Question

In: Physics

Generate an entangled pair of qubits. Send to Alice and Bob far away from each other....

Generate an entangled pair of qubits. Send to Alice and Bob far away from each other. Both measure along basis in one of two possible orientations. The result is sent to Charlie at some later time, who compares the corellations and concludes the Bell inequalities have been violated.

But in Copenhagen, Charlie can say, the pair of results didn't become real until I collected both observations from Alice and Bob. They weren't real when either of them measured them. They only became real once I observed them. Then, both results, when they materialized, materialized at the same place. So, no nonlocality?

Solutions

Expert Solution

Yes, this restores locality, and is sometimes called "Solipsistic Copenhagen". It is described on the first page of Everett's thesis and paper on many worlds. The solipsistic Copenhagen interpretation is the only you can collapse the wavefunction, everyone else is in superposition.

From this interpretation to many worlds is only the step of moving the collapsing entity away from youself, and noting there is no contradiction with experiment, so the whole collapse thing is not really required, and one can logical positivistically remove it from the theory, at the cost of saying that the notion of reality and definite events is not physics, but how the branches get selected by the memories of observers. It moves the question away from physics to philosophy of mind.

While I think this is a neat trick, it might not be nature's trick. One has to be sure quantum mechanics is exact before declaring it so.


Related Solutions

How to generate a key pair for Alice and Bob Respectively Suppose Alice sends plaintext P=...
How to generate a key pair for Alice and Bob Respectively Suppose Alice sends plaintext P= 113, how does she encrypt and whats the ciphertext C? After Bob receives C, how does he decrypts it to get the plaintext P? Suppose Alice sends plaintext P= 113, how does she sign it and what are sent to Bob. How does Bob verify the signature? Suppose Bob sends plaintext P=113, how does he sign it and what are sent Alice. How does...
RSA: Alice wishes to send Bob the message POET. Suppose Bob chooses P = 29, Q...
RSA: Alice wishes to send Bob the message POET. Suppose Bob chooses P = 29, Q = 31, E = 47, and D = 143. Show the steps that Alice uses to encrypt the message POET (use the ascii values of the letters P, O, E, and T), and how Bob decrypts the message he receives from Alice. You will be generating very large numbers, and will find the following calculator helpful: https://www.calculator.net/big-number-calculator.html
Alice and Bob bet 50 dollars with each other in a game in which their friend...
Alice and Bob bet 50 dollars with each other in a game in which their friend Charlie tosses a two-sided coin 3 times in a remote location. If Alice correctly predicts the majority face (i.e. the face which occurred the most often in the three tosses), she gets to keep Bob's money as well. Charlie calls them and lets them know that at least 1 heads has occurred.a) Assuming that the coin was fair, what is the probability that the...
Consider a spacecraft that is far away from planets or other massive objects. The mass of...
Consider a spacecraft that is far away from planets or other massive objects. The mass of the spacecraft is M = 1.5×105 kg. The rocket engines are shut off and the spacecraft coasts with a velocity vector v = (0, 20, 0) km/s. The space craft passes the position x = (12, 15, 0) km at which time the spacecraft fires its thruster rockets giving it a net force of F = (6 × 104 , 0, 0) N which...
Alice wants to send a plaintext message m = 10 to Bob secretly using RSA public...
Alice wants to send a plaintext message m = 10 to Bob secretly using RSA public key cryptosystem. Bob selects p = 7, and q = 13 with e = 5. You have to perform following tasks: a. Compute and list Bob’s public and private keys. b. Compute the ciphertext that Alice will send to Bob using plaintext message m = 10. c. Recover the actual plaintext from the ciphertext sent by Alice
A proton and an alpha particle (q=+2e,m=4u) are fired directly toward each other from far away,...
A proton and an alpha particle (q=+2e,m=4u) are fired directly toward each other from far away, each with an initial speed of 0.014 c . Part A What is their distance of closest approach, as measured between their centers? Express your answer to two significant figures and include the appropriate units
:) Alice and Bob play the following game: in each round, Alice first rolls a single...
:) Alice and Bob play the following game: in each round, Alice first rolls a single standard fair die. Bob then rolls a single standard fair die. If the difference between Bob’s roll and Alice's roll is at most one, Bob wins the round. Otherwise, Alice wins the round. (a) (5 points) What is the probability that Bob wins a single round? (b) (7 points) Alice and Bob play until one of them wins three rounds. The first player to...
Problem 4 | A modied man-in-the-middle attack on Diffie-Hellman Suppose Alice and Bob wish to generate...
Problem 4 | A modied man-in-the-middle attack on Diffie-Hellman Suppose Alice and Bob wish to generate a shared cryptographic key using the Diffie-Hellman protocol. As usual, they agree on a large prime p and a primitive root g of p. Suppose also that p = mq + 1 where q is prime and m is very small (so p - 1 = mq has a large prime factor, as is generally required). Since g and p are public, it is...
On a planet far far away from Earth, IQ of the ruling species is normally distributed...
On a planet far far away from Earth, IQ of the ruling species is normally distributed with a mean of 103 and a standard deviation of 17. Suppose one individual is randomly chosen. Let X = IQ of an individual. a. What is the distribution of X? X ~ N(,) b. Find the probability that a randomly selected person's IQ is over 85.  Round your answer to 4 decimal places. c. A school offers special services for all children in the...
On a planet far far away from Earth, IQ of the ruling species is normally distributed...
On a planet far far away from Earth, IQ of the ruling species is normally distributed with a mean of 100 and a standard deviation of 16. Suppose one individual is randomly chosen. Let X = IQ of an individual. a. What is the distribution of X? X ~ N( , b. Find the probability that a randomly selected person's IQ is over 116. Round your answer to 4 decimal places. c. A school offers special services for all children...
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT