Question

In: Economics

Which branch of the U.S. Government is the most powerful? Discuss the powers and limitations of...

Which branch of the U.S. Government is the most powerful? Discuss the powers and limitations of power of each branch

Solutions

Expert Solution

The United Starts government's most powerful branch is the Judicial Branch. For a couple of different reasons the Judicial Branch is the most powerful branch. First, the Judicial Branch has the power to declare congressional acts unconstitutional, and can declare executive branch acts unconstitutional. A well-known example of that is the Marbury v. Maddison court case. William Marbury who was appointed by President John Adams as Justice of Peace in The District of Columbia. Marbury needed to deliver some documents to James Madison, who was Secretary of State at the time.

James Madison did not want such papers to be given to William Marbury because he did not feel that Marbury deserved to be the Justice of Peace. Marbury petitioned the Supreme Court to order the records to be delivered to James Madison. The Supreme Court, with John Marshall as Chief Justice, found first that Madison 's refusal to deliver the commission was both illegal and rectifiable Nonetheless, the Court stopped short of ordering Madison (by letter of mandamus) to hand over Marbury 's commission, arguing instead that the provision of the 1789 Judiciary Act that allowed Marbury to bring his claim to the Supreme Court was itsel.

The Judicial Branch was often framed in such a way that the judges of the Supreme Court received lifetime terms. That is somewhat different from the other two branches, as the elected members have term limits in the other two branches of government. Those are some of the reasons why the U.S. government's most powerful branch is the Judicial Branch.

Legislative Branch- In a bicameral Legislature, Article I of the Constitution vests the legislative authority of the Untied States. The Congress consists of the House of Representatives, whose members are elected for two-year terms and represent districts of equal numbers, and the Senate which consists of two senators from each state serving for six-year terms. Senators were initially elected by the state legislature but are now elected directly. The House and Senate makeup represented a compromise between the larger states, which wanted a population-based legislature and the smaller states that wanted equal representation for each state.

Executive Branch- The President retains the control of the executive branch. The President is chosen by the electoral college for a four-year term, not by direct voting. Under this system every state has a number of election college members equal to the number of House and Senate members. The candidate who gets the most votes in a state gets all of that state's electoral votes. The candidate with an electoral college majority becomes the President. The winner is chosen by the House of Representatives if no candidate receives a majority of the electoral votes

The Judicial Branch- The Constitution grants U.S. judicial power to one Supreme Court and other lower courts which Congress may establish. The President nominates federal judges for life and must be confirmed by the Senate. Under the Constitution, all federal courts are Courts with restricted jurisdiction. They will only hear "cases or disputes" which means they can not conduct non-judicial duties or advise the president or congress on the constitutionality of the proposed action. They can not hear all sorts of cases, but only those listed under the jurisdiction of the United States, as provided for in Article III.


Related Solutions

The legislative branch, the executive branch, and the judicial branch. Which branch is the most powerful?...
The legislative branch, the executive branch, and the judicial branch. Which branch is the most powerful? Do you think the checks and balances among these three branches should be the way they are? Why or why not? A good answer will support their argument with evidence and explanation.
Who is the most powerful person in the U.S.? Discuss the difference of the power, role,...
Who is the most powerful person in the U.S.? Discuss the difference of the power, role, and influence of the President compared to the Speaker of the House, the Senate Majority Leader and other positions of power in the U.S. today. What are the more important constraints or limits on the President's power? Should the President "represent" the American people or "lead" them?
Identify the separation of powers between the three branches of government. Then, discuss how each branch checks and balances the other branches.
Write a 1,050- to 1,400-word essay that addresses the following: Identify the separation of powers between the three branches of government. Then, discuss how each branch checks and balances the other branches. Select and discuss a current event or issue from the past 5 years (possible areas include: health care reform, presidential appointments, and national security, for example). Then, discuss 1) how the separation of powers affects this issue and 2) how the checks and balances affects this issue.
Answer in short essay. which branch of the Federal Government do you think is the most...
Answer in short essay. which branch of the Federal Government do you think is the most powerful, why? Alexander Hamilton called fhe Supreme Court the "least dangerous branch" why?
“Some of the most powerful CEOs in the U.S. are rethinking their roles and arguing maximizing...
“Some of the most powerful CEOs in the U.S. are rethinking their roles and arguing maximizing profits for shareholders isn't their only job. Nearly 200 business leaders, including Apple's Tim Cook and Amazon's Jeff Bezos, have signed a new Statement of Purpose of a Corporation. It says a CEO's responsibilities include generating good jobs, protecting the environment and making sure there is economic opportunity for all. Traditional liberal thinkers may consider all this obvious. But for the corporate titans of...
Two principles fundamental to the U.S. system of government arethe separation of powers and checks...
Two principles fundamental to the U.S. system of government are the separation of powers and checks and balances. Please define each concept. Next, I would like you to give me a concrete example of the separate powers of each branch of government. Finally, I would like you to give me a concrete example of how each branch of government checks each of the other branches of government. Please be specific.
What is federalism?  Explain the expressed and implied powers of the U.S. Constitution.  Which two U.S....
What is federalism?  Explain the expressed and implied powers of the U.S. Constitution.  Which two U.S. Supreme Court cases (decisions) relied on the implied powers clause?  Explain one of the cases.
1) which of the following business forms is most suitable for the powers, particularly if they...
1) which of the following business forms is most suitable for the powers, particularly if they establish and conduct the counseling business in conjunction with their like-minded friends?
Discuss the limitations of BMI. Discuss when it would be most appropriate to use BMI and...
Discuss the limitations of BMI. Discuss when it would be most appropriate to use BMI and describe instances when another more formal technique should be utilized and why?
Explain the distinction between Exclusive Powers, Concurrent Powers and Residual Powers, which are outlined in the...
Explain the distinction between Exclusive Powers, Concurrent Powers and Residual Powers, which are outlined in the Australian Constitution. Give an example of each power.
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT