Question

In: Nursing

The patient, Mrs. Z., is a sixty-year-old woman who received a kidney transplant approximately one year...

The patient, Mrs. Z., is a sixty-year-old woman who received a kidney transplant approximately one year earlier. Her current hospitalization is for a urinary tract infection and dehydration. She had a similar hospitalization three months ago. She is characterized in the medical record as “non-compliant” with her medicines, and she does not drink enough fluids to maintain her hydration. In order to treat her infection and to rehydrate her, the hospital staff would like to place a peripherally inserted central catheter (PICC) line and also additional IV lines. These would need to remain in place for several days. The patient refuses the placement.

            The ethics consultant interviewed Mrs. Z and found her very difficult to engage in any sustained conversation. Mrs. Z would only offer that she “didn’t want any tubes” and that the reason was because “they hurt.” She repeated this line over and over when questioned. When asked whether she understood that these interventions might help her get better and that a lack of treatment could lead to her getting worse, she would say, “I don’t want to talk about that.” She would repeat these sentences or something similar in response to virtually any questions.

            She has a husband, whom she married about five years ago, and who is currently in a rehabilitation facility after suffering a stroke. He has difficulty speaking, but when contacted by telephone, he said that he thought, “everything should be done.” Hospital staff also contacted her twenty-four-year-old son, who is going to school in another state and was her kidney donor. He says his mother’s mental status has never been completely right since the transplant and deteriorates significantly when she gets an infection and is dehydrated. He says that she has been negative about treatment since the transplant but would likely have wanted this care if she were her “old self”. Armed with this information, the ethics consultant asked Mrs. Z if she could say how her son felt about her decisions or why he thinks she should agree to the PICC line and IV line placements. In response, she would turn away in bed and sometimes cover her head with the sheet.

Questions:

  1. Do you think Mrs. Z has the capacity to make decisions about her care? Why or why not?
  2. If Mrs. Z does not have decision-making capacity, who is the more appropriate surrogate decision-maker; her husband or her son? Specifically, what effect on being able to act as the surrogate decision-maker is created by either the husband’s stroke or the fact that the son is the donor of Mrs. Z.’s kidney?
  3. Can a surrogate consent to restraining the patient to treat her?
  4. Should Mrs. Z receive treatment for her dehydration and infection despite refusing this care?
  5. If Mrs. Z is treated despite her refusal, would you characterize this as “weak” paternalism or “strong” paternalism?

Solutions

Expert Solution

No, Mrs. Z can't take decision about her care. because she is continuously refusing for any treatment. she is afraid of tubes and getting irritate. Although she has been negative about her treatment since transplant because of UTI and other problems.

Her son is more appropriate surrogate decision maker.

Her son is more appropriate because he is the donor of mrs. Z's kidney

Yes surrogate can sign a consent to restraint the patient. because treatment is necessary and some adult clients need to be restraints better for their life.

Yes mrs.Z is getting treatment of dehydration and infection through PICC line.

Mrs.Z treated despite her refusal, this is characterised as weak paternalism.

Paternalism has been one of the traditional characteristics of the therapeutic relationship in medicine. It implies that the physician makes decisions based on what he or she discerns to be in the patient's best interests, even for those patients who could make the decisions for themselves.


Related Solutions

Mrs. Nygyen is a 60-year-old patient who has been diagnosed with chronic kidney disease. Mrs. Nygyen’s...
Mrs. Nygyen is a 60-year-old patient who has been diagnosed with chronic kidney disease. Mrs. Nygyen’s past medical history includes diabetes mellitus type 2, osteoarthritis, and hypertension. 1. Upon intake assessment, the nurse notes that Mrs. Nygyen has very dry skin and mucous membranes, mild ecchymosis to the lower extremities, and lung crackles bilaterally. Vital signs include blood pressure of 160/90, pulse 90, respirations 22, and temperature 99.0° F. What assessment data collected by the nurse would indicate that Mrs....
A 52-year-old patient with End-Stage Kidney Disease related to alcoholism needs a kidney transplant. The patient’s...
A 52-year-old patient with End-Stage Kidney Disease related to alcoholism needs a kidney transplant. The patient’s identical twin sister, who is in good health, has agreed to donate one of her kidneys. Both sisters were admitted to the same hospital for the procedure. Initial Discussion Post: Address the following: • What is the RNs role for the kidney recipient in the immediate post-operative period? • What is the RNs role for the kidney donor in the immediate post-operative period? •...
A 52-year-old patient with End-Stage Kidney Disease related to alcoholism needs a kidney transplant. The patient’s...
A 52-year-old patient with End-Stage Kidney Disease related to alcoholism needs a kidney transplant. The patient’s identical twin sister, who is in good health, has agreed to donate one of her kidneys. Both sisters were admitted to the same hospital for the procedure. Initial Discussion Post: Address the following: What is the RNs role for the kidney recipient in the immediate post-operative period? What is the RNs role for the kidney donor in the immediate post-operative period? Are there ethical...
A 52-year-old patient with End-Stage Kidney Disease related to alcoholism needs a kidney transplant. The patient’s...
A 52-year-old patient with End-Stage Kidney Disease related to alcoholism needs a kidney transplant. The patient’s identical twin sister, who is in good health, has agreed to donate one of her kidneys. Both sisters were admitted to the same hospital for the procedure. Initial Discussion Post: Address the following: What is the RNs role for the kidney recipient in the immediate post-operative period? What is the RNs role for the kidney donor in the immediate post-operative period? Are there ethical...
Mrs. Johnson, a 45-year-old woman who is healthy and is a middle-class worker, recently received news...
Mrs. Johnson, a 45-year-old woman who is healthy and is a middle-class worker, recently received news that she carries the APEO-e4 gene that may increase her chance of developing Alzheimer’s disease. What are modifiable factors that Mrs. Johnson can change to reduce her risk of developing Alzheimer’s disease? Which level/levels of prevention do these modifiable factors correlate with?
You are the primary care provider for Mrs. Z, a 70-year-old female patient who has suffered...
You are the primary care provider for Mrs. Z, a 70-year-old female patient who has suffered from chronic back pain for a number of years. You are well acquainted with this patient, and due to recent changes in prescription regulations you now see her once a month to renew her narcotic prescription. Three months ago Mrs. Z’s 17-year-old granddaughter moved in with her, after a fight with her mother. Z’s granddaughter was a straight-A student prior to a car accident...
Mrs. Johnson is a 70-year-old woman who had a stroke less than a year ago. Mrs....
Mrs. Johnson is a 70-year-old woman who had a stroke less than a year ago. Mrs. Johnson is alert and oriented. She feels the sensation to void but right-sided weakness prevents her from always being able to get to the bathroom in time. For this reason, she wears incontinence undergarments. Mrs. Johnson’s daughter, Amy stops by twice each day to check on her and prepare meals for her. There are times when Mrs. Johnson is incontinent and remains in a...
A patient who has had a kidney transplant is receiving cyclosporine. A nurse should observe the...
A patient who has had a kidney transplant is receiving cyclosporine. A nurse should observe the patient for signs of which problem?
Brief Patient History Mrs. G is a 54-year-old African American woman who has been having intermittent...
Brief Patient History Mrs. G is a 54-year-old African American woman who has been having intermittent indigestion for the past month. She has a history of hypertension and hyperlipidemia. She was admitted as an inpatient on a medical floor for management of her blood pressure and is scheduled to undergo endoscopy tomorrow. Mrs. G suddenly becomes diaphoretic and complains of nausea and epigastric pain. Clinical Assessment The rapid response team is called to evaluate Mrs. G. When the team arrives...
Mrs. A. is an 84-year-old woman who was recently discharged from the hospital with a diagnosis...
Mrs. A. is an 84-year-old woman who was recently discharged from the hospital with a diagnosis that includes an exacerbation of congestive heart failure (CHF). She also has diabetes and hypertension. Mrs. A. was discharged from the hospital on multiple medications and lives alone. Home care services were initiated with skilled nursing care visits, some home health aide support, and orders to include daily telemonitoring of her vital signs. The telehealth device will remotely monitor Mrs. A.’s blood pressure, heart...
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT