In: Finance
A 3-year-old machine purchased by the company for $200,000 is getting old and unable to meet today’s market demands. The machine can be upgraded now for $80,000 or sold for $40,000. The current machine will have an annual operating and maintenance (O&M) cost of $100,000 and a $30,000 salvage value in 3 years. If upgraded, the old machine will be retained for only 3 more years, then replaced with a new machine.
The replacement machine, which can serve the company now and for at least 8 years, costs $200,000. In addition, there are shipping and handling charges of $20,000. Its salvage value will be $40,000 for years 1 through 4; $20,000 after 5 years; and $10,000 thereafter. It will have an annual operating and maintenance cost of $65,000 per year.
The company wants to perform an economic analysis at 15% per year using a 3-year planning horizon.
Compare the Capital Recovery (CR) for the replacement machine (challenger) over the study period of 3 years and an expected life of 8 years. Use 4 decimal places of the compound interest factors to do your calculation. Show detailed steps of your replacement analysis.
| PARTICULARS | EXISTING | |
| $ | ||
| IF WE UPGRADE THE EXISTING MACHINE | 80000 | |
| OPERATING & MAINT . COST | 100000 | |
| FOR THREE YEARS | ||
| PRESENT VALUE FACTOR 15% FOR THREE YEARS | 2.283 | |
| PRESNET VALUE OF OPERATING COST IS | 100000*2.283 | 228300 |
| 308300 | ||
| SCRAP VALUE AT THE END OF THREE YEAR | 30000 | |
| LESS PRESNT VALUE FACTOR IN YEAR THREE OF SCRAP | 0.657 | 19710 |
| PRESNT VALUE OF NET CASH FLOW | 288590 | |
| EQUIVALENT CASH OUFLOW PER ANNUM | 288590/2.283 | 126408.2348 |
| PURCHASE COST OF NEW MACHINE | 200000+20000 | 220000 |
| PLUS SHIPPING CHARGE | ||
| LESS SALE VALUE OF OLD MACHINE | 40000 | |
| NET CASH FLOW IN YEAR 1 | 180000 | |
| OPERATING & MAINT . COST | 65000 | |
| FOR THREE YEARS | ||
| PRESENT VALUE FACTOR 15% FOR THREE YEARS | 2.283 | |
| PRESNET VALUE OF OPERATING COST IS | 65000*2.283 | 148395 |
| SCRAP VALUE AT THE END OF THREE YEAR | 40000 | |
| LESS PRESNT VALUE FACTOR IN YEAR THREE OF SCRAP | 0.657 | 26280 |
| PRESNT VALUE OF NET CASH FLOW | 302115 | |
| EQUIVALENT CASH OUFLOW PER ANNUM | 302115/2.283 | 132332.4573 |
| IN THIS EQUIVALENT CASH OUFLOW PER ANNUM IS LOWER IN CASE 1 AS UP | ||
| GRADING THE MACHINE. SO WE GO FOR UPGRADTION FOR THREE YEARS AND AFTER | ||
| THAT GO PURCHASE OF NEW MACHINE | ||
| CAPITAL RECOVERY MEANS | ||
| RETURN OF INVESTED CAPITAL OVER AN INVESTMENT LIFE SPAN |