Imagine that a "truth serum" existed that, when administered, would make everyone tell the pure, unedited...

Imagine that a "truth serum" existed that, when administered, would make everyone tell the pure, unedited truth in all situations. Discuss the pros and cons of such a product. (Are there times in which lying is necessary/acceptable? Or should it be abolished entirely?) Finish with a conclusion in which you either support or condemn the truth serum. Support your decision.

Solutions

Expert Solution

Since childhood we have been taught that lying is an unacceptable behavior. I do agree with the same but at the same time, my personal opinion is that lying when in the situations where it save the lives of individual is required then it is acceptable. But the situation has to be grave, it should not be that one lies to save their extra-marital affair.

Using a serum to make people tell the truth is ok, but again I would say that such a serum must not be used in all the cases. The truth and lie, in my opinion are relative to each individual. What I consider right and let me be the best judge, to judge whether to speak the truth or to lie to save someone’s life. The best judge for the situation specific behavior is the person experiencing it. One should not force the opinion one has in regards to the morality or ethicality about speaking the truth or telling a lie.

Overall, I would like to conclude that the person is the best judge for taking a decision regarding the lie or telling the truth.

Hayet Jeridi answered 1 year ago

Next > < Previous

Related Solutions

When asked to reveal their true preferences people always tell the truth. never tell the truth....

When asked to reveal their true preferences people always tell the truth. never tell the truth. sometimes tell the truth. generally don't know what preferences are. 10 分問題 2 Demand curves for pure public goods satisfy the law of demand. True. False. Uncertain. 10 分問題 3 Summing demand curves horizontally sends market ______________ to individuals, while summing vertically sends market ______________ to individuals. price; price quantity; quantity quantity; price price; quantity 10 分問題 4...

A truth serum given to a suspect is known to be 82 percent reliable when the...

A truth serum given to a suspect is known to be 82 percent reliable when the person is guilty and 94 percent reliable when the person is innocent. In other words, 18 percent of the guilty are judged innocent by the serum and 6 percent of the innocent are judged guilty. If the suspect was selected from a group of suspects of which only 8 percent are guilty of having committed a crime, and the serum indicates that the suspect...

Should a provider tell the truth to a patient with terminal illness when the family does...

Should a provider tell the truth to a patient with terminal illness when the family does not want the provider to? The family member's premise is that the patient stated would just kill himself if he was ever diagnosed with the disease because of what he witnessed with his brother. How would you approach this situation?

Consider if a Social credit rating system existed in the U.S.A. 1. Would it make people...

Consider if a Social credit rating system existed in the U.S.A. 1. Would it make people act more ethical? 2. Should the USA give tangible benefits for good conduct?

1. Imagine a world where everyone payments are digital, what purposes would we have for cash?...

1. Imagine a world where everyone payments are digital, what purposes would we have for cash? (a) Give as many reasons as you can why people would still hold cash (b) What percentage of their income would you guess people would hold as cash, on average? (c) What eﬀect would this have on the money multiplier?

Which discipline (ex. humanities) values objectivity and truth? Would that make sense to say the scientific...

Which discipline (ex. humanities) values objectivity and truth? Would that make sense to say the scientific world?

Imagine you discover a new organism. What fundamental feature(s) would tell you it is a member...

Imagine you discover a new organism. What fundamental feature(s) would tell you it is a member of the superphylum Ecdysozoa? What features would allow you to assign it to one of the three ecdysozoan phyla ?

1. Can you tell me about an event when you had to step out and make...

1. Can you tell me about an event when you had to step out and make a decision on your own? 2. Did you ever have to grieve for any of the decision you have made? 3. How do you face criticisms and resolve the issue in the work area?

Imagine you are 30 years old in 2019, and would like to retire in 2049 (when...

Imagine you are 30 years old in 2019, and would like to retire in 2049 (when you are 60 years old). On December 31st 2019, you invest $10,000 in an investment brokerage account. With the $10,000, you buy 2 mutual funds. $5000 is invested in a stock mutual fund that is expected to return 7% per year, and $5000 in a Bond mutual fund that is expected to return 4% per year. Every year on December 31st, you continue to...

When would it be appropriate to make a refinement to a policy or procedure? Provide at...

When would it be appropriate to make a refinement to a policy or procedure? Provide at least three examples.

Subjects