Question

In: Psychology

Is mental illness a myth? Do you agree or disagree with Thomas Szasz's proposition that so-called...

Is mental illness a myth?

Do you agree or disagree with Thomas Szasz's proposition that so-called mental illnesses are really "problems in living" rather than products of underlying disease?

Does the concept mental illness, as Szasz claimed, "obscure the everyday fact that life for most people is a continuous struggle."  

Solutions

Expert Solution

Thomas Szasz proved taht unlike true diseaseses of the brain and the body, mental illness ia a destructive social construct that medicalizes living and deprives people of their dignity. Szaza's ideas are always controversialduring his life time, and they started to fuel around the discourse the topic and legalization of the drugs.

the term mental illness is widely used to describe something hich is very different the disease of the brain.mental illness as a deformity of the personality is regarded as the cause of the human disharmony.. Mental illness is really a problem for living and is a hardship for the person to survive in the society. Even for the family members the situation will be critical to see the child in the situation. mental disorder which will not be cured by drugs is a continuous struggle for the family for the whole life. The psychological factors in the family also get disturbed.


Related Solutions

Read the “Dig Deeper” vignette, “The Myth of Mental Illness”, provided below. Do you think mental...
Read the “Dig Deeper” vignette, “The Myth of Mental Illness”, provided below. Do you think mental illness is a myth? Why or why not? DIG DEEPER: The Myth of Mental Illness In the 1950s and 1960s, the concept of mental illness was widely criticized. One of the major criticisms focused on the notion that mental illness was a “myth that justifies psychiatric intervention in socially disapproved behavior” (Wakefield, 1992). Thomas Szasz (1960), a noted psychiatrist, was perhaps the biggest proponent...
what is the basic position of strong ai? do you agree or disagree? if you agree,...
what is the basic position of strong ai? do you agree or disagree? if you agree, provide and argue against one or more objections from weak ai. if you disagree, provide one or more arguments from weak ai to counter-argue strong ai.
Discuss whether you agree or disagree with Thomas Pogge’s innovative solution of getting affordable drugs to...
Discuss whether you agree or disagree with Thomas Pogge’s innovative solution of getting affordable drugs to market.
environmentalists are a hindrance to a country's development. do you agree or disagree.
environmentalists are a hindrance to a country's development. do you agree or disagree.
To what extent do you agree or disagree with the statement that the creation of an...
To what extent do you agree or disagree with the statement that the creation of an organisational structure is the perfect way to bring about harmony in the utilisation of resources in an organisation’’ Subject: Organisational Behavior & Management
2. "Unions do not happen, they are caused by management." Do you agree or disagree with...
2. "Unions do not happen, they are caused by management." Do you agree or disagree with this statement? Why?
First, how does Thomas Hobbes view humanity? Why is his view so negative? Do you agree...
First, how does Thomas Hobbes view humanity? Why is his view so negative? Do you agree with his view? Why or why not? Next, what is the social contract theory? How does a society come out about as a result of said theory? Then, following this, how can ethics naturally come about as well. Finally, what do you ultimately believe is the origin of ethics? Is ethics an innate human trait that comes about while creating human societies? Or is...
In a meaningful and substantive manner, do you agree or disagree with the ways the choice...
In a meaningful and substantive manner, do you agree or disagree with the ways the choice to deal with the outliers(a, b, c)? Explain your position at length. (a) A participant estimating ordinary people’s heights estimates one woman’s height to be “84 inches” tall. The participant may have got confused and said an incorrect number. Using raw data to double check her height and make sure that this has been accurately recorded. This number is really high and unbelievable. This...
In a meaningful and substantive manner, do you agree or disagree with the ways the choice...
In a meaningful and substantive manner, do you agree or disagree with the ways the choice to deal with the outliers(a, b, c)? Explain your position at length. (a) A participant estimating ordinary people’s heights estimates one woman’s height to be “84 inches” tall. 1. Check for participant misunderstanding- the pariticipant may not have realized that this would be equivilant to seven feet, making it justifiable to exclude this peice of data. 2. Use the median as the measure of...
The affects of lowering and hiring gas price · · Do you agree or disagree with...
The affects of lowering and hiring gas price · · Do you agree or disagree with the decisions /opinions of the government right now ? Why?
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT