Question

In: Operations Management

Peter Kraljic distinguishes four types of product categories in these two dimensions: Strategic items (High profit...

Peter Kraljic distinguishes four types of product categories in these two dimensions:

  1. Strategic items (High profit impact and high supply risk). These types of products are purchased from one supplier. There may be a balance of power between the company and the supplier, but when this supplier ceases to deliver, purchasing stagnates. In general, raw materials belong to this category. Raw materials determine to a large extent the value of the cost price of the finished product.
  2. Bottleneck items (Low profit impact and high supply risk). These items do not represent a high value but they are a vulnerable factor in the entire supply chain. These are products that are essential for the production process but they are difficult to obtain. There is an imbalance of power between the company and the supplier, in which the supplier is the dominant factor. By creating buffer stock of these scarce items and by finding alternative suppliers, a company can undermine this position.
  3. Leverage items (High profit impact and low supply risk). These types of products can easily be purchased from different suppliers and they determine to a large extent the value of the cost price of the finished product. A minor change in price or a change in quality will strongly affect the cost price. In the balance of power between the company and the supplier, the company is the dominant factor. By concluding good framework agreements and drawing up targeted pricing, the relationship between the company and the supplier continues to be in harmony.
  4. Non-critical items (Low profit impact and low supply risk). These types of products cause the least problems with respect to purchasing performance. Such products represent a low value and they can be purchased in different varieties and from different suppliers. Most raw materials and substances fall into this category. There is a balance of power between the company and the supplier. By increasing product standardisation, much time and money can be saved.

After critiquing on the two dimensions (supply risk and profit impact) of Kraljic’s model, concentrating on how appropriate each dimension is for use in the development of sourcing strategies. Explain the limitations of the model and any information gaps that may result from using only the two dimensions.

Solutions

Expert Solution

Introduction:

In recent years, purchasing has become a strategic utility that deals with numerous transaction supply chains and conveys an economical and valuable arrangement for organisations that function within that chain, due to the current pace of business environments which has “expanded that role to control of the entire sourcing and acquisition process” (Sollish, F. et al, 2012). Sourcing now plays a massive role in guaranteeing that the approaches used through appropriate supplier management processes are optimally designed. This can only be done when sourcing is seen as a strategic perspective within the supply chain process mainly because excellent sourcing practices can lead to a consistent and economical supply base for the organization. The Kraljic Portfolio Purchasing Model is used by organizations to ensure supply security and reduce costs, because "purchasing must become supply management” (Kraljic, P. 1983).

Evaluation:

There are two dimensions on which the Kraljic portfolio purchasing model is based upon, which are profit impact and supply risk (Sollish, F. et al 2012).

  • Profit Impact: defined as low or high, based on the importance of purchasing material, the materials added value towards the organisation, and its cost effects on the organisations overall profitability.
  • Supply risk: defined as low or high, based on the complexity of the supply, its obtainability or the readiness of more up-to-date materials/technology, cost of logistics, and the availability of different manufacturers, vendors and suppliers.

When put together, these two dimensions create four quadrants known as Leverage items, Strategic items, Non-critical items and Bottleneck items. Different sourcing strategies must be developed and implemented for each quadrant, in order to reduce organisational expenditure (Kähkönen, A.K. et al 2012).

Using the Kraljics model, an organisation can improve its sourcing strategies which may lead to significant cost savings by spreading the materials/products across the four quadrants. This will reduce the amount of risk taken by the organisation and allow the organisation to have the upper hand when dealing with suppliers(Ellram, L. M. 1995). Once all products/materials have been places in the quadrants, the organisation will then understand how to evaluate risk and maximise profits, and accordingly, prepare its sourcing strategies (Chen, I.J. et al 2004).

For leverage items, the organisation is at an advantage against the supplier, and could mean higher profit margins and lower risks for the organisation. Strategic items are crucial for the organisation and suppliers should be on the priority list of the organisation sourcing team due to the high risk and low supply. Non-critical items are readily available and appose almost no risk and no impact on the organisations financial status. Finally, Bottleneck items are short in supply and high in risk, however these items also have a low profit impact on the organisation. the organisations needs to implement an appropriate sourcing and purchasing strategy for each item based on its risk and profit impact (Caniels, M.C.J.et al 2005).

Conclusion:

Though The Kraljic Portfolio Purchasing Model helps organisations better understand where to place their products/items in terms of supply risk and profit impact, the model has its limitations (Gelderman, C.J. et al 2005).Measurements of supply risk and profit impacts cannot be constantly and accurately measured, conflict may arise between buyer and seller resulting in shifting of power dominance, no financial risk assessment or analysis is included in the base risk factor and finally, if the buyer can use this model, then so can the supplier, thus putting them at an advantage position as well(Caniels, M.C.J. et al 2007).


Related Solutions

The four primary types of risk in a project are: strategic fit, new service or product...
The four primary types of risk in a project are: strategic fit, new service or product and the unforeseen design consequences that can occur, the ability to meet the project specifications, and poor design, communication, and planning. Discuss a real-life project (personal example or a researched example) and discuss how risk was or was not managed properly as well as the steps that should be taken when identifying and managing risk in a project.
a) Discuss each of the four categories of services provided by CPA firms b) Two types...
a) Discuss each of the four categories of services provided by CPA firms b) Two types of attestation services provided by CPA firms ate audits and reviews. Discuss the similarities and differences between these two types of attestation services. Which type provides the most assurance?
a manufacturer of two types of swings, Tarzan and High Flyer, makes a profit of $59...
a manufacturer of two types of swings, Tarzan and High Flyer, makes a profit of $59 on Tarzan swings and $69 on High Flyer swings. In the manufacturing process of each Tarzan swings require 4 hours of assembly and 4 hours of finishing while High Flyer swings require 6 hours of assembly and 10 hours of finishing. Due to warehouse contraints the manufacturer only hss 144 hours a day available for assembly and 200 hours a day for finishing. assuming...
Four types of Strategic Control: Strategic Control refers to tracking the rollout of a marketing strategy....
Four types of Strategic Control: Strategic Control refers to tracking the rollout of a marketing strategy. Learn about four types of strategic control and how their use increases the chances that your strategy will be successful. Pick one using your own words and another references, explain why it’s an important control. http://smallbusiness.chron.com/four-types-strategic-control-14720.html
1. Use the dimensions of warmth and control to describe the four major types of parenting....
1. Use the dimensions of warmth and control to describe the four major types of parenting. Which style seems to promote the best development in children? Explain 2. Most people view puberty as a strictly biological event. Enlighten them by describing both physiological and environmental factors that influence the process of puberty.
Low Wages, High Wages, and Taxes. There are two categories of people: those that receive high...
Low Wages, High Wages, and Taxes. There are two categories of people: those that receive high nominal wages and those that receive low nominal wages. Denote these two nominal wages as WH (high wages) and WL (low wages), respectively, and WH > WL . The utility function for each person, regardless of the nominal wage he/she receives, is identical: u (c,l) =lnc +lnl , in which, exactly as in Chapter 2, c stands for consumption and l stands for leisure....
Low Wages, High Wages, and Taxes. There are two categories of people: those that receive high...
Low Wages, High Wages, and Taxes. There are two categories of people: those that receive high nominal wages and those that receive low nominal wages. Denote these two nominal wages as WH (high wages) and WL (low wages), respectively, and WH > WL . The utility function for each person, regardless of the nominal wage he/she receives, is identical: u (c,l) =lnc +lnl , in which, exactly as in Chapter 2, c stands for consumption and l stands for leisure....
Low Wages, High Wages, and Taxes. There are two categories of people: those that receive high...
Low Wages, High Wages, and Taxes. There are two categories of people: those that receive high nominal wages and those that receive low nominal wages. Denote these two nominal wages as WH (high wages) and WL (low wages), respectively, and WH > WL . The utility function for each person, regardless of the nominal wage he/she receives, is identical: u (c,l) =lnc +lnl , in which, exactly as in Chapter 2, c stands for consumption and l stands for leisure....
1.Describe the two types of product classifications. 2.Define the four types of consumer products. 3.Define a...
1.Describe the two types of product classifications. 2.Define the four types of consumer products. 3.Define a product item, a product line, and a product mix. 4.Describe the two key reasons why a firm might make adjustments to a product item, product line, or product mix. 5.Define the four primary adjustments a firm might make when adjusting product items, product lines, or product mixes. -Principles of Marketing.
1) A grocery store carries the following items. There are two main categories of food –...
1) A grocery store carries the following items. There are two main categories of food – conventional and organic ingredients – and four food groups. The data are shown in the following table. Food Groups Food Categories Grains Fruits Vegetables Meat Total Conventional 82 48 276 204 610 Organic 93 77 24 11 205 Total 175 125 300 215 815 If all of the grains and meats were accidentally displayed together without a sticker or label to mark their origin,...
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT