Question

In: Psychology

Consider the way emotions have been perceived in a negative light through much of history, both...

Consider the way emotions have been perceived in a negative light through much of history, both by philosophers (i.e., Plato, Descartes) and by the Christian church (i.e, equating emotions with our “fleshly” nature). Contemporary views from various directions (i.e., neuroscience researchers, Scripture) tend to view emotion/feelings in a more positive light.

Should the field of psychology (i.e., Freud, behaviorists, humanistic psychologists) be given credit for this shift in perception? 250 words or more

Solutions

Expert Solution

William James in 1884 and Carl Lange in 1885 gave the first scientific theory, in a revolutionary “peripheral” approach to emotion separately. The theory was the focus of the first theoretical concept of emotion. The concentration on emotion or a particular emotion is considered to be the perception of a specific peripheral arousal pattern, i.e. we experience fear because we are sweating. It should be underlined that, according to James, this definition of emotion is only applicable to emotions when a physical response is associated with the situation. In 1885, According to Lange, If one tremble when subjected to a fearful situation, does the tremble occur because of the fearful situation or does the bodily response direct the emotion of fear? The second option is supported by James and Lange. The authors recaptured the time-honoured idea that each emotion has its own pattern of physiological changes even though their concept of emotion was against the traditional concept of emotion. The theories of James-Lange and Cannon-Bard places the importance of “cognition” in emotion.

The basic emotion perspective started with Darwin, and the fundamental assumptions were given by theorists such as Dewey, Watson, Allport, and McDougall. Second, the appraisal perspective was started by Arnold and brought in a revolutionary change in the cognitive psychology, it actually has roots in the psychological literature much earlier, with important works by Young during the Dark Ages and Irons and Dewey in the Golden Years. Third, basic emotion and appraisal traditions are not the only approaches to emotion that can be found in the historical literature. The third tradition of emotion theorizing—a psychological constructionist approach—was clearly articulated during the first century of psychology. Psychological constructionist works have been referred to by various names that refer to the psychological ingredients discussed by a given author (e.g., “neo-Jamesian” or “dimensional”), but these labels miss the fundamental assumptions that characterize a psychological constructionist perspective: all psychological states, whether called emotion or not, are constructed (or emerge) from the operation of more basic psychological mechanisms. It is these psychological ingredients, and the processes by which they combine, that psychology should target in its scientific approach to emotion. Fourth, and perhaps most importantly for the field of emotion, the dichotomies nature of emotion defines our current beliefs and preferences than an accurate representation of what was written in the past.

Historically nonemotional processes like language may play a role in the experience and perception of emotion. The psychological constructionist approach hypothesizes that cognition and emotion are both involved in the theoretical construct of emotion. According to theorists, psychology may be better understood to the neurosciences if a psychological constructionist approach is adopted. The brain might better respect the psychological ingredients involved in the mental states called “feeling” or “thinking” than those phenomena that the ingredients create.

Looking at the above discussion it can be assumed that cognitive psychologists have to be given credit for the evolution of the concept of emotion.


Related Solutions

Over the course of history, many diseases have been associated with a very negative stigma. What...
Over the course of history, many diseases have been associated with a very negative stigma. What disease is considered the most stigmatized in history? A. HIV/AIDS B. Leprosy C. Mental Health D. Obesity
There have been a number of studies that have focused on emotions and gender. Cummins (2014)...
There have been a number of studies that have focused on emotions and gender. Cummins (2014) discussed a number of them. One that she reviewed showed there was a large difference in empathic reactions to pictures between males and females; however she felt the study was flawed because it relied upon self-report (Cummins, 2014). This could have led the males to play down any empathy because they have been socialized to do so (2014). When studies have been conducted that...
Some observers argue that since c02 and temperature levels have been much higher in earth’s history...
Some observers argue that since c02 and temperature levels have been much higher in earth’s history than they are today. The current concerns about the human contribution to climate change are overblown. How would you empirically test this argument?
How does marriage and divorce affect the economy in both a positive and negative way?
How does marriage and divorce affect the economy in both a positive and negative way?
If a message contains both positive and negative information, what is the best way to present...
If a message contains both positive and negative information, what is the best way to present the negative information (see Chapters 7 & 8)?
Economic laws have been true throughout human history. As an example, consider the following passage, from...
Economic laws have been true throughout human history. As an example, consider the following passage, from Professor Samaddar’s lectures on the economy of Ancient India: “Weaving in India has been encouraged from time immemorial... As is the case now-a-days, labourers working overtime were given extra payment... and special rewards were given for working on holidays.” (p.117) Using a supply and demand diagram in the market for labour, clearly explain why Indian workers working overtime or during holidays were paid extra
Economic laws have been true throughout human history. As an example, consider the following passage, from...
Economic laws have been true throughout human history. As an example, consider the following passage, from Professor Samaddar’s lectures on the economy of Ancient India: “Weaving in India has been encouraged from time immemorial... As is the case now-a-days, labourers working overtime were given extra payment... and special rewards were given for working on holidays.” (p.117) Using a supply and demand diagram in the market for labour, clearly explain why Indian workers working overtime or during holidays were paid extra
Economic laws have been true throughout human history. As an example, consider the following passage, from...
Economic laws have been true throughout human history. As an example, consider the following passage, from Professor Samaddar’s lectures on the economy of Ancient India:“Weaving in India has been encouraged from time immemorial... As is the case now-a-days, labourers working overtime were given extra payment... and special rewards were given for working on holidays.” Using a supply and demand diagram in the market for labour, clearly explain why Indian workers working overtime or during holidays were paid extra.(15%)
All our lives we have been warned of having too much debt, both consumer and business,...
All our lives we have been warned of having too much debt, both consumer and business, which can lead to insolvency and bankruptcy. Explain the proper use of debt, including any limitations, for the consumer (family) and for a business.
Consider the following: (i) blue light of wavelength 450 nm, traveling through water (ii) yellow light...
Consider the following: (i) blue light of wavelength 450 nm, traveling through water (ii) yellow light of wavelength 580 nm, traveling through air (iii) red light of wavelength 670 nm, traveling through glass a) Calculate the speeds of each color of light in their respective mediums. b) Rank from slowest-to-fastest these colors of light in their respective mediums. c) Rank from slowest-to-fastest these colors of light in vacuum.
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT