Question

In: Economics

why does Don marquis argument against abortion undermines Michael Michael tooley argument for abortion and infanticide

why does Don marquis argument against abortion undermines Michael Michael tooley argument for abortion and infanticide

Solutions

Expert Solution

Don Marquis is Professor of Philosophy at the University of Kansas. He defends the view that, except in unusual circumstances, abortion is seriously wrong.

The purpose of this essay is to set out an argument the claim that abortion, except perhaps in instances, is seriously wrong. One reason for these exceptions is to eliminate from consideration cases whose ethical analysis should be controversial detailed for clear-headed opponents of abortion. Such cases include abortion after rape and abortion during the first fourteen days after conception when there is an argument that the fetus is not definitely an individual. Another reason for making these exceptions allow for those cases in which the permissibility of abortion is compatible with the argument of this essay. Such cases include abortion when continuation of a pregnancy endangers a woman's life and when the fetus is anencephalic. When I wrongness of abortion in this essay, a reader she presume the above qualifications. I mean by  an abortion an action intended to bring about the death of a fetus for the sake of the woman who carries it. (Thus, as is standard on the literature on this subject, I eliminanate spontaneous abortions from consideration.) I mean by a fetus a developing human being from time of conception to the time of birth. (Thus, as is standard, I call embryos and zygotes, fetuses.)

The argument of this essay will establish that abortion is wrong for the same reason as killing a reader of this essay is wrong. I shall just assume, rather than establish, that killing you is seriously wrong. I shall make no attempt to offer a complete ethics of killing. Finally, I shall make no attempt to resolve some very fundamental and difficult general philosophical issues into which this analysis of the ethics of abortion might lead.


Related Solutions

Why are people for and against abortion?
Why are people for and against abortion?
true or false a problem with don marquis's view in his 1989 article called "Why Abortion...
true or false a problem with don marquis's view in his 1989 article called "Why Abortion is Immoral" is it implies that infanticide is morally permissible
Texas Abortion Law (Senate Bill 8): The Argument
Legislators are enacting public policies and legislation that dictate what a woman may and cannot do in terms of her reproductive rights. Senate Bill 8 (SB8) otherwise called the heartbeat bill, that was signed into law in 2021, is one critical talking point.
Topic in Medical Ethics: Abortion: Explain both sides of the argument. Then, explore whose argument is...
Topic in Medical Ethics: Abortion: Explain both sides of the argument. Then, explore whose argument is more rationally rigorous and coherent. Note, this is not the same thing as which side you already agree with! Decide which argument is more rational and logical, not which reading already says what you believe.  These may not be the same thing. So, for instance, you might find that a reading has the best argument, despite the fact that your original opinion on the matter...
Define what the multiplier is AND explain how and why it works. Explain two argument against...
Define what the multiplier is AND explain how and why it works. Explain two argument against Robert Gordon’s claim that wage stagnation is due to the exhaustion of technological progress.
Why is Abortion a controversial issue including a specific thesis of why abortion-rights shouldn't be taken...
Why is Abortion a controversial issue including a specific thesis of why abortion-rights shouldn't be taken away in the united states *please write a paragraph long exclamation*
What is Callahan’s strongest argument against allowing the legalization of euthanasia? Evaluate that argument.
What is Callahan’s strongest argument against allowing the legalization of euthanasia? Evaluate that argument.
+should nations continue to try and reduce trade barriers? why? what is a good argument against...
+should nations continue to try and reduce trade barriers? why? what is a good argument against trade and why?+
Michael Don owns an equipment hire business under the name Safety Hire. Financial data for Safety...
Michael Don owns an equipment hire business under the name Safety Hire. Financial data for Safety Hire as of 30 June 2019 are shown as below:. Account Balance ($) Accounts receivable 73,000 Wages expense 78,000 Equipment hire income 200,000 Advertising expense 32,000 Prepaid insurance 9,000 Accounts payable 88,000 Insurance expense 7,000 Cash at bank 48,000 Equipment 190,000 Michael Don, capital ? Required: a) Prepare an income statement for the business for the year ending 30 June 2019. b) Prepare a...
what's an argument against relying too heavily on Hadith? What is a Quranic based argument in...
what's an argument against relying too heavily on Hadith? What is a Quranic based argument in favor of Hadith? i picked the wrong subject so the right one is socialogy
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT