Question

In: Nursing

The following results were obtained in an environmental cohort study which was investigating the risk of...

The following results were obtained in an environmental cohort study which was investigating the risk of brain cancer associated with exposure to high power transmission lines. Brain cancer was a binary variable meaning the person had it or did not.   

Radiation Dose (REM)

Total population

Cases of brain cancer

Cumulative Incidence

Relative Risk

0-0.99

25,000

2,700

1.0

1-4.99

10,000

1,300

≥5

2,000

1,500

Please fill in the table above. Please show all your work. Use the lowest radiation category (i.e. 0-0.99) as the referent group.

Please interpret the relative risk for the 1-4.99 and ≥5 REM groups compared to the referent group.

Based on the Bradford-Hill criteria discussed in the Causality lecture, what causal criteria is mainly demonstrated by this study? Provide your justification.

Solutions

Expert Solution

Relative risk of cases of brain cancer in radiation group (1-4.99) = incidence in radiation group 1-4.99÷ incidence in radiation group 0-0.99.

=1300/10000÷2700/25000

Relative risk=1.203

Relative risk in radiation group more than 5 = incidence in radiation group more than 5÷ incidence in radiation group 0-0.99

=1500/2000÷2700/25000

Relative risk =6.944

Bradford Hill proposed criteria to establish such an argument.one such criteria is strength of association.relative risk is the factor showing association of casuating factor to incidence. here in the study relative risk of 1.20 in radiation group (1-5) means that this group has 1.2 times more chance of getting brain cancer than reference group (ie. 0-0.99).

While relative risk of 6.944 in radiation greater than 5 group shows this group have 6.944 times more chance of getting brain cancer than reference group.

Hope this helps. All the best ?


Related Solutions

In a study of obesity the following results were obtained from samples of males and females...
In a study of obesity the following results were obtained from samples of males and females between the ages of 20 and 75: n Number OverweightMales 150 21 Females 200 48 Can we conclude from these data that in the sampled populations there is a difference in the proportions who are overweight? Let a = .05.
Consider the data in the following table, obtained from a cohort study conducted by Iso and...
Consider the data in the following table, obtained from a cohort study conducted by Iso and colleagues [Isa H, Date C, Yamamoto A, et al. Smoking cessation and mortality from cardiovascular disease among Japanese men and women. The JACC study. Am J Epidmeiol. 2005;161(2):170-179.]. Total Cardiovascular Disease According to Smoking Status Disease Current Smoker Cases Person-years Yes 882 — 220,965 No 673 — 189,254 Calculate the rate ratio and corresponding 95% confidence interval for these data. Express your answer to...
Study Nike's environmental goals and analyze the results.
Study Nike's environmental goals and analyze the results.
In a statistic class, 11 scores were randomly selected with the following results were obtained: 68,...
In a statistic class, 11 scores were randomly selected with the following results were obtained: 68, 74, 66, 37, 52, 71, 90, 65, 76, 73, 22. What are the outer fences? A)-6.0, 140.0 B)-10.0, 92.0 C)2.0, 128.0 D)2.0, 162.0 E)37.0, 107.0
Briefly state the primary problem that results from lack of randomization in an observational cohort study.
Briefly state the primary problem that results from lack of randomization in an observational cohort study.
Study Nike's environmental goals and analyze the results briefly.
Study Nike's environmental goals and analyze the results briefly.
The following sample of 9 values were obtained in a study of the relationship between the...
The following sample of 9 values were obtained in a study of the relationship between the weight and chest size of infants at birth: Weight (kg) 2.75 2.15 4.41 5.52 3.21 4.32 2.31 4.30 3.71 Chest size (cm) 29.5 26.3 32.2 36.5 27.2 27.7 28.3 30.3 28.7 Obtain a scatter plot of the data and comment on the correlation between the two variables. Compute the correlation coefficient (r) and test whether it differs from 0 (use level of significance of...
In a study conducted of proctored and non- proctored algebra tests, researches obtained the following results:...
In a study conducted of proctored and non- proctored algebra tests, researches obtained the following results: Proctored: n=30, x=74.30, s= 12.87 Non Proctored: n=32, x= 74.26, s= 18.15 Use 0.01 to test the claim that students taking non proctored tests get a higher mean that those taking proctored tests.
which two of the following study design are best for assessing temporality, please select two? a)cohort...
which two of the following study design are best for assessing temporality, please select two? a)cohort b)experimental C) cross sectional d) ecological E) case control
Which study design is best to minimize confounders--cohort or case-control?
Which study design is best to minimize confounders--cohort or case-control?
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT