Question

In: Nursing

Contemporary issues in healthcare law and Ethics. Activity 9.1 beginning on page 214. What claims could...

Contemporary issues in healthcare law and Ethics. Activity 9.1 beginning on page 214. What claims could Dr. Stuart assert against the other physicians, and what defenses could the other physicians raise? Discuss the elements of each potential claim and defense, as well as your evaluation of the likelihood of success on each claim or defense.

Solutions

Expert Solution

DrStuart was monitored the medical center and the the case main facts are compelling and brings out the lack of care at the center and few loopholes are present at there, so DrStuart can question the physicians for:

1. Falsifying and Slander: The physicians,Dr. Jackson and Dr. Alexander, quoted that "all of the physicians at the meeting on November 15 had agreed that Dr. Jackson and Dr. Alexander should speak to Happy Family on their behalf"- this claim is contentious. Under the facts given, no where is it mentioned, that the other Dr.s gave such a mandate to these Physicians, moreover there is no evidence/ facts given elsewhere, that lead us to believe that such an mandate have ever be given- it is highly possible that the Dr.s are lying and slandering Dr. Stuart, who is obviously disliked by the group, because they see her as a potential competitor and fear losing business to her center.

2. Coercing and Undue utilization of Official Influence: The facts from the cases states : "In addition, the administrator of General stated that General might have to reevaluate its contractual arrangement with Happy Family the next time that General’s provider contract with Happy Family came up for renewal"

This is a clear case of coercion and using official authority. It is plausible to believe that Happy Family has done its due diligence and had made their decision to enter into an agreement. Since the Hospital in qustion is a bigger player, which obviously means a source of higher revenues, the hospital used its significant clout to obfuscate a potential competitor in Dr. Stuart, by holding back Happy family and trying to interrupt Dr. Staurt's work.

On the other hand the Physicians can set up a defense stating that given the disclosures of new facts- regarding Dr. Stuart's Past history and client feedback- it is but their professional duty of the Dr.s to try and address the issues affecting the profession in general. Assuming all facts to be true and that the Dr.s were not lying, it is in common interest to stop practitioners like Dr. Staurt so as to maintain the high level of integrity, that is so common among medical practitioners.

However, after the analysis, it can be concluded that if presented tactfully, Dr. Stuart has a good case in her hand. Morality and ethical high ground stand of the Dr.s are impressive but it still not justfy their efforts to coerce happy family. If it can be proven beyond doubts, that happy family was indeed coerced, whcih led to their ultimate cancellation- Dr. Stuart can win the case.


Related Solutions

What is the relationship between law and ethics? Provide at least two contemporary business examples of...
What is the relationship between law and ethics? Provide at least two contemporary business examples of how an act can be legal yet unethical. Considering cultural differences, analyze the ethical pros and cons related to overseas manufacturing for a company such as Nike.
Discuss the relevance of Engineering law and ethics as an academic discipline to the contemporary society
Discuss the relevance of Engineering law and ethics as an academic discipline to the contemporary society
. Why it is healthcare law and ethics important in the world and workplace?
. Why it is healthcare law and ethics important in the world and workplace?
What is the relationship between ethics, morality and the law? Are all ethical and moral issues...
What is the relationship between ethics, morality and the law? Are all ethical and moral issues also legal issues, explain why or why not? Explain why a doctor being sued for malpractice could be considered both a non-legal and legal issue. Give an example of doing something that is not ethical but IS legal. Why should you do what is ethical in this case even if it is not illegal, i.e., you wont get in trouble with the law?
For this assignment, please select a current and contemporary (recent) healthcare policy. In a 2-3 page,...
For this assignment, please select a current and contemporary (recent) healthcare policy. In a 2-3 page, APA paper provide the following information: -Policy Title -History and Background of the policy to include when it was brought into law. -Brief summary of the policy to include the purpose of the policy, the population it impacts, and any interventions or applications that occurred as a result of the policy. The assignments and the Project in this course will build upon one another,...
Biomedical ethics chapter 24 What are the key ethical issues for healthcare practitioners who use or...
Biomedical ethics chapter 24 What are the key ethical issues for healthcare practitioners who use or recommend CAM practices?
law and ethics Which is not true about CGL insurance a. it provides protection against claims...
law and ethics Which is not true about CGL insurance a. it provides protection against claims b. insurance can be purchased on multiple layers c. it can be a claim made or occurrence policy d it protects against the insured loss rather than against the claim if the third party
I need a 3-4 page research paper on the following topic: (The class is healthcare law...
I need a 3-4 page research paper on the following topic: (The class is healthcare law and regulation) To what extent does regulation create a drag on the efficiency and productivity of the health care industry and to what extent does it facilitate its success? (I very much appreciate the work that goes into answering these questions! But please do not answer this question with things like a bulleted list, or something copy and pasted from a publication, because that...
I need a 3-4 page research paper on the following topic: (The class is healthcare law...
I need a 3-4 page research paper on the following topic: (The class is healthcare law and regulation) To what extent does regulation create a drag on the efficiency and productivity of the health care industry and to what extent does it facilitate its success? (I very much appreciate the work that goes into answering these questions! But please do not answer this question with things like a bulleted list, or something copy and pasted from a publication, because that...
Discuss the importance of ethics in financial accounting. What issues may arise if ethics is compromised?...
Discuss the importance of ethics in financial accounting. What issues may arise if ethics is compromised? How would this impact the company internally, how would it impact the external users such as investors, creditors, government?
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT