Question

In: Physics

Whenever I read about the curvature of spacetime as an explanation for gravity, I see pictures...

Whenever I read about the curvature of spacetime as an explanation for gravity, I see pictures of a sheet (spacetime) with various masses indenting the sheet to form "gravity wells." Objects which are gravitationally attracted are said to roll down the curved sheet of spacetime into the gravity well. This is troubling to me, because, in-order for objects on the locally slanted spacetime sheet to accelerate, gravity must be assumed. Therefore I ask; does the explanation of gravity as the curvature of spacetime assume gravity? If yes, what is the point of the theory? If No, what am I missing?

Solutions

Expert Solution

I greatly sympathize with your question. It is indeed a very misleading analogy given in popular accounts. I assure you that curvature or in general, general relativity (GR) describe gravity, they don't assume it. As you appear to be uninitiated I shall try to give you some basic hints about how gravity is described by GR.

In the absence of matter/energy the spacetime (space and time according to the relativity theories are so intimately related with each other it makes more sense to combine them in a 4 dimensional object called space-time) is flat like a table top. This resembles closely with (not completely) Euclidean geometry of plane surfaces. We call this spacetime, Minkowski space. In this space the shortest distance between any two points are straight lines.

However as soon as there is some matter/energy the geometry of the surrounding spacetime is affected. It no longer remains Minkowski space, it becomes a (pseudo) Riemannian manifold. By this I mean the geometry is no longer like geometries of a plane surface but rather like geometries of a curved surface. In this curved spacetime the shortest distance between any two points are not straight lines in general, rather they are curved lines. It is not very hard to understand. Our Earth is a curved surface and the shortest distance between any two points are great circles rather than straight lines. Similarly the shortest distance between any two points in the 4 dimensional spacetime are curved lines. An object like sun makes the geometry of spacetime curved in such a way that the shortest distance between any two points are curved. This is called a geodesic. A particle follows this curved geometry by moving along this geodesic. Einstein's equations are mathematical descriptions of the relation of the geometry to the matter/energy.

This is how gravity is described in general relativity.


Related Solutions

I need some explanation to present about light quanta.
I need some explanation to present about light quanta.
I keep getting more confused about GABA inhibitor the more I read about it through the...
I keep getting more confused about GABA inhibitor the more I read about it through the chapters, can you explain it to me clearly?
I used to see many commercials about sunscreen when I was growing up and now I...
I used to see many commercials about sunscreen when I was growing up and now I hardly ever see them. Why do you think that is?
I just wanna ask a simple question, but i need some explanation about it. What is...
I just wanna ask a simple question, but i need some explanation about it. What is the Physical quantities (Probably Wavelength or something like that) that causes every people has their own unique sound? Not Frequency Right? Because if frequency, people can just adjust their sound to make their frequency same with other people sound.
How do I see the content of Stucase23 about Lafayette hospital?
How do I see the content of Stucase23 about Lafayette hospital?
Read these two articles about the AT&T Time Warner merger. What do you see as the...
Read these two articles about the AT&T Time Warner merger. What do you see as the benefits and drawbacks of this merger for both consumers and the firms? Do you think it should be approved? Why or why not? In general, do you think monopolies are good or bad for consumers? Why? The Perils of an AT&T-Time Warner Merger: Last time a communications giant acquired Time Warner, it was an unprecedented disaster. Here's what is likely to go wrong this...
Please, read the question carefully. I need correct answers and clear explanation. Thank you! On Sept...
Please, read the question carefully. I need correct answers and clear explanation. Thank you! On Sept 15, 2017, Julia Inc entered into a contract to provide 12 new deep fryers to a Montreal Poutinerie. Julia normally charges $1,500 for each deep fryer. As part of the agreement, Julia will provide on-site training at the Poutinerie’s 3 locations. Julia will host 3 separate training sessions at each location. For this training, Julia normally charges $700 / day. The Poutinerie needed Julia’s...
Please give an explanation or what the rational of the code is about, I am trying...
Please give an explanation or what the rational of the code is about, I am trying to figure it out what it means so to better understand it. Discuss the Code Provision on Square and Rectangular HSS and Box- Shaped Members, Rounds HSS, Tees and Double Angles Loaded in the Plane of Symmetry, and Single Angles.
Read the Book "The Patient Will See you now", write a 4-5 page paper. I want...
Read the Book "The Patient Will See you now", write a 4-5 page paper. I want you to look closely at the areas discussed in this book, discuss what areas will work well and what types of medicine it will work well within. Please use APA formatting and cite your references.
PLEASE READ CAREFULLY BEFORE STARTING THE ASSIGNMENT!!! AS YOU CAN SEE I AM DONE WITH ALMOST...
PLEASE READ CAREFULLY BEFORE STARTING THE ASSIGNMENT!!! AS YOU CAN SEE I AM DONE WITH ALMOST HALF THE TABLE. I DIDN'T FIND A SINGLE AMOUNT FOR THE COLUMNS: RENT EXPENSE, SALARIES EXPENSE, SUPPLIES EXPENSE, AUTO EXPENSE, MISC EXPENSE. THE SAME QUESTIONS HAS BEEN ASKED MANY TIMES ON CHEGG, BUT ALL THE AMOUNTS POSTED FOR THOSE MISSING COLUMNS ARE WRONG IN EACH AND EVERY SINGLE POST, SO PLEASE DON'T COPY AND PASTE FROM ANY OF THEM. I LITERALLY CHEKCED EACH AND...
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT