Question

In: Accounting

what is the major drawback of the SOX act?

what is the major drawback of the SOX act?

Solutions

Expert Solution

There are four major drawbacks of SOX act -

1. It is costly
One of the biggest criticisms of SOX is that the rules are the same for both large multi-national companies and small public companies. In particular, Section 404 hits publicly funded corporations harder as they need to have the resources in place to execute what the section demands.

2. It results in increased audit fees
Since 2002, audit fees have increases substantially as a result of auditors being forced to be more accountable for the audit reports on their clients. As the liability of auditors increase, so does the audit fee. These added expenses can take a toll on the profit of a company.

3. Increased Personnel

An important function of SOX guidelines is the segregation of accounting duties. This ensures that one individual does not handle certain accounting processes from start to finish, which may increase the chances of fraud or embezzlement. In order to meet the segregation of duties requirement, companies must add additional accounting personnel. Using current employees outside the accounting office is not acceptable because it breaks down the internal controls function.

4. Tougher Penalties

Penalties for accounting fraud and embezzlement were increased under the new SOX guidelines. Unfortunately, some penalties enacted focused on minimal violations, such as not signing financial statements or issuing statements to the public stating that executive management has approved of any financial information released by the company. Strict penalties on such minor infractions may limit the executive talent pool if future management employees do not wish to be liable for such actions and penalties.


Related Solutions

what are SOX ( Sarbanes Oxley Act) provisions and how have SOX provisions, SEC-related rules, and...
what are SOX ( Sarbanes Oxley Act) provisions and how have SOX provisions, SEC-related rules, and listing standards influenced the Corporate Governance structure?
explain the highlights of Sarbanes oxley act (SOX)?
explain the highlights of Sarbanes oxley act (SOX)?
What are some of the critiques addressing traditional economic model? What could be a major drawback...
What are some of the critiques addressing traditional economic model? What could be a major drawback of behavioral economics when it is applied to health? 
Discuss one major benefit and one major drawback of those assumptions. What does penalty cost mean...
Discuss one major benefit and one major drawback of those assumptions. What does penalty cost mean in the context of inventory management? Explain the concept of “loss of goodwill” in the context of inventory management.
what drawback does the presence of market failure create in the microeconomy? How is this drawback...
what drawback does the presence of market failure create in the microeconomy? How is this drawback typically created?
The supplementary document/resource titled “SOX Act 101-Key Components”, references eight key implementation components of the SOX...
The supplementary document/resource titled “SOX Act 101-Key Components”, references eight key implementation components of the SOX Act. Given what you know about why the Act was established in 2002, explain which of those eight sections you feel was most necessary in the effort to discourage fraudulent activities by organizations. Additionally, explain which is your favorite section.
The Sarbanes Oxley (SOX) Act was passed in 2002 as a result of corporate scandals and...
The Sarbanes Oxley (SOX) Act was passed in 2002 as a result of corporate scandals and in as attempt to regain public trust in accounting and reporting practices. Two random samples of 1015 executives were surveyed and asked their opinion about accounting practices in both 2000 and in 2006. The table below summarizes all 2030 responses to the question, “Which of the following do you consider most critical to establishing ethical and legal accounting and reporting practices?” Did the distribution...
The Sarbanes-Oxley (SOX) Act was enacted in 2002 for companies in the private sector as a...
The Sarbanes-Oxley (SOX) Act was enacted in 2002 for companies in the private sector as a result of the Enron and other scandals. However, it does not apply to government. Should SOX-like provisions be required for the federal government? Has there been any move in this direction? Why or why not?
Explain the goals of Sarbanes-Oxley Act (SOX) legislation? original answer please
Explain the goals of Sarbanes-Oxley Act (SOX) legislation? original answer please
The Sarbanes-Oxley Act (SOX) was enacted in the wake of accounting scandals in the early 200s....
The Sarbanes-Oxley Act (SOX) was enacted in the wake of accounting scandals in the early 200s. Examine one (1) of the following white collar crime cases in detail and compare it to SOX: Adelphia Enron Global Crossing Halliburton Qwest Tyco MCI WorldCom Olympus HealthSouth Parmalat AIG Bernard Madoff Key elements of your paper should include: A brief background of the company An overview of the case: The key actors - Who are they: what are their backgrounds, titles, and roles...
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT