Question

In: Operations Management

Multi-national enterprises (MNEs) have been criticised for having a "cash-cow" perspective of their host country's resources....

Multi-national enterprises (MNEs) have been criticised for having a "cash-cow" perspective of their host country's resources. Explain why this may be the case and provide examples in your response.

Solutions

Expert Solution

'Cash cows' is one of the four elements of the BCG Matrix. It represents a product, service or a business that provides with far more return than the market growth rate, having a huge market share in a mature growth industry (eg. Iphone by Apple). The investment requirements are minimal for cash cow products to thrive in the market.

Cash cow products and services may have a large number of benefits for the organisation but it might lead to exploitation of the society, especially to the inhabitants of the country. This is more detrimental in case of developing and under developed countries. It includes misues of the natural resources, leading to their depletion, exploitation of cheap labour, repatriation of profits, illegal movement of money into tax havens, dilution of local cultures and traditions etc. Society also faces cost of climate change and mitigation. Moreover, they block the entry of new products and innovation in the markets leading to monopoly of the MNC's and their products.

Examples in thi regard include: cocoa industry in Africa, merger of Maruti and Suzuki in India, energy companies, Pharameceutical companies, etc.

Extensive CSR policies and structural changes in companies could help curb these issues.


Related Solutions

Why do Multi-National Enterprises (MNEs) undertake foreign direct investment (FDI) instead of exporting to the nation?...
Why do Multi-National Enterprises (MNEs) undertake foreign direct investment (FDI) instead of exporting to the nation? What are the different levels of FDI in terms of financial investment/commitment between exporting and a totally owned subsidiary and what factors influence which level of FDI a MNE would choose when doing FDI?
Outline the characteristics of Global and Transnational Strategy. Identify situations in which Multi-National Enterprise (MNEs) should...
Outline the characteristics of Global and Transnational Strategy. Identify situations in which Multi-National Enterprise (MNEs) should deploy each of these strategies?
Identify a "multi-national" culture-based conflict that you have observed in the workplace or find a "multi-national"...
Identify a "multi-national" culture-based conflict that you have observed in the workplace or find a "multi-national" culture-based conflict in current events where the company needed to resolve the conflict. Imagine you are the negotiator, consider your own personality, ability factors and your cultural perceptions. How would these factors and perceptions influence your strategy to resolve the conflict? “What Factors Shape a Negotiator's Predisposition to use Unethical Tactics.” Consider the conflict you identified, are there any ethical considerations that you need...
List and critically assess the methods and models that Multinational Enterprises (MNEs) have used to minimize...
List and critically assess the methods and models that Multinational Enterprises (MNEs) have used to minimize their tax obligations. Also, identify the primary techniques that MNEs have adopted to maximize their profit potential. Illustrate your answer with specific reasoning, argument and drawing on examples.
Multinational enterprises (MNEs) have an impact far beyond their firm boundaries. Assume you are working for...
Multinational enterprises (MNEs) have an impact far beyond their firm boundaries. Assume you are working for a small firm that supplies a product or service to an MNE. How might your relationship change as the MNE moves from Globalization 2.0 to Globalization 3.0 operations? Being a “small firm”, what are some examples of how this relationship change could potentially benefit the company? How might the change affect a small supplier in a negative way?
Multinational enterprises (MNEs) have an impact far beyond their firm boundaries. Assume you are working for...
Multinational enterprises (MNEs) have an impact far beyond their firm boundaries. Assume you are working for a small firm that supplies a product or service to an MNE. How might your relationship change as the MNE moves from Globalization 2.0 to Globalization 3.0 operations? Being a “small firm”, what are some examples of how this relationship change could potentially benefit the company? How might the change affect a small supplier in a negative way?
Do MNEs (Multinational Enterprises) have a lower or higher cost of capital than domestic firms? Discuss.
Do MNEs (Multinational Enterprises) have a lower or higher cost of capital than domestic firms? Discuss.
Describe the role of “education” in culture. Why is education important for a multi-national entity, which is considering expansion into a new host country market?
Describe the role of “education” in culture. Why is education important for a multi-national entity, which is considering expansion into a new host country market? 
Two broad perspectives have been outlined; the consensus perspective and the conflict perspective. The contemporary The...
Two broad perspectives have been outlined; the consensus perspective and the conflict perspective. The contemporary The feminist theory, the exchange theory, the symbolic interactionism theory, and modernity theory are the contemporary theories covered. Which one of the broad perspectives or contemporary theories are most closely aligned with family and societal dynamics?
A key dynamic within any Multi National Corporation (MNC) is management of cash and also foreign...
A key dynamic within any Multi National Corporation (MNC) is management of cash and also foreign exchange risk exposure. Cash management is critical and also heavily influenced by global dynamics. Within the Caribbean and South American jurisdiction, the economic framework is tightly connected with the major Asian economies of China and Japan, as well as the United States and the United Kingdom. The Caribbean and South American economy respectively, have been a barometer of the global economic cycle. For the...
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT