Question

In: Psychology

Distinguish the difference between act and rule-utilitarianism. What are they and how are they different? After...

Distinguish the difference between act and rule-utilitarianism. What are they and how are they different? After presenting the views raise one objection for act-utilitarianism. Explain why it poses a problem for act-utilitarianism. Is this also a problem for rule-utilitarianism? Why or why not?

Solutions

Expert Solution

ACT UTILITARIANISM-

Jeremy Benthem is supposed to be the pioneer of act utilitarianism.

"Pain and pleasure are the facets bestowed upon human beings by Nature" is the essesnce of act utilitarianism.

Consequences allied with a single act are dealt with by act utilitarianism.

"The greatest good for the greatest number of people" is the prime ideology behind act utilitarianism.

Maximisation of utility is the chief/ significant concern of act utilitarianism.

RULE UTILITARIANISM-

Consequences allied with the framework of rules of the conduct are dealt with through rule utilitarianism.

Behaviours are attempted to be standardised with the help of rules laid down by rule utilitarianism philosophy.

The at par rules cultivate at par actions and behaviours.

The truth is that if rule utilitarianism fails to fetch greataer good, breaking the rules/ standards set will also not fetch greater good.

PROBLEM FOR ACT UTILITARIANISM-

Some of the aspects of human life like- cheating, violence, enslavement, sexual misbehaviour may produce happiness for someone or a considerable/ mediocre number of people.

These actions can never be justified on the basis of the happiness generated or utility displayed for the said number of people. Therefore, these acts cannot be treated morally permissible.

But the same above mentioned attribute is not an issue/ a problem for rule utilitarianism as there are rules governing and cultivating just actions that are morally permissible.


Related Solutions

4. What is the purpose of ethics? 5. What is the difference between act utilitarianism and...
4. What is the purpose of ethics? 5. What is the difference between act utilitarianism and rule utilitarianism? 6. What is the difference between negative rights and positive rights?
what is the difference between "rule of law" and "rule by law"? Can the different approaches...
what is the difference between "rule of law" and "rule by law"? Can the different approaches to law help to explain government structure in Pacific Asia?
Question 77: The Ethics of Care has many similarities to Question options: Rule Utilitarianism Act Utilitarianism...
Question 77: The Ethics of Care has many similarities to Question options: Rule Utilitarianism Act Utilitarianism Kant’s Categorical Imperative Rawls’s Theory of Justice Part B: Which of the following is not a reason why a feminist perspective has called for rethinking the history of ethics? Question options: Traditional ethics has excluded women’s voices. Traditional ethics stresses autonomous man and the ethics of strangers. Traditional ethics has not emphasized justice. Traditional ethics invalidates the priority of intimate relationships.
what is the differnce between act and rule consequentialism?
what is the differnce between act and rule consequentialism?
What is the difference between positive and negative reinforcement? Is there a need to distinguish between...
What is the difference between positive and negative reinforcement? Is there a need to distinguish between the two? If so, what is the practicality of distinguishing the two forms of reinforcement? If not, what would be saved by eliminating the distinction?
1. What is the difference between the Securities Act of 1933 and the Securities Exchange Act...
1. What is the difference between the Securities Act of 1933 and the Securities Exchange Act of 1934 with respect to what they regulate? What factors do the purchasers of securities under the Securities Act of 1933 need to prove to recover losses from the CPA? What would be a viable defense by the CPA? 2. Many CPA firms are taking a business risk approach to audits. Define what is meant by business risk. Provide an example of a business...
a) Distinguish between cash discount and a purchase discount. b) What is the difference between a...
a) Distinguish between cash discount and a purchase discount. b) What is the difference between a sales discount and a purchase discount? Can you illustrate a journal entry for each? c) What is the purpose of a accounts payable subsidiary ledgers? How is it used? Why is it used?
What is "Government" and how is it different than "Politics?" Also, What is the difference between...
What is "Government" and how is it different than "Politics?" Also, What is the difference between Democracy and Republic--as a form of government? Please be specific and answer in paragraphs
What is segment margin? How is it different from contribution margin? What is the difference between...
What is segment margin? How is it different from contribution margin? What is the difference between traceable fixed costs and common fixed costs? Choose a company. Break that company into two separate segments. What are three common fixed costs of the company? What are three traceable fixed costs to each segment?
What is segment margin? How is it different from contribution margin? What is the difference between...
What is segment margin? How is it different from contribution margin? What is the difference between traceable fixed costs and common fixed costs? Choose a company. Break that company into two separate segments. What are three common fixed costs of the company? What are three traceable fixed costs to each segment?
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT