What are some arguments supporting or critiquing the logic of divine command?

Expert Solution

The view of divine command is that morality is dependent on god. And it also states that considering our rights and wrongs consists in the obedience of god's commands. Morality is based on the commands of god and morally right action is one that god commands.

Criticism of this theory can be understood by following points:

Divine commands has difficulties because the conception of morality makes god's commands arbitrary.

History has shown that morals change over time and period so what was considered morally incorrect in the past need not necessarily be incorrect in today's time hence disregarding this theory.

Divine commands says that there is nothing right or wrong in the world unless it is as per the will of god which means any immoral or unjust act like raping, murdering etc. can be made moral by claiming it to be moral as per the command of god.

Relegion pluralism. There are multiple regions with different authoritative texts. Hindus rule of ahimsa says not to eat meat and be vegeterians whereas levictus teaches us to eat meat.

There is no criteria for which claim to accept if two individuals present confliction claims based on divine commands

Hayet Jeridi answered 3 months ago

What two questions are raised by theological volunteerism ( divine command theory) ? What are the...

What two questions are raised by theological volunteerism ( divine command theory) ? What are the implications of holding one or the other true? Which one do you agree with and why?

1) What is a practical difficulty that Divine Command Theory faces? ( Why is it difficult...

1) What is a practical difficulty that Divine Command Theory faces? ( Why is it difficult to put DCT Into practice in resolving ethical disputes?) 2) Explains the Euthyphro argument. Make sure to indicate what is an argument for or against?

Briefly explain Divine Command Thoery. Describe at least one objection to this theory.

Brutus’s essay offers a series of arguments critiquing the nature of representation under the Constitution. While...

Brutus’s essay offers a series of arguments critiquing the nature of representation under the Constitution. While Brutus’s arguments predate modern theories of “minimalist,” “pluralist,” “aggregative,” or “deliberative” democracy, he is clearly working from a definition of “rule by the people” that we can compare to contemporary theories of democracy. Which of the four “models” of democracy is Brutus’s definition of democracy most like? In your answer, you should clearly define the chosen model of democracy and briefly argue why, based...

Question: What are some arguments in favor of outsourcing? What are some arguments against outsourcing? How...

Question: What are some arguments in favor of outsourcing? What are some arguments against outsourcing? How has the argument for outsourcing changed in the wake of the COVID-19 pandemic? Your answers will be short essays and should be three full paragraphs or longer.

(Intro/Basic) JAVA Write a small program that gets some numbers as command-line arguments and finds the...

(Intro/Basic) JAVA Write a small program that gets some numbers as command-line arguments and finds the maximum of those numbers. You can assume that the user will provide some command-line arguments when running the program (so you don’t have to worry about what to do if the user doesn’t provide any arguments -- that won’t happen). Also, you can assume that all the command line arguments will be floating-point numbers, i.e., numbers with a decimal point, like 2.95.

What are some arguments justifying the continual use of the death penalty, and what are arguments...

What are some arguments justifying the continual use of the death penalty, and what are arguments for abolishing it? (You need to explain the arguments/issues in some detail and specificity

In Linux (Ubuntu), write a script to check command arguments (3 arguments maximum). Display the argument...

In Linux (Ubuntu), write a script to check command arguments (3 arguments maximum). Display the argument one by one. If there is no argument provided, remind users about the mistake. If there is an easy way to use a loop to get all arguments, use it? a. Display the source code in an editor (#4-1) b. Execute your script in the terminal, and display the command and the result (#4-2)

What are some examples of arguments for and against an emissions tax?

What are some arguments that are for/against the Duhem-Quine thesis

Question