Question

In: Economics

Hello all, 1) Apply the categorical imperative (Kant) to the Bernie Madoff affair.

Hello all,

1) Apply the categorical imperative (Kant) to the Bernie Madoff affair.

Solutions

Expert Solution

German philosopher Immanuel Kant (1724–1804) accepted the basic proposition that a theory of duties—a set of rules telling us what we’re obligated to do in any particular situation—was the right approach to ethical problems. What he set out to add, though, was a stricter mechanism for the use of duties in our everyday experience. He wanted a way to get all these duties we’ve been talking about to work together, to produce a unified recommendation, instead of leaving us confused between loyalty to one principle and another. At least on some basic issues, Kant set out to produce ethical certainty.

Bernie Madoff always claimed that the Ponzi scheme wasn’t the original idea. He sought money from investors planning to score big with complicated financial maneuvers. He took a few losses early on, though, and faced the possibility of everyone just taking their cash and going home. That’s when he started channeling money from new investors to older ones, claiming the funds were the fruit of his excellent stock dealing. He always intended, Madoff says, to get the money back, score some huge successes, and they’d let him get on the straight and narrow again. It never happened. But that doesn’t change the fact that Madoff thought it would. He was lying temporarily, and for the good of everyone in the long run.

Sheryl Weinstein had a twenty-year affair with Madoff. She also invested her family’s life savings with him. When the Ponzi scheme came undone, she lost everything. To get some money back, she considered writing a tell-all, and that led to a heart-wrenching decision between money and her personal life. Her twenty-year dalliance was not widely known, and things could have remained that way: her husband and son could’ve gone on without the whole world knowing that the husband was a cuckold and the son the product of a poisoned family. But they needed money because they’d lost everything, including their home, in Madoff’s scam.

A categorical imperative, is something you need to do all the time: there are ethical rules that don’t depend on the circumstances, and it’s the job of the categorical imperative to tell us what they are. Here, we will consider two distinct expressions of Kant’s categorical imperative, two ways that guidance is provided.

Kant’s categorical imperative shows is that lying cannot be universalized. The act of lying can’t survive in a world where everyone’s just making stuff up all the time. Since no one will be taking anyone else seriously, you may try to sell a false story but no one will be buying.

Kant sees it he has to make a basic decision: should I lie to investors to keep my operation afloat? The answer is no. According to the categorical imperative, it must be no, not because lying is directly immoral, but because lying cannot be universalized and therefore it’s immoral.

The same goes for Sheryl Weinstein as she wonders whether she should keep the lid on her family-wrecking affair. The answer is no because the answer is always no when the question is whether I should lie. You might want to respond by insisting, “She’s already done the deed, and Bernie’s in jail so it’s not going to happen again. The best thing at this point would be for her to just keep her mouth shut and hold her family together as best she can.” That’s a fair argument. But for Kant it’s also a loser because the categorical imperative gives the last word. There’s no appeal. There’s no lying, no matter what.

The first expression of the categorical imperative—act in such a way that the rule for your action could be universalized—is a consistency principle. Like the golden rule (treat others as you’d like to be treated), it forces you to ask how things would work if everyone else did what you’re considering doing.


Related Solutions

Can someone please explain applying the categorical imperative concept by Immanuel Kant to the Bernie Madoff...
Can someone please explain applying the categorical imperative concept by Immanuel Kant to the Bernie Madoff affair? Thank you
Which of these ethical theories: egoism, Utilitarianism, Kant and Deontology, First Formula of the Categorical imperative,...
Which of these ethical theories: egoism, Utilitarianism, Kant and Deontology, First Formula of the Categorical imperative, Second formula of the categorical imperative, or virtue ethics, would be most applicable in addressing accounting ethical dilemmas, why?
Explain what Kant meant by "categorical imperative." Explain why you do or do not agree with...
Explain what Kant meant by "categorical imperative." Explain why you do or do not agree with this idea. Describe the relationship between Kant's idea of the categorical imperative and his search for morality. Why does Kant think morality is a duty for all humans?
Ethics question 1.Explain the Formula of Humanity formulation of the Categorical Imperative (or the Universal Law...
Ethics question 1.Explain the Formula of Humanity formulation of the Categorical Imperative (or the Universal Law formulation). 2. Give an example of an action that would be impermissible according to the Categorical Imperative. 3. Give an example of an action that would be permissible according to the Categorical Imperative. 4. Explain in detail why the Categorical Imperative (so understood) would judge those actions as you believe it does.
Please Address all those parts of Bentham, Mill and kant: 1) Bentham Principles? Utilitarianism? hedonistic calculus?...
Please Address all those parts of Bentham, Mill and kant: 1) Bentham Principles? Utilitarianism? hedonistic calculus? Criticisms? 2) Mill Utilitarianism? Higher VS Lower Pleasures? Arguments for preferring higher to lower pleasures? Criticisms? 3) Kant Ground work Good Will? Acting for duty’s sake?
1. The marginal rate of substitution is ________________ (Select all that apply)
1. The marginal rate of substitution is ________________ (Select all that apply)a. Equal to the slope of the budget line at an optimal point if the optimal point is not at a corner.b. How much of each good a consumer can afford.c. The amount of one good an individual would be willing to trade for a different good and be just as well off.d. The slope of the indifference curve.e. Equal to the price ratio at an optimal point if...
Which of the following are TRUE? Select all that apply. A probability of 1 is the...
Which of the following are TRUE? Select all that apply. A probability of 1 is the same as a probability of 100% The difference between interval and ordinal data is that interval data has a natural zero. If you are doing a study and the population is Americans, the easiest type of study to run would be a simple random sample. If your population is 80% female and your sample is 60% male, there is undercoverage bias. In order to...
An enzyme (select all that apply) 1) is not altered by reaction with a substrate 2)...
An enzyme (select all that apply) 1) is not altered by reaction with a substrate 2) is changed by reaction with a substrateis 3) made of carbohydrate 4) can be reused if not damaged 5) is made of protein 6) slows the rate of chemical reactions 7) increases the rate of chemical reaction Select all that apply. An enzyme 1) is a carbohydrate 2) is a protein 3) is a biological catalyst 4) is changed by reaction with a substrate...
1) Which of the following is not true? Select all that apply: a) Advances in technology...
1) Which of the following is not true? Select all that apply: a) Advances in technology are only possible in advanced economies. b) Advances in technology have no impact on worker productivity c) Advances in technology increase worker productivity d) Technological change is a combination of invention and innovation. 2) A common measure of productivity used to track growth of GDP per capita is ________________ Select the correct answer below: a) quantity of labor used in production b) dollar value...
1. The risk premium is _____. Check all that apply: the reward for bearing risk the...
1. The risk premium is _____. Check all that apply: the reward for bearing risk the difference between the expected rate of return on an asset and the risk-free rate normally zero for risky assets normally positive for risky assets 2. An investor wants to invest money in Treasury bills and a risky fund managed by Infinity Capital. The investor wants to achieve an expected return of 10% on his complete portfolio. Infinity Capital has an expected return of 9%...
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT