Case 3: Recently, an association that represented police in New Jersey complained that the incidence of...

Case 3: Recently, an association that represented police in New Jersey complained that the incidence of cancer was unusually high among police officers who used radar guns in tracking the speed of drivers. The association brought suit against the state, claiming that those officers who used these radar guns had an incidence of cancer 18 percent higher than a comparable group of government workers from the state park service who were randomly selected for comparison purposes. The comparison sample and the police officers were matched on educational level, age, gender, and years of service. The sample was large: 283 police officers and 231 park workers.

Was the case justified? Why or why not? (Be sure to support your answer with reference to the strengths and weaknesses of the design, and consider possible confounds.)

What kind of study is this? What are the problems associated with this kind of study?

How would you improve the study?

Expert Solution

The study was meant to asses whether using radar guns had any association with cancer. In this study the police officers handling the radar guns were compared with a sample of government workers from state park service. These two samples are totally different, which causes many other confounding variables to arise, as the sample itself is different. So, the difference we see may not be related to radar guns, but may be related to other factors. Therefore, the case is not justified, as the incidence of cancer cannot be attributed directly to the use of radar guns.

Our aim is be only to measure effect of radar guns on the incidence of cancer among police officers. For this, both the groups should consists of police officers, only expect one group handles radar guns and the other does not. Both the groups which consists police officers, are matched on educational level, age gender, years of service etc. But, one group should be of police officers who use radar guns, and the other who doesn't. These two groups should be now measured on the incidence of cancer. The difference of incidence in cancer rates between groups may suggest that radar guns use is related to cancer.

Hayet Jeridi answered 1 year ago

Twenty five candidates for the New Jersey State Police Academy took an entrance examination in 1999....

Twenty five candidates for the New Jersey State Police Academy took an entrance examination in 1999. The data below show the scores received on this examination. They also show the gender of each recruit. # of Correct Answers Gender 15 Male 17 Female 12 Male 11 Male 14 Male 12 Male 16 Female 10 Female 10 Male 10 Male 20 Female 15 Female 14 Male 10 Male 15 Male 19 Female 11 Male 13 Male 14 Female 13 Female 21...

Case: The incidence of a new infectious disease in Country A (population 20 million) during 2011...

Case: The incidence of a new infectious disease in Country A (population 20 million) during 2011 was 80 per 100,000. After catching the disease, the average person had the illness for five days. The cost of treating one case of the disease was $20 for each day the case had the disease. In 2012, the disease spread to Country Z (population 30 million), whose population closely resembles the population of Country A in terms of demographic characteristics such as age...

in a college in new jersey 1/3 of the students live off campus while 5/9 of...

in a college in new jersey 1/3 of the students live off campus while 5/9 of the students live in new jersey. furthermore 3/4 of the students live on campus or are not from new jersey. if a student is selected at random from the college, what is the probAbility a) student lives on campus and is not from new jersey b) the student is not from new jersey provided they live on campus c) student lives on campus provided...

Business Decision Case New Haven Corporation recently identified an investment opportunity involving the purchase of a...

Business Decision Case New Haven Corporation recently identified an investment opportunity involving the purchase of a patent that will permit the company to modify its line of CD recorders. The patent’s purchase price is $720,000 and the legal protection it provides will last for five more years; there is no salvage value. However, after preparing the capital expenditure analysis below, New Haven’s treasurer has recommended to the company’s capital budgeting committee that the investment be rejected. Brad Decker, chairperson of...

Question 3 You are a management consultant who has recently introduced a new procedure to a...

Question 3 You are a management consultant who has recently introduced a new procedure to a reception office. The receptionist should do at least 10 minutes of paperwork in each hour. You made a check on 40 random hours of work and found that the mean time spent on paperwork is 8.95 minutes with a standard deviation of 3 minutes. Test to see if the new procedure meets specifications at a 1% level of significance. [18 marks]

Short Case: Luna's New Reality Meet Luna. Luna recently moved in with her daughter and son-in-law....

Short Case: Luna's New Reality Meet Luna. Luna recently moved in with her daughter and son-in-law. She was married for 50 years to her husband, Robert. They raised one daughter, Alma. They lived comfortably in a small mobile home in northern rural Pennsylvania. Unfortunately, last year, Robert suffered an unexpected fatal heart attack. Luna slowly slipped into depression and it became apparent that she was not able to maintain their home nor continue to care for herself. Alma would travel...

CASE 3–18 Ethics and the Manager [Course Objective B] Terri Ronsin had recently been transferred to...

CASE 3–18 Ethics and the Manager [Course Objective B] Terri Ronsin had recently been transferred to the Home Security Systems Division of National Home Products. Shortly after taking over her new position as divisional controller, she was asked to develop the division’s predetermined overhead rate for the upcoming year. The accuracy of the rate is important because it is used throughout the year and any overapplied or underapplied over- head is closed out to Cost of Goods Sold at the...

Wildcat Gym, with its 3 branches located in Central New York, wants to assign three recently...

Wildcat Gym, with its 3 branches located in Central New York, wants to assign three recently hired health consultants - Todd, Josh, and Nina - to its 3 branches in Cortland, Auburn, and Oneonta. It is clearly indicated from its Headquarters that none of these three consultants will be assigned to the same locations. The relocate costs are shown here in the table. Consultant/Location Cortland Auburn Oneonta Todd $720 $680 $550 Josh $700 $710 $588 Nina $655 $635 $495 Part...

Case Application 3: TEAM FUN! Tony, the new director of human resources, and Edna, the compensation...

Case Application 3: TEAM FUN! Tony, the new director of human resources, and Edna, the compensation and benefits manager, are hanging employment legislation posters in RETREAT, the TEAM FUN! employee cafeteria. Edna offers, “I remember some woman who applied for a job to advertise men’s baseball gear and sued when she didn’t get the job. The EEOC said she had no case. A couple of years ago, we moved Fred from fitness demos to stock management because he couldn’t do...

CASE 3 The provider visits an 80-year-old patient and asks if anything new has been bothering...

CASE 3 The provider visits an 80-year-old patient and asks if anything new has been bothering her. She says she has been having pain from her upper stomach and esophagus every night and gets slightly nauseous. She is Chinese and has been using her specially made peppermint tea to calm her stomach after dinner and before bed. Peppermint herbal tea has been used in her family as long as she can remember to calm the stomach. The provider recognizes that...

Question