Question

In: Computer Science

Discuss the prospect of using WiFi technology on indoor positioning instead of Bluetooth. Provide a comparative...

Discuss the prospect of using WiFi technology on indoor positioning instead of Bluetooth. Provide a comparative analysis.

Solutions

Expert Solution

Wi-Fi is a popular technology choice for calculating the position of an asset tag for a real-time location system (RTLS). The use of Wi-Fi indoor positioning systems has advantages and limitations over other location technologies, like Bluetooth, ultra-wideband (UWB), or ultrasound. Some customers, especially users in healthcare RTLS, have found using existing Wi-FI systems to be problematic to achieve the desired accuracy goals for their RTLS solution. Wi-Fi is used in four different ways for location determination, and each approach has its own set of advantages and challenges.

Wi-Fi fingerprinting is an approach to indoor asset tracking where the location and base station ID (BSSID) of each Wi-Fi access point (AP) in a building is recorded as part of a survey. An asset tag then scans the Wi-Fi environment and reports the list of Wi-Fi APs and their associated signal strengths. The database from the survey is then used to estimate the tag’s likely position. This is also how smartphones often estimate their position when they are in areas where GPS does not work, like inside buildings. There are many databases of Wi-Fi APs,

Ensuring Wi-Fi Positioning System Accuracy

(SPOILER: IT’S TOUGH)

The advantage of fingerprinting is that it’s a cheap and easy way to get location information from existing Wi-Fi infrastructure. However, in order to get any type of room-level accuracy, a survey must be conducted with specialized equipment. RTLS companies that use fingerprinting usually offer this as part of provisioning the system. However, when equipment is swapped or moved, the survey is no longer valid, and this will ultimately become an ongoing maintenance issue for the RTLS system.

An improvement over simple fingerprinting is the use of RSSI-based multilateration, which is using the signal strength of all detectable Wi-Fi APs along with knowledge of their location to calculate position. In most cases, this is accurate to around 4m or at the room level, assuming there are enough APs. In parts of buildings with less AP coverage (especially at the end of halls, for example), there simply isn’t enough data to determine location. Errors in pinpointing a room or floor are therefore common in these areas.

More advanced Wi-Fi-based RTLS systems use time-of-flight (ToF) based triangulation, which is when packets sent to and from asset tags (or other devices, like workers’ phones) are timestamped by multiple Wi-Fi APs. If the APs have tightly synchronized clocks, the time differences can be used to calculate position. These systems require specialized Wi-Fi infrastructure that must be installed in sufficiently dense layouts to support RTLS. These systems are among the most accurate but require costly Wi-Fi systems. More APs need to be installed than would be needed just for data usage. Walls (especially those in large buildings like hospitals) can add to the multipath problem, which can degrade the accuracy of ToF-based RTLS.

A similar approach to ToF is angle of arrival (AoA), where the angle at which a given Wi-Fi transmission was received is calculated using something called a multiple-input multiple-output (MIMO) antenna, which clusters antennas together to increase range and throughput. MIMO antenna systems are common in some enterprise environments. Sometimes, systems use a combination of ToF and AoA, which can result in very accurate location. AoA systems have the additional concern that they need to be installed in a certain orientation to work correctly. They suffer from the same noise, sampling artifacts, and multipath channel effects as TOF does, but the requirement for clock synchronization is less of an issue.

One last concern for Wi-Fi indoor positioning systems, in general, is that tags must have a Wi-Fi transceiver installed inside them, which makes them more costly (and bulkier) than Bluetooth, IR, or ultrasound. Link Lab’s AirFinder RTLS system uses a combination of Bluetooth and Ultrasound instead of Wi-FI, but it’s important for customers to understand the alternatives for RTLS


Related Solutions

The Mizkhan Museum recently deployed the Quuppa positioning system, powered by Bluetooth technology, to improve the...
The Mizkhan Museum recently deployed the Quuppa positioning system, powered by Bluetooth technology, to improve the interactive visitor experience and gain valuable information on visitor movement throughout the museum. The app-based solution that guides visitors through the museum from the moment they enter the facility, providing highaccuracy location information. Mizkan can use this information to analyse the pattern of visitor flow and gain insight into which exhibits are the most popular. Deployment of the Quuppa system took only a single...
The Mizkhan Museum recently deployed the Quuppa positioning system, powered by Bluetooth technology, to improve the...
The Mizkhan Museum recently deployed the Quuppa positioning system, powered by Bluetooth technology, to improve the interactive visitor experience and gain valuable information on visitor movement throughout the museum. The app-based solution that guides visitors through the museum from the moment they enter the facility, providing highaccuracy location information. Mizkan can use this information to analyse the pattern of visitor flow and gain insight into which exhibits are the most popular. Deployment of the Quuppa system took only a single...
The Mizkhan Museum recently deployed the Quuppa positioning system, powered by Bluetooth technology, to improve the...
The Mizkhan Museum recently deployed the Quuppa positioning system, powered by Bluetooth technology, to improve the interactive visitor experience and gain valuable information on visitor movement throughout the museum. The app-based solution that guides visitors through the museum from the moment they enter the facility, providing highaccuracy location information. Mizkan can use this information to analyse the pattern of visitor flow and gain insight into which exhibits are the most popular. Deployment of the Quuppa system took only a single...
The Mizkhan Museum recently deployed the Quuppa positioning system, powered by Bluetooth technology, to improve the...
The Mizkhan Museum recently deployed the Quuppa positioning system, powered by Bluetooth technology, to improve the interactive visitor experience and gain valuable information on visitor movement throughout the museum. The app-based solution that guides visitors through the museum from the moment they enter the facility, providing highaccuracy location information. Mizkan can use this information to analyse the pattern of visitor flow and gain insight into which exhibits are the most popular. Deployment of the Quuppa system took only a single...
c)using the AIT(accra institute of technology)wifi for students as an example, explain the challenges you face...
c)using the AIT(accra institute of technology)wifi for students as an example, explain the challenges you face while accessing it ,explain why tje challenge(s) exist (s) and explain what you think could be done to fix the challenge(s)
Discuss the rationale for international trade using comparative and absolute advantage theories Provide an example of...
Discuss the rationale for international trade using comparative and absolute advantage theories Provide an example of how to resolve macroeconomic challenges like income distribution
provide an example of an application when you would select using raman spectroscopy instead of IR
provide an example of an application when you would select using raman spectroscopy instead of IR
How technology advancements impact our lives we live and businesses we do: 1. Provide a comparative...
How technology advancements impact our lives we live and businesses we do: 1. Provide a comparative - disadvantages and advantages - of in-person and on-line modes of learning and academic progress. 2. For businesses, how Corona Pandemic has fast-forwarded the evolution to adopt to virtual/online business models to cater to increasing demands of their customers.
discuss some of the ethical challenges that the use of technology could pose for retailers. provide...
discuss some of the ethical challenges that the use of technology could pose for retailers. provide specific examples and links to relevant resources.
Using the data for Brady and Co. below please provide: Balance Sheet - comparative, classified in...
Using the data for Brady and Co. below please provide: Balance Sheet - comparative, classified in proper format for fiscal years 2015 and 2016 Income Statement - multiple-step for fiscal years 2015 and 2016. Include earnings per share data. Statement of Retained Earnings for 2016. 2015 2016 Dr Cr Dr Cr Accounts Payable          999,210       1,079,837 Accounts Receivable        2,943,125      3,245,967 Accrued Liabilities - Other          508,643          721,358 Accrued Pension Liabilities          650,216          450,356 Accrued Restructuring...
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT