Question

In: Nursing

How is relativism self-refuting? Provide examples

How is relativism self-refuting? Provide examples

Solutions

Expert Solution

A doctrine is self-refuting if its truth implies its falsehood. Relativism asserts that the truth-value of a statement is always relative to some particular standpoint. This implies that the same statement can be both true and false. ... Relativism, they can claim, is simply in the same situation as any other theory.

Relativism is Self-Refuting. A doctrine is self-refuting if its truth implies its falsehood. Relativism asserts that the truth-value of a statement is always relative to some particular standpoint. This implies that the same statement can be both true and false.

Cognitive Relativism

Cognitive relativism asserts the relativity of truth. Because of the close connections between the concept of truth and concepts such as knowledge, rationality, and justification, cognitive relativism is often taken to encompass, or imply, the relativity of these other notions also. Thus, epistemological relativism, which asserts the relativity of knowledge, may be understood as a version of cognitive relativism, or at least as entailed by it.

This kind of relativism can take different forms depending on the nature of the standpoint or framework to which truth is relativized. If truth is relativized to the individual subject, for instance, the result is a form of subjectivism. If the standpoint is an entire culture, the result is some form of cultural relativism. Other possible frameworks include languages, historical periods, and conceptual schemes. These frameworks do not exclude one another, of course, and in the positions developed by thinkers such as Thomas Kuhn and Michel Foucault (both generally regarded as holding relativistic views of truth) they are presented as interwoven.

Cognitive relativism is not so widely held as moral relativism. Moral relativism is the view that moral judgments (those employing concepts like good, bad, right or wrong) should only be assessed relative to a particular, limited standpoint (usually that of a specific culture). This doctrine became a commonplace for many growing up in modernized societies in the second half of the twentieth century and is virtually the default position encountered among undergraduates by countless philosophy instructors today. One major reason for its popularity is the importance attached by so many thinkers to the distinction between facts and values. Factual judgments are generally thought to be objective and provable; value judgments, by contrast, are commonly held to express subjective attitudes and to be unprovable, rather like judgments of taste.

Gradually, however, cognitive relativism has gained in credibility as the sharp logical dichotomy between facts ands values has been increasingly questioned. Instead of a dichotomy, many now argue for a spectrum of judgments with a greater or lesser evaluative component to them. Moreover, these components themselves may not be seen as radically different; they may, for instance, simply reflect the degree to which a judgment is controversial within a particular community, with what we call factual judgments being the least disputed. From this point of view, cognitive relativism is broader and more fundamental than moral relativism, for it asserts that the truth value of all judgments, not just moral ones, is relative.


Related Solutions

Discuss and summarize the main principles of effective self-disclosure and provide two examples of positive self...
Discuss and summarize the main principles of effective self-disclosure and provide two examples of positive self disclosure and negative self disclosure.
Explain in a short paragraph and give examples 3. Define Ethnocentrism and Cultural Relativism - How...
Explain in a short paragraph and give examples 3. Define Ethnocentrism and Cultural Relativism - How would you balance cultural relativism and universal human rights? Do you think that you could remain neutral in your judgement of all the behaviors you might see in a small - scale society? Give at least one example. 4. How development of agriculture helped lay foundation for development of complex societies? 5. Discuss the evolution of gen der roles. Give specific examples . Define...
Provide an explanation in support of or refuting the following statement: Humans would never develop natural...
Provide an explanation in support of or refuting the following statement: Humans would never develop natural immunity to a novel biological agent created in a laboratory
How do you build self confidence please give examples
How do you build self confidence please give examples
How does ethical relativism applie to business practices?
How does ethical relativism applie to business practices?
Define/distinguish the difference concepts of ethnocentrism and cultural relativism. Provide and discuss an example of each...
Define/distinguish the difference concepts of ethnocentrism and cultural relativism. Provide and discuss an example of each concept.
What is the "false self system"? What are some examples of the false self? Why is...
What is the "false self system"? What are some examples of the false self? Why is it apart of our personalities?
What is sociological relativism? What is cultural relativism, and what are the problems associated with cultural...
What is sociological relativism? What is cultural relativism, and what are the problems associated with cultural relativism? What is anti-anti relativism?
Discuss How do markets provide for an efficient allocation of scarce resources? Provide examples
Discuss How do markets provide for an efficient allocation of scarce resources? Provide examples
Discuss Moore’s law and provide examples of how it affects companies.
Discuss Moore’s law and provide examples of how it affects companies.
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT