What is the nocebo effect? Why does the nocebo effect create a moral dilemma in the...

What is the nocebo effect? Why does the nocebo effect create a moral dilemma in the informed consent procedure? According to Cohen, when do doctors have good reason to NOT disclose potential side effects of treatments to their patients? Do you agree? Explain why or why not.

Expert Solution

While placebo effect is the perspective of mind over medicine, it has a dark side as well known as the nocebo effect. This has the opposite effect, i.e. when an individual is told about the negative impacts of something, it starts exhibiting symptoms for real. The verdict here lies in the fact that if one believes that the treatment would not help you, it really doesn’t. The nocebo effect creates a moral dilemma for informed consent. This is so because when a patient is informed about the potential risks involved in a medical procedure, it is said to negatively impact their psyche. These may then in turn activate the nocebo effect and end up having devastating consequences medically as well. According to Cohen, in analogy to the original problem with the concept of knowledge, these Gettier-type cases show an indeterminacy in the concept of IC: we either need to add some explicit additional condition of causal connection between information and consent, or else we should understand the concept in a new way—specifically, since the practice of autonomy necessarily involves some consideration of the relevant information, we must understand free consent in a way that no longer refers to patient autonomy. This essentially also means that this needs to be understood in comprehensive detail and analysed through different perspectives, especially the vulnerability of the psyche of the individual concerned. In cases where higher likelihood of negative cognitions is anticipated, it is better to not inform the patient regarding potential risks. In this manner, this should be considered independent from the required autonomy of the individual concerned.

Hayet Jeridi answered 2 months ago

Moral Dilemma A moral dilemma involves a situation in which the agent has only two courses...

Moral Dilemma A moral dilemma involves a situation in which the agent has only two courses of action available, and each requires performing a morally impermissible action.. Plato presents the classic example of a moral dilemma. A man borrows a weapon from his neighbor promising to return it at his neighbors request. One day the neighbor in a fit of rage, asks for the weapon back apparently with the intention to kill someone. The man is faced with a dilemma:...

Moral Development in School-Age Children Develop a situation that would include a moral dilemma that is...

Moral Development in School-Age Children Develop a situation that would include a moral dilemma that is likely to be faced by an individual in early school age or middle childhood with whom you might be working in a counseling setting. The moral dilemma can be fictional or nonfictional. 1) In your post, describe how Kohlberg would describe the stage of moral development in the situation you have created. 2) Discuss one other theorist or theory (learning theory, cognitive developmental theory,...

What is the Euthyphro dilemma? State the dilemma in your own woods and explain why it...

What is the Euthyphro dilemma? State the dilemma in your own woods and explain why it presents a problem for the view that morality is grounded in some divine command.

1-what moral responsibilities does to the physician have ? 2-what moral respobilities does the scientist have...

1-what moral responsibilities does to the physician have ? 2-what moral respobilities does the scientist have ? 3- Why does the randomized clinical trial create a false dichotomy in the physician’s opinions? 4- Why is there moral tension in the concept of the physician-scientist?

1) What do you think about having a moral dilemma such as terrorism dealt with through...

1) What do you think about having a moral dilemma such as terrorism dealt with through the hands of government? (200 words)

A young person is facing a moral dilemma. Their country is involved in a military action...

A young person is facing a moral dilemma. Their country is involved in a military action in a foreign nation, and they have been conscripted by the government for the war effort. Unfortunately, their mother is suffering from a terminal illness, and she has no other family. The person and their mother, with whom they still live, are very poor, and a soldier’s salary will not be sufficient to pay for the care that the mother requires. If the person...

What is the Doctrine of Double Effect? What sorts of moral problems is this principle designed...

What is the Doctrine of Double Effect? What sorts of moral problems is this principle designed to help solve? What must be considered under this view to decide whether an action is morally permissible? How does this view differ from act utility? Give one example of a moral judgment about a case that uses the doctrine of double effect to show why the act is moral or immoral. Take the example from the text, the video, or class lectures.

Question

What is the nocebo effect? Why does the nocebo effect create a moral dilemma in the...

Solutions

Expert Solution

Related Solutions