evidence given by the oracle.

Also of relevance is the famous motto inscribed above the entrance to the oracle at Delphi: "Know thyself." Socrates is an ardent advocate of self- knowledge, and his investigations can be seen as an attempt to come to a better understanding of his own nature. He is famous for claiming that no one could ever knowingly and willingly do evil, that evil is a result of ignorance and deficient self- knowledge. His investigations generally ask such questions as what it is to be virtuous, or pious, or just. In his dogged efforts to understand these terms himself, and his persistence in showing his interlocutors to be wrong in assuming they have such understanding, Socrates reveals himself as a man intent on gaining the self-knowledge necessary to lead a virtuous life.

Socrates' account of his conversations with the supposed wise men of Athens provides us with a valuable account of his method of elenchus, or cross-examination. The Apology is a rare exception in Plato's works, in that only a small part of it is given over to the elenchus; in most of the works, it is the principal means by which Plato lays out Socrates' arguments. The elenchus begins with Socrates' interlocuter claiming to have a perfect understanding of some term, usually an ethical term like "justice," "virtue," or "piety," though epistemology and metaphysics are sometimes discussed in Plato's more mature work. Socrates then proceeds to question his interlocutor about his knowledge of that term, trying to arrive at the essence of the matter. Usually, the interlocutor will manage to find several cases that he thinks exemplify that term, but he will have trouble saying what they all have in common that make the given term apply to them. Through careful interrogation, Socrates will show that his interlocutor does not in fact know anything more than a few scattered and imprecise examples.


Related Solutions

3. In Apology, Socrates offers the horse-breeder analogy. How does this analogy go, and what is...
3. In Apology, Socrates offers the horse-breeder analogy. How does this analogy go, and what is it supposed to demonstrate about the importance of living an examined life? What is one potential objection to the analogy?
In the Apology, Socrates said that if the Athenian court forbade him to practice philosophy from then on, he would refuse to obey.
In the Apology, Socrates said that if the Athenian court forbade him to practice philosophy from then on, he would refuse to obey. In the Crito he seems to say that one must always obey the legal authorities, even when they command what is unjust.  Is there a way to reconcile what he says in these two works?  Can you think of a way to make his statements consistent with one another?  Try to formulate a position on this question that you'd be...
What is the Theory of Spontaneous Generation? How did Louis Pasteur disprove this theory? What did...
What is the Theory of Spontaneous Generation? How did Louis Pasteur disprove this theory? What did his observations provide the basis for, and how has this impacted microbiology?
for philosophy.. Explain why Socrates was brought to trial? What were the charges and how did...
for philosophy.. Explain why Socrates was brought to trial? What were the charges and how did he offend his fellow citizens of athens ? 200 words.
How would a Daoist go about trying to resolve a situation involving interpersonal conflict? How would...
How would a Daoist go about trying to resolve a situation involving interpersonal conflict? How would a Confucian practitioner approach the problem? A Buddhist?
American Airlines is trying to decide how to go about hedging Sfr 70m in ticket sales...
American Airlines is trying to decide how to go about hedging Sfr 70m in ticket sales receivable in 180 days. Suppose it faces the following exchange and interest rates (first rate for borrowing, second for investing) Spot rate $0.6433-42/SFr Forward rate (180 days) $0.6578-99/SFr SFr 180 day interest rate (annualized) 01%-3.97% US $ 180 day interest rate (annualized) 01%-7.98% What is the hedged value of American’s ticket sales using Forwards? What is the hedged value of American’s ticket sales using...
American Airlines is trying to decide how to go about hedging $70 million in ticket sales...
American Airlines is trying to decide how to go about hedging $70 million in ticket sales receivable in 180 days. Suppose it faces the following exchange and interest rates. Spot rate:                                                          $0.6433-42/SFr Forward rate (180 days):                                    $0.6578-99/SFr DM 180-day interest rate (annualized):              4.01%-3.97%    U.S. dollar 180-day interest rate (annualized):    8.01%-7.98% 9.a.   What is the hedged value of American’s ticket sales using a forward market hedge? 9.b.   What is the hedged value of American’s ticket sales using a money market...
7. What was the purpose of “Sarbox”? How did the act go about achieving its purpose?
7. What was the purpose of “Sarbox”? How did the act go about achieving its purpose?
How did the founders of Rent the Runway go about testing their original idea? What concerns...
How did the founders of Rent the Runway go about testing their original idea? What concerns did suppliers and designers have? How did Rent the Runway’s founders dispel these concerns? Describe how the firm seeks to build deep and mutually beneficial industry partnerships
Talk about ERP software systems from any vendor, such as SAP or Oracle etc, to answer...
Talk about ERP software systems from any vendor, such as SAP or Oracle etc, to answer the following question. What is contained in the software modules of 'Customer Relationship Management' or 'Supply-Chain Management' or 'Product-Life Cycle Management', and highlight the advantages and disadvantages of that information system module.
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT