In: Accounting
Orange Corp. has two divisions: Fruit and Flower. The following
information for the past year is available for each division:
Fruit Division | Flower Division | ||||
Sales revenue | $ | 1,440,000 | $ | 2,160,000 | |
Cost of goods sold and operating expenses | 1,080,000 | 1,620,000 | |||
Net operating income | $ | 360,000 | $ | 540,000 | |
Average invested assets | $ | 3,000,000 | $ | 2,160,000 | |
Orange has established a hurdle rate of 8
percent.
Required:
1-a. Compute each division’s return on investment
(ROI) and residual income for last year. (Enter your ROI
answers as a percentage rounded to two decimal places, (i.e.,
0.1234 should be entered as 12.34%.))
1-b. Determine which manager seems to be
performing better.
Fruit Division | |
Flower Division |
2. Suppose Orange is investing in new technology
that will increase each division’s operating income by $146,000.
The total investment required is $2,300,000, which will be split
evenly between the two divisions. Calculate the ROI and return on
investment for each division after the investment is made.
(Enter your ROI answers as a percentage rounded to two
decimal places, (i.e., 0.1234 should be entered as
12.34%.))
3. Which manager will accept the investment.
Solution 1a:
Return on investment | |||||
Particulars | Choose Numerator | / | Choose denomerator | = | Return on Investment |
Formula | Income | / | Average Invested Assets | = | Return on Investment |
Fruit Division | $360,000.00 | / | $3,000,000.00 | = | 12.00% |
Flower Division | $540,000.00 | / | $2,160,000.00 | = | 25.00% |
Compuatation of Residual Income | ||
Investment Center | Fruit Division | Flower division |
Net Income | $360,000.00 | $540,000.00 |
Minimum required return | $240,000.00 | $172,800.00 |
Residual Income | $120,000.00 | $367,200.00 |
Solution 1b:
Flower division manager seems to be performing better.
Solution 2:
Return on investment | |||||
Particulars | Choose Numerator | / | Choose denomerator | = | Return on Investment |
Formula | Income | / | Average Invested Assets | = | Return on Investment |
Fruit Division | $506,000.00 | / | $4,150,000.00 | = | 12.19% |
Flower Division | $686,000.00 | / | $3,310,000.00 | = | 20.73% |
Compuatation of Residual Income | ||
Investment Center | Fruit Division | Flower division |
Net Income | $506,000.00 | $686,000.00 |
Minimum required return | $332,000.00 | $264,800.00 |
Residual Income | $174,000.00 | $421,200.00 |
Solution 3:
If divisional managers performance are evaluated on the basis of residual income, then both manager will accept the new investment as it is resulting in increase of residual income.
If divisional managers performance are evaluated on the basis of ROI, then Flower division manager will not accept the new investment as his division ROI will decrease from 25% to 20.73%. Further Fruit division manager will accept the new investment as his division ROI will increase from 12% to 12.19%