1. What is the "principle of alternate possibilities?" a. Is Frankfurt's view consistent with soft determinism?...

1. What is the "principle of alternate possibilities?"

a. Is Frankfurt's view consistent with soft determinism? Why? How do you know?

Solutions

Expert Solution

The principle of alternate possibilities was given by frankfurt. He defined it by saying that a person is mirally responsible for something he has done only if has alternatively done it . Later he himself experimented and proved ut wrong and said that a person morally responsible for something he has fone even if he hasnt done it alternatively. It is said to be an illusion. It also has a rincie saying that it is only possible if causal determinism is false. Causal determinism is another name of soft determinism as it says that the actions of people are dependent on external causes. Although free will is a part of actions but that is also indluenced by the external causes. On the other hand frankfurt argues that all the actions of people are solely directed by the persons inner will. Hence taking the principle saying it is only possible if soft determinism is false and the difference in the cause of the action it can be said that frankfurts view is inconsistent to soft determinism.

Hayet Jeridi answered 1 month ago

Next > < Previous

Related Solutions

Discuss the meaning of determinism. Discuss social-cultural determinism. Discuss fatalism and hard and soft determinism. Discuss...

Discuss the meaning of determinism. Discuss social-cultural determinism. Discuss fatalism and hard and soft determinism. Discuss existentialism and human consciousness.

What is determinism? Can determinism be real? If determinism is real, can we have free will?...

What is determinism? Can determinism be real? If determinism is real, can we have free will? If so, how do societal norms influence free will? Remember to fully explain and apply course material with educational support for consideration of credit. As you answer these questions, think about the nature versus nurture debate. If people are born with traits, does culture impact the development of the person? If people are born with traits, do they have free will to choose differently?...

Which of the following is consistent with the controllability concept (principle)? A. A store manager's performance...

Which of the following is consistent with the controllability concept (principle)? A. A store manager's performance evaluation is not negatively affected by the hurricane damages. B. The Dollar Tree headquarters allocates the advertising costs to individual stores. C. Airlines' stock prices plunged due to big loss of passengers in the midst of the COVID 19 pandemic. D. Insurance companies charge deductibles when the car is damaged by vandalism. A joint process resulted in Products M1 and M2. Both of them...

Address one of the following questions with a 200 word post. 1. What is causal determinism?...

Address one of the following questions with a 200 word post. 1. What is causal determinism? Provide some examples of objects that are causally determined. 2. Explain the relation between fatalism and causal determinism. 3. Assuming causal determinism is true, does it follow that we cannot hold people responsible for their actions? Why of Why not? 4. Provide and example of an action which is entirely uncaused. Would this uncaused action be free? 5. Provide an example of a person...

What does it mean for a system to be consistent? Is incidence geometry consistent? What does...

What does it mean for a system to be consistent? Is incidence geometry consistent? What does it mean for a system to be complete? Is incidence geometry complete?

What is the difference between the production possibilities curve and the consumption possibilities curve?

1. Consider the following Production Possibilities Frontier. (Chapter 1) Goods Possibilities _______________________________________________ A B C...

1. Consider the following Production Possibilities Frontier. (Chapter 1) Goods Possibilities _______________________________________________ A B C D E Capital Goods 5 4 3 2 0 Consumer Goods 0 5 9 12 14 _______________________________________________ a. Use the information in the above table to show the production possibilities frontier (PPF) graphically. Mark the attainable and efficient, attainable but inefficient, and unattainable possibilities. Explain in words what the frontier (the curve) shows us. b. Explain the reason its shape is “bowed out?”?” Under...

What is the difference between the production possibilities curve and the consumption possibilities curve? Assume that...

What is the difference between the production possibilities curve and the consumption possibilities curve? Assume that the world consists of Norway and Sweden and that these countries do not trade with each other. There are two goods in this world: timber and mobile phones. Assume that Sweden needs 1 worker to produce a unit of timber and 2 workers to produce a mobile phone. Norway needs 6 workers to produce a unit of timber and 3 workers to produce a...

What is meant by the consumption possibilities of a country? question How are Consumption possibilities related...

What is meant by the consumption possibilities of a country? question How are Consumption possibilities related to production possibility in a closed economy? In an open economy?

-What is the principle of subsidiarity? -What is the principle of correspondence? -What is economies of...

-What is the principle of subsidiarity? -What is the principle of correspondence? -What is economies of scale?

Subjects