Question

In: Psychology

Need assistance with this assignment. Read the Boffetta et al. (2010) article. Identify any potential threats...

Need assistance with this assignment.

Read the Boffetta et al. (2010) article. Identify any potential threats to internal or external validity in the article. Do you notice any potential problems with the conclusions?

Solutions

Expert Solution

Note: This response is in UK English, please paste the response to MS Word and you should be able to spot discrepancies easily. You may elaborate the answer based on personal views or your classwork if necessary.

(Answer) This study by Boffetta et al. is about probable carcinogens in vegetables and fruits. In order to study the link between the consumption of certain fruits and vegetables with cancer and death rate, the researchers collected data of the populace of a particular area. The researchers collected data about the history cancer patients, deaths and consumption/purchase of fruits and vegetables.

From what can be gathered by reading the article, the researchers have used a correlation study to determine a causal relationship. There are pros and cons to this study in terms of validity. Firstly, when it comes to correlation study, one must accommodate that fact that there could be a confounding variable. For instance, People who eat pizza from an expensive restaurant “A” had a lesser chance of heart disease than people who ate from a cheaper pizza restaurant “B.” However, the confounding variable “C” is that the richer people could afford to spend on an organic diet that was the actual cause of the lower risk of heart disease. Therefore the issue of the research methodology is the problem of internal validity.

The issue with external validity is that the study relies more on historic data of population affliction and lifestyle in terms of food and not much of actual biological research. This study does contain a few scientific pursuits. However, they seem to be inconclusive in certain areas. Analysis of the gene structure of the fruits and vegetables on a cellular level would have to be conducted for a proper external validity of this study and not a mere census.

The problem with the discussion (there is no concrete conclusion paragraph in this study), is that the researcher only talks about data derived from census and there is hardly any scientific discussion. Since fruits and vegetable are not the only things that people consume and that humans are exposed to several other environmental factors, it is not possible to confirm the hypothesis with validity.


Related Solutions

Read Chapter 13 in Marshall et al., (2014). Read the "Calculating Your Costs Per Visit" article....
Read Chapter 13 in Marshall et al., (2014). Read the "Calculating Your Costs Per Visit" article. 1.Course Project Option 1 is to complete the questions on Case 10.13 for the company you selected. 2.Course Project Option 2 is to complete the following budgeting assignment: Stillwater Video Company, Inc. produces and markets two popular video games, High Range and Star Boundary. The closing account balances on the company's balance sheet for the last year are as follows: Cash, $18,735; Accounts Receivable,...
Choose either the Santilli et al or Crabtree et al article from the assigned readings. How...
Choose either the Santilli et al or Crabtree et al article from the assigned readings. How did the authors use community assessment tools to tackle a public health issue relevant to the community? What role did local knowledge play in the implementation of the project and its outcomes?
Using the Levett-Jones et al. (2010) article and additional evidence based nursing literature discuss the importance...
Using the Levett-Jones et al. (2010) article and additional evidence based nursing literature discuss the importance of clinical reasoning in relation to preventing patient deterioration and maintaining safe nursing practice.
Biological Role of Nardonella Endosymbiont in Its Weevil Host. (Kuriwada et al 2010). Find online to...
Biological Role of Nardonella Endosymbiont in Its Weevil Host. (Kuriwada et al 2010). Find online to answer. http://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal.pone.0013101 (in your own words): 1. the research question / hypothesis of the paper.    2. Explain the significance of the data shown in Table 1, with regard to the methodology behind the experiments    3. Summarize the results and significance of Figure 3.    4. Did the authors actually demonstrate what is suggested in the title of the paper?    5. With...
The following questions are from the published research article: Segre, L. et al. (2014). Depression and...
The following questions are from the published research article: Segre, L. et al. (2014). Depression and Anxiety Symptoms in Mothers of Newborns Hospitalized on the Neonatal Intensive Care Unit, Nursing Research, 63(5), 320-332. In the overall results of this study (the clinical significance), what did the researchers find that explained 37% of the variance in negative emotionality n NICU mothers? If you were a nurse working in NICU, how could this help guide your practice?
Read the 2008 paper by Spanos et al. “A nonlinear model for top fuel dragster dynamic...
Read the 2008 paper by Spanos et al. “A nonlinear model for top fuel dragster dynamic performance assessment” (attached to this file) as an example. Even if you don’t understand everything in the paper, please try to answer the following questions in your own words after reading it: Here is a link to the paper: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/261913459_dragsterSAE a) What is the general aim of this paper? b) Did the authors actually test the predictions of their model? c) Do you think...
1. Download and read “Racetrack betting and informed behavior” by Asch et al (Journal of Financial...
1. Download and read “Racetrack betting and informed behavior” by Asch et al (Journal of Financial Economics, July 1982), then answer the following: (i) How does the use of racetrack betting data overcome the EMH joint hypothesis problem?
A study by Lefèvre et al. (2010, PLoSONE 5: e9546) investigated whether alcohol consumption affected peoples'...
A study by Lefèvre et al. (2010, PLoSONE 5: e9546) investigated whether alcohol consumption affected peoples' attractiveness to the mosquito, Anopheles gambiae, which is the primary vector for malaria in Africa. A total of 43 human participants were tested, and the attractiveness of each participant was tested twice. The first test collected a baseline attractiveness for each participant. The participants then drank either a liter of beer (n=25 participants) or a liter of water (n=18), and after 15 minutes, the...
Malhotra et al. (2007) identify six leadership practices of effective leaders of virtual teams. If you...
Malhotra et al. (2007) identify six leadership practices of effective leaders of virtual teams. If you needed to, how would you rank these and why?
I need assistance finding studies as references for an assignment. These are the parameters I require:...
I need assistance finding studies as references for an assignment. These are the parameters I require: Topic: PTSD as a result of trauma. PUBLISHED 2014 or after Peer reviewed study One author is a RN Study conducted NOT in the following countries: China, Middle East, Russia, India I need TWO of these types of studies. Thanks in advance!
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT